Improve Full Round capabilities in Creo
1. Describe the Problem
Currently the only way to create "Full Rounds" in the Found feature is if we select a pair of edge references.
There is a specific user case where we want to create a full round, but with the current Creo methology it is not possible, not even in the latest Creo version (12.4), and this use case happens quite frequently.
When we are designing "cooling" lines for parts in the molds industry, we frequently need "holes" whose bottom is a full round instead of planar or forming a "V" shape. The hole command only allows this two options, "Flat" and "Drilled" (tiipical 118º or 120º cone tip). Sometimes we use the "extrude" command to make "holes", and afterwards we need to make wither a full chamfer, or a full round at the flat bottom of the exreuded "hole".
To increase productivity and avoid design erros or regeneration failures whe we change diameter of the holes, we need a way to apply full rounds to the flat bottom of the holes, but Creo currently does not allow it, since it does not allow selection of a single surface to fillet, it only allows selection of edges.
Creo allow creation of full rounds with two almost parallel edge selection that belong to a same surface. But we cannot use this method to apply a full round at the bottom of a flat hole feature or extruded hole, since the two halved of the circular face are nor valid selections to perform a full round.
My suggestion is for Creo to detect this cases, when the user selects a single surface (the selector already allos selection of surfaces, but for other use cases (For surface to surface fillet creation, which needs a surface pair).
The idea is that if the user selects non adjacent surfaces (mainly planar circularly trimmed surfaces) (the flat portion of the bottom surface of a hole), and the adjacent surfaces of these selected surfaces are cylinders or cones, then it is valid selection to provide a full round or a full chamfer, meaning, to replace the planar face with a spherical half surface.
The possibilities of only having to select flat (or conical) faces instead of edges, has the added benefit that the user can be presented with the possibility to create a full round, instead of having to specify its value, since having to manually specify the radius value is prone to errors when the design changes, causeing feature failures, or creating a smaller fillet radius than intended and needed.
To have robust design, with designs prone to changes, the user would have to create first an analyse feature to measure the hole radius, and provide a relation to the fillet feature to use the same value. This is time consuming and decreases productivity. We only do it in UDFs, but they cannot be applied in most cases.















2. Are you using a workaround?
As a workaround, if we use UDFs, we can "waste" time by creating an analyse feature to measure the hole diameter, and provide a relation to change the fillet radius or chamfer value to half of the hole diameter. For ad-hoc feature creation, this is not possible or wastes too much time, so, what happens is that we measure the value, and assing the said value to the fillet. When the design changes, the hole becomes smaller, the fillet creation will fail, and the user hast to re-specify the correct value. If the hole is changed and gets bigger, there will be a silent error, meaning, Creo will not report it, but the fillet round or chamfer will be incorrect.
3. What is the use case for your organization?
Increase productivity for a use case that happens quite frequently. This is also a core capability that will increase productivity and better convey design intent for all the Creo users that need this core capability.
4. What impact does this problem currently have on your organization?
Difficult to estimate the time in hours due to lost productivity.
