Skip to main content
May 28, 2015 12:32 PM UTC
Question

Re: Fasteners references edges definition error

Mats,

Here's a common problem we've seen over many years when trying to analyze fasteners going through two tubes (image below).  The outer tube rotates around the inner tube.  This problem would not work, for now, the way I have it set up in Creo Simulate using advanced fasteners.  I think I might start this as a new discussion to try and develop the best method to analyze this type of problem.  I think you stated you would use beam elements, point-to-point and then connect the ends of the beams with rigid links to surface regions.

tube_in_tube.JPG

    2 replies

    May 28, 2015 2:15 PM UTC

    In your specific case, you could:

    - in the outside (bolt head), connect the upper end point of the beam with the only edge, since bolt head <-> pipe contact in this side is ideally (i.e. undeformed situation) with the edge only.

    - in the inside, with the same logic as above, you could connect the other beam end point to a circle of the same outside diameter of the nut below edge traced on the inner pipe surface;

    - even better, for both sides, replace the outside edge and inside curve with a surface region around, representing an average contact surface area under the load (->maybe quitedifficult to calculate)

    but more important, be careful that beam theory is valid only for slim beams (length >> section area), while as I see in the screenshot, your bolts are quite squat --> in this case results on bolt (and therefore on pipes too) would not be so precise.

    I already made a FEM analysis on a squat pin and compared its results to beam analysis results and as expected I noticed quite a big difference.

    (depends anyway on your needs)

    hope to be of some help,


    bye

    May 29, 2015 8:57 AM UTC

    Yes, I think this would be a suitable case to model beam elements+links and a temperature load.