Skip to main content

Filter by idea status

Filter by product

6851 Ideas

To develop Automated process for existing Creepage and Clearance tool using xml file creo schematicAcknowledged

1. Describe the ProblemTo develop Automated process for existing Creepage and Clearance tool using xml file creo schematic.Existing Creepage and clearance Tool is time consuming process.It includes lots of manual work, Component definition is manualLots of issues facing when working with big assemblies and complicated modelsFatal errorLots of gaps/ More chances of human errorsAccuracy is low.Analysis time is More.Independent process from system/No linkage with application/user 2. Are you using a workaround?yes we are using this for our E-mobility products.3. What is the use case for your organization?Propose to use a novel approach in existing tool which include the below features: 1. Proposing Automated process with help of Creo schematic input in .xml format to be import in Creepage and Clearance tool 2. 70-80% information can be auto populate and component having high voltage is automatically selected in improved tool 3. Accuracy of analysis is increased with automated flow with .xml 4. This will simplify structure of same in TLA as well 5. Person can run analysis in very advance even while concept level we would be having creepage values to consider in early stage 6. More than 50% Time saving with proposed approach 7. User can select standard that can have predefined values for analysis as per specific application/ High Voltage levels4. What impact does this problem currently have on your organization?This is creating delay in analysis and taking too much time due to fatal error frequent times.

Conductors/Traces via IDX in Creo ParametricAcknowledged

1. Describe the ProblemDescription of Current Behavior: Currently, while Creo Parametric works according to the existing product specifications, there is a significant gap in our ECAD-MCAD collaboration. Our entire ECAD collaboration process relies on the IDX format to track and exchange all design changes. However, while copper information—specifically vias, copper pads, planes, and conductors (traces)—is fully supported on the ECAD side, it is not supported or imported into Creo Parametric within IDX. Currently, Creo Parametric only allows copper information to be brought through a separately generated *.eda file.Proposed Enhancement (Solution): We request an enhancement to the IDX interface within Creo Parametric to fully support the native import and representation of copper information (vias, pads, planes, and conductors) directly through the IDX format. Because all our design changes are exchanged via IDX, it is absolutely essential that conductors can also be exchanged through this same unified process. Users should not be forced to break the workflow and fall back on legacy *.eda files just to access this crucial data. (Note: This has been reported to R&D as SPR 7115263, and a change in functionality is being considered for a future release by Product Management).Business Value & Impact:Unified ECAD/MCAD Collaboration: Since our entire workflow relies on IDX for exchanging all changes, adding conductor support to IDX ensures a single, seamless, and standardized data exchange process.Increased Efficiency & Error Reduction: Eliminates the cumbersome and error-prone workaround of generating, managing, and synchronizing secondary *.eda files just to get copper data into Creo.Downstream Accuracy: Having accurate copper conductors directly in the 3D model via our standard IDX workflow is essential for accurate downstream processes like thermal and structural analyses.2. Are you using a workaround?To bring copper information into Creo Parametric, we currently have to rely on a legacy *.eda file. However, since our ECAD software (like many others on the market) cannot generate *.eda files natively, we are forced into a highly inefficient, multi-step workaround. We first have to export an intermediate IPC file from our ECAD system, which is then used in an additional step to eventually generate the *.eda file required by Creo just to import the copper data.3. What is the use case for your organization?Our organization relies entirely on the IDX format as the single source of truth for all ECAD-MCAD collaboration and change management. Our primary use case is to seamlessly exchange complete PCB design data between our ECAD software and Creo Parametric. We need the precise physical representation of the copper layers and conductors directly in the 3D MCAD environment to perform reliable mechanical clearance checks, as well as accurate downstream structural and thermal simulations. A unified IDX workflow is required to keep both domains perfectly in sync.4. What impact does this problem currently have on your organization?The current limitation severely disrupts our design workflow and creates a massive overhead. To bring copper information into Creo Parametric, we are currently forced to use a legacy *.eda file workaround. However, our ECAD software (like many others on the market) cannot generate *.eda files natively.

Make Update Control RMB Action Available also for Shrinkwrap and Merge/Inheritance features.Acknowledged

1. Describe the ProblemIn Copy Geometry feature I can use the Update Control RMB action to set up the dependency of the feature itself (see pic.)  In a Shrinkwrap feature this menu is not available (see pic.)  As a result, selecting multiple Copy Geometry and External Copy Geometry features allows you to set the update control simultaneously. This capability is not available for Shrinkwrap or Merge/Inheritance features. 2. Are you using a workaround?Edit the definition of each feature (sometimes dozens of features) and set the desired behavior.3. What is the use case for your organization?In certain situations, it would be useful to select all data-sharing features at once (e.g., using the search tool) and set the same update behavior for all of them. This operation is possible in some other CAD systems. Currently, you can select all data-sharing features, but you cannot set the Update Control for those that do not provide the RMB option (e.g., Shrinkwrap).4. What impact does this problem currently have on your organization?This would provide significant time savings when removing all external references from all components in an assembly. In other CAD systems, this operation is already possible. In CATIA, you can “Isolate” one or more components. Going further, it would be highly beneficial to have a command that removes ALL external references from every part belonging to an assembly, both explicit (e.g., Copy Geometry, Shrinkwrap) and implicit (external references embedded within standard features).

Surface Round and ChamferAcknowledged

1. Describe the ProblemAlthough surface references usually are more stable than edge references, when we want to fillet or chamfer all the edges surrounding a surface, we still have to reference at least an edge of the exterior loop of a surface. Some CAD packages (Solidworks, even FreeCAD), allow the user to pick a surface to fillet, instead of the edges of said surface. In Creo, we cannot select the surface, we have to select its external loop of edges, and we can do it with an Edge Chain rule. We select the surface, but have to select at least one edge of the outer loop. Instead of a single reference, we have to provide two. And the edge we pick on the outer loop, is subject to change, so, it's not a stable reference and does not preserve design intent. My proposal, to the possibility to select surfaces, instead of only edge chains in the "Round" and "Chamfer" features. As an alternative, add an additional rule on the "Edge Chain", probably called "Surface Contour" which will prompt the user with a single reference, the surface to fillet or chamfer, or change the behaviour of "Complete loop" to avoid having to select an anchor. (Less desirable this last option due to compatibility reasons with legacy files). If we opt to add a new rule "Surface Contour" instead of changing behaviour of "Complete Loop", this "Surface Contour" rule will also be provided a check-box to ask the user if we wants to also select all the "inner loops" of a surface, since this sometimes is time consuming when a surface has many inner loops to manually select them all with the existing "Complete loops" rule. Besides the check-box to include all the inner loops of the surface, an additional field could be provided to select any loops to exclude from selection.     2. Are you using a workaround?Yes. We have to manually select all edges manually or with the "Complete Loop" rule when possible 8in most cases). The problem with the "Complete Loop" is that it needs to references, and when we only want the outer loop, there is no way to specify it to Creo, we have to manually click on an external edge, which due to design changes, can be deleted, or changed to a weak reference, so, does not preserve design intent for designs prone to many changes. The other disadvantage of the existing "Complete Loop" rule is that when the surface has many inner loops, the user wastes too much time selecting all the loops, and when the design changes, some loops might be added to the surface, but not to the selection process, and other surface loops might be deleted resulting in feature failure.3. What is the use case for your organization?Increase productivity for a common core problem that all the users deal with, specially in designs that are very prone to design changes.4. What impact does this problem currently have on your organization?Difficult to estimate the hours of loss productivity, but this change would greatly increase productivity for all general users, not only on our small team..

Limitation for Color Fills in 2D Figures with Creo Illustrate 12.1.0.0Acknowledged

Please include detailed documentation such as screenshots, images or video.1. What product and version are you running?We are using Creo Illustrate 10.2 and new 12.12. What is the problem?Other than expected (or wished) we misunderstood the What's new feature:"Support for Color Fills in 2D Figures"It is working well for new drawn 2D Geometry - as said ..."Ability to apply a color fill to ellipses, rectangles, and polylines".Sample for created fill areas:But the greatest benefit would be if existing complex Geometry from Source file could be filled, as well just designated areas to mark by the fill.Somehow ... the Fill finding something, but ...... not specific to the wanted fill... limited by not closed filled areas - looks like randomly found by closed 2D lines.very simple example where ellipse found but only partly filled  3. Are you using a workaround? If yes, please describe it.None4. What is the use case for your organization? Describe how your idea would work in context or how it would apply to a practical situation.The fill is perfect to Highlight areas in the documentation Figures, but limited due to need to redraw it and can not use the e.g. complex geometry.5. What impact does this problem currently have on your organization? (Number of users affected, hours of lost productivity, etc.)Can not benefit from new feature.

Improve Full Round capabilities in CreoAcknowledged

1. Describe the ProblemCurrently the only way to create "Full Rounds" in the Found feature is if we select a pair of edge references. There is a specific user case where we want to create a full round, but with the current Creo methology it is not possible, not even in the latest Creo version (12.4), and this use case happens quite frequently. When we are designing "cooling" lines for parts in the molds industry, we frequently need "holes" whose bottom is a full round instead of planar or forming a "V" shape. The hole command only allows this two options, "Flat" and "Drilled" (tiipical 118º or 120º cone tip). Sometimes we use the "extrude" command to make "holes", and afterwards we need to make wither a full chamfer, or a full round at the flat bottom of the exreuded "hole". To increase productivity and avoid design erros or regeneration failures whe we change diameter of the holes, we need a way to apply full rounds to the flat bottom of the holes, but Creo currently does not allow it, since it does not allow selection of a single surface to fillet, it only allows selection of edges. Creo allow creation of full rounds with two almost parallel edge selection that belong to a same surface. But we cannot use this method to apply a full round at the bottom of a flat hole feature or extruded hole, since the two halved of the circular face are nor valid selections to perform a full round. My suggestion is for Creo to detect this cases, when the user selects a single surface (the selector already allos selection of surfaces, but for other use cases (For surface to surface fillet creation, which needs a surface pair). The idea is that if the user selects non adjacent surfaces (mainly planar circularly trimmed surfaces) (the flat portion of the bottom surface of a hole), and the adjacent surfaces of these selected surfaces are cylinders or cones, then it is valid selection to provide a full round or a full chamfer, meaning, to replace the planar face with a spherical half surface. The possibilities of only having to select flat (or conical) faces instead of edges, has the added benefit that the user can be presented with the possibility to create a full round, instead of having to specify its value, since having to manually specify the radius value is prone to errors when the design changes, causeing feature failures, or creating a smaller fillet radius than intended and needed. To have robust design, with designs prone to changes, the user would have to create first an analyse feature to measure the hole radius, and provide a relation to the fillet feature to use the same value. This is time consuming and decreases productivity. We only do it in UDFs, but they cannot be applied in most cases.   2. Are you using a workaround?As a workaround, if we use UDFs, we can "waste" time by creating an analyse feature to measure the hole diameter, and provide a relation to change the fillet radius or chamfer value to half of the hole diameter. For ad-hoc feature creation, this is not possible or wastes too much time, so, what happens is that we measure the value, and assing the said value to the fillet. When the design changes, the hole becomes smaller, the fillet creation will fail, and the user hast to re-specify the correct value. If the hole is changed and gets bigger, there will be a silent error, meaning, Creo will not report it, but the fillet round or chamfer will be incorrect.3. What is the use case for your organization?Increase productivity for a use case that happens quite frequently. This is also a core capability that will increase productivity and better convey design intent for all the Creo users that need this core capability.4. What impact does this problem currently have on your organization?Difficult to estimate the time in hours due to lost productivity.

Native Conversion of Creo "Explode Lines" to Illustrate "Explode Lines"Acknowledged

Please include detailed documentation such as screenshots, images or video.1. What product and version are you running?Creo Illustrate 10.02. What is the problem?Currently, Creo Explode Lines import as static Datum Curves rather than native objects. This lack of associativity forces manual rework as any change to the sBOM structure causes these curves to vanish, requiring illustrators to redraw every single path from scratch. We need the capability to convert Creo Parametric data into native Creo Illustrate objects that persist through sBOM or positional updates.3. Are you using a workaround? If yes, please describe it.No, I have already contacted PTC Support and no usefull workaround was provided. Currently, we have to redraw all the explode lines of our products after they are imported into Creo Illustrate.4. What is the use case for your organization? Describe how your idea would work in context or how it would apply to a practical situation.We frequently restructure the sBOM to create logical service kits, but doing this causes imported Creo Explode Lines (which are only static Datum Curves) to vanish. This forces illustrators to manually redraw every path for every structural change, turning simple updates into hours of redundant work.5. What impact does this problem currently have on your organization? (Number of users affected, hours of lost productivity, etc.)We have 50+ illustrators who waste countless hours on this kind of rework.

Autonumbering in Creo Parametric - Don't Consume Number Unless NeededAcknowledged

Autonumbering in Creo Parametric is not consistently implemented.  In some places Creo displays <auto generated name> and doesn't consume a number from Windchill until the action is completed.  In other places Creo consumes a number immediately, as soon as the related dialog is opened, before any actions have been completed.  (Just opening the dialog and closing it will consume a number.)  Please change this so <auto generated> is displayed everywhere and no number is consumed from the database until it's actually needed (the action is completed.)   Good: Everything works exactly as desired when creating a brand new file in Creo.  No number is pulled from the database until the object has actually been created.   Bad: This falls apart everywhere else.  All of these other actions will pull a number from the database as soon as the dialog is opened: Save As from Creo Assembly - Create New Object Assembly - Replace (even though "Unrelated Component" is not selected) Rename from the embedded browser in Creo   Wasting a number every time one of these other actions is taken is making the whole thing unusable (at least for us.)  Yes, it functions, but it's not acceptable to "waste" 80% of the available numbers.   Note:  There was a previous product idea but it was 'Archived' due to its age.  Unfortunately this problem still exists so this idea was created to replace it (and at the direction of the Community management.)

Assign materials in the Creo Composite Design module with the Ansys GRANTA GatewayAcknowledged

1. Describe the ProblemTo assign materials to our parts in Creo Parametric, we use the Ansys GRANTA Gateway that fills Creo materials attributes in the model. This Gateway is connected through the GRANTA Database where we gather all our organisation materials information. We are starting to use the Creo Composite Design module and in this feature, we can't use materials from the Granta Gateway.  2. Are you using a workaround?We are assigning composite materials through the Creo Parametric materials feature in the Composite feature (see screenshot attached). Therefore we use the PTC Composite materials library and not our Composite materials from our databases in Granta.  3. What is the use case for your organization?We are starting to use the composite module for some real use cases in our organisation and we would like to use the composite materials that are in our Granta databases.4. What impact does this problem currently have on your organization?We can't use the materials that have been characterized by our Materials team in our organisation as the information is stored and updated in the databases in Granta. These materials are all tested in our materials lab and are specific to the products we are designing in our organisation. Therefore, using the PTC common library is not ideal. Today, our designers have to recreate these materials copying the attributes defined in our Granta databases or have to use PTC materials.

Improve the calculated result of projected area to whole partAcknowledged

1. Describe the ProblemCreo Parametric provides an analysis feature "Measure: Area" to measure the area of a projected surface to an assembly. With the help of PTC support it was confirmed that this calculation deviates far more than the expected value of 0.15% as published here. We require a more accurate estimation of projected areas to meet our engineering needs.The deviation is evident when using the Shadow Analysis feature, as demonstrated with a sequence of spheres: even at the highest accuracy settings, the projected area is not calculated precisely.This inaccuracy stems from the calculation method (documented here). To calculate the Projected area of an entire part, a 1000 by 1000 grid is used for the calculation. In contrast, a numerically precise result can only be obtained for single Creo areas. Proposed Solution: If the current grid calculation scheme is retained, allow users to select between a “standard grid size” and a “manual grid size” for projected area calculations, enabling a trade-off between accuracy and speed, as is common in advanced fluid simulations.Provide visual feedback on the chosen grid size directly on the projection plane, helping users assess result quality before calculation.This visulisation helps to indicate whether the grid resolution is sufficient.Currently, no visual feedback is generated at all.The new tool should clearly indicate expected numerical deviations, preventing unexpected discrepancies for users.  (visualisation of workaround, see point 2.) 2. Are you using a workaround?Theoretically, it is possible to define such a single contiguous area as mentioned above by project trimmed edges along an assembly contour. BUT this is a time-consuming and error-prone manual process that is not comparable with the previous GUI (Select assembly, select plane to project, projected area calculated). One realistic example is shown in the above screenshot. The automatically generated silhouette curve often requires extensive manual correction to define the correct projected surface.3. What is the use case for your organization?Accurate projected area values are essential for designing wind load areas and determining the resulting mechanical loads on components.4. What impact does this problem currently have on your organization?Designers and calculation engineers face uncertainty in component dimensioning due to inaccurate projected area calculations. This affects critical input variables for the safety-relevant design of load-bearing structures. Highlighting and addressing this deviation is crucial for improving long-term calculation reliability.