Recently active
Tobias,It seems that you don't have any problem making the pattern on a flat sheet. You will have to make all the holes on a flat sheet in sheet metal then bend the sheet into place.
Mats,Here's a common problem we've seen over many years when trying to analyze fasteners going through two tubes (image below). The outer tube rotates around the inner tube. This problem would not work, for now, the way I have it set up in Creo Simulate using advanced fasteners. I think I might start this as a new discussion to try and develop the best method to analyze this type of problem. I think you stated you would use beam elements, point-to-point and then connect the ends of the beams with rigid links to surface regions.
1. If you make the text with the Sketching tool, no.2. If you make the text as a cut all the way through the sheet metal, yes.3. If you make the text as a partial cut or extrusion, no.Sheet metal mode requires parallel walls. I'm not a sheet metal expert, but that's the way I see it for now, and maybe an expert will pitch in this discussion. I attached some images.
Creo 3.0 added Account for Stiffness in the preload, so the user only has to make one intervention instead of two, as in Creo 2.0.
Tommaso,The advanced fastener tool includes axial, shear, and bending. Bending was added in Creo 2.0. You can see all three in the run summary window.
Victor,I've uploaded the model to this problem and a screenshot of some results. It's in Creo 3.0.
Tommaso,The edges are parallel, but the component surfaces are not perpendicular to the hole. This requirement must be met in order to use the fastener. Please see attached conditions.
Mats,Are you stating that you create a surface region on the countersink?
Tommaso,Not exactly. I created a flat surface within the countersink, as shown below. This is not a true countersink fastener, but rather a bolted connection with a countersink relief around it. This is why I submitted a Product Idea to create countersink fasteners in Creo Simlulate.
Stig,I'm using Creo Simulate 3.0 (M020), and I'm not experiencing any of these problems. Sorry for the delayed response, but I was out all last week.
When I have a countersink, I have some flat surface at the connecting reference, and that's how I deal with countersinks.
Product Idea to add countersink fasteners.https://www.ptcusercommunity.com/ideas/3783
The two corresponding edges must be parallel. I submitted a Product Idea to add countersink fasteners like Solidworks, but it hasn't received much attention.
Tommaso, Here is a post on the same topic: https://community.ptc.com/t5/3D-Part-Assembly-Design/Simulation-status-Failed-while-calculating/td-p/126281 I haven't seen this problem in Creo 3, but I've seen it in WF4 thru Creo 2.
Erik,I submitted a Product Idea over two years ago to increase the amount of RAM in Creo Simulate. Mark Fisher finally came back with a response, but when I questioned his response, he has yet to answer. I made the argument that increasing RAM was better than not increasing it at all. Please read that last two comments in the attached link.https://www.ptcusercommunity.com/ideas/2424
Victor,I think I've worked this problem before. It looks like a problem out of Dr. Toogood's book, but I'm out of the office this week. There is a dimensioning error in the problem. If you look at the two 2 meter vertical lengths (4 m total), it's not as long as one of the 4 m lengths below it. So I scaled it in Pro|Engineer, and it was around 1.5 m, been a long time since I worked it. But I think I put in all the datum points and used the beam tool with point-to-point connections. You can pick your own cross-section with the beam tool. Creo can do this, as this is a very simple problem to work.
Victor,If you're on maintenace with PTC, you may watch this excellent video on building a truss in Creo Simulate.http://learningexchange.ptc.com/tutorial/788/creating-a-structural-truss-analysis
Most likely it's related to a surface that is folded over itself. Using the diagnostic window, you should be able to identify the surfaces or rounds that are giving you the problem by selecting them. They should highlight the surface or round in the Creo window. Redefine the feature so it does not overlap itself. The surface should have uniform color.
Sagar,To upload files:Reply > Use advanced editor > Attach
sjohonstone,You're welcome. For the last example that I posted, notice that the number of p-loop passes decreased as the number of elements increased. That may not always be the case, but it was for your test model. Since the test model was so small in number of elements, I ran MPA setting at p1-p9, but for larger 3D models (more elements), I would start at p3, to reduce the run time.
sjohnstone,I ran the studies again with MPA at 1% convergence. The previous studies were MPA at 5%. The new 2D runs are:1. Default autoGEM (23 elements)2. AutoGEM control 1 inch max element size (110 elements)3. AutoGEM control .25 inch max element size (1334 elements)I saved all the results under one window, as shown below (easier to view). There is a 6.9% difference between the max stress in the first run and the last run for the hole, and yes, they all converged to within 1%. The convergence can also influence the solution. You cannot plot a convergence curve with SPA (Single Pass Adaptive).
sjohnstone,I ran your test model with my own boundary conditions and mat props, and as you can see in the below images, there is very little change in the solution and convergence. I made three separate 2D runs, 1) with default automesh, 2) autogem set to 1 for element size, 3) autogem set to .25 for element size.Study 1:Study 2:Study 3:
If your model is not classified, and if you're on maintenance, you could submit the model to Technical Support and request that they run the same type of tests. If you can upload it to the Community, I can run it on my PC and provide the results.
Erik,There isn't a way to turn this off with a config option. If you try the config option display_coord_sys and set to No, it doesn't effect the post-processing results. I checked with PTC Technical Support, Case C1256637.
Erik,You're talking about turning off the Coordinate Systems in the Visibilities window permanently with a config option (shown below). I don't know if any way to do this, as I have searched for it myself. I can call tech support, and if there isn't a way to do it, then a Product Idea needs to be submitted.
Already have an account? Login
No account yet? Create an account
Enter your E-mail address. We'll send you an e-mail with instructions to reset your password.