Recently active
1. Describe the ProblemIn a drawing that details more than one model, such as an assembly with two configurations, the repeat region cannot handle it, with two major disabilities and one minor.No BOM balloons. According to CS102227 you cannot create BOM Balloons for a repeat region using column models. You have to create them by hand, and then they are not parametric.No bulk items. The quantity for bulk items is shown as 1. You cannot alter it with relations and show it as "AR" (As Required), you have to place a note over the 1 to hide it in the R. This is the kind of fakery that we are trying to avoid and should not rely on as a best practice.Adding columns on the edge of a repeat region puts them outside the repeat region. You have to add them inside the edge column, which makes expanding an existing table unnecessarily complicated.Here's an example. But in this example, the workaround chosen was to add a dumb text column to the left of the repeat region, and several more rows of dum
1. Describe the ProblemDisabling assembled component on reference pattern seed feature is impossible.2. Are you using a workaround?Simple reps can be used to workaround in some extent.3. What is the use case for your organization?To be able to use reference patterns for example for fasteners and plugs and being able to freely disable any fastener or plug when creating product variations.4. What impact does this problem currently have on your organization?10-20 users affected. Reference patterns cannot be used effectively. Hours lost yearly around 20 hours.
1. Describe your environment: What is your industry? What is your role in your organization? Describe your stakeholders. We work for Schneider Electric multinational company that specializes in digital automation and energy management. My role in the organization is Mechanical Platform Solutions Architect and our stakeholders are all of our Business representatives who spoke for all company designers.2. What version of Creo Parametric are you currently running?Creo Parametric 8.0.23. Describe the problem you are trying to solve. Please include detailed documentation such as screenshots, images or video.we have a model check configured to review and mark an error if a flexible modeling feautre is present.however there are use cases where we have imported model coming from neutral files or other CAD systems and we want to apply a condition if an imported feature exists it does not mark an error if flexible modeling are founded.there is a similar functionality w
1. Describe the ProblemIn Creo Parametric it can be helpful to have a common required block of relations to drive company standard attributes or calculations. For normal relations and comments ModelCHECK will only check for the existence of a relation or comment. There is no position check. (For solve blocks ModelCHECK does understand order dependance). 2. Are you using a workaround?Manual Checking3. What is the use case for your organization?Checking of models prior to release for compliance to company standards. I want the relations to look like /*Begin Required Common RelationsCDA_CAGE_CODE=CAGE_CODE/*Comment About Contract Number Should Be BelowCONTRACT_NUMBER=CONTRACT_IDENTIFIER/*End Required Common Relations But this will pass /*Begin Required Common Relations/*Comment About Contract Number Should Be Below/*End Required Common RelationsCDA_CAGE_CODE=CAGE_CODE/*Comment About Contract Number Should Be BelowCONTRA
1. Describe the ProblemIn the Piping module, the designer specifies a minimum centerline bend radius in the line stock. However, many hose suppliers specify the minimum inside bend radius of their hose stock. There is no way to directly input inside bend radius as a requirement in the line stock.2. Are you using a workaround?The designer can add the hose's cross-section radius to the centerline radius that is specified in the line stock.3. What is the use case for your organization?The ideal solution would enable the designer to select, in the line stock menu, whether they want to specify inside bend radius or centerline bend radius.4. What impact does this problem currently have on your organization?Our organization uses the piping module for flexible hoses for several components on every engine project. Therefore, all projects in the organization are impacted. The primary impact now is that most designers specify the supplier's inside bend radius as the CL bend radius and therefore h
1. Describe the ProblemWhen working with wire harness routing, we use assemblies for our connectors. These assemblies contain all of the relevant data for the connector (terminals, cavity plugs, etc.).Reference image.If I need to move a connector assembly, there's no option to specifically select an assembly. I first must select a component of the assembly and then navigate to the model tree where I can then select the complete assembly. 2. Are you using a workaround?The only workaround is to use multiple mouse clicks to first select the part, then navigate to the model tree and select the assembly.3. What is the use case for your organization?My idea would place "Assembly" as an option in the dropdown menu. Selecting assembly would then automatically select the entire connector assembly, rather than just a component of the connector assembly.4. What impact does this problem currently have on your organization?This has minimal impact, but would be a really nice addition to make my d
1. Describe the ProblemAnnotation orientation cannot be selected prior to placing GD&T Advisor annotations. If the user desires to have the annotation displayed on a different plane/different orientation than the default, they must manually edit the annotation and move to the desired plane.2. Are you using a workaround?Yes- manually redefining the annotation to preferred orientation after creating it in GD&T advisor.3. What is the use case for your organization?After selecting the feature you want to annotate in GD&T advisor, there would be an additional tab in the ribbon that would allow you to select the orientation plane for your new orientation.4. What impact does this problem currently have on your organization?Slows down designers by making them perform additional operations while creating parts.Status changed to: ArchivedHello,We are archiving your idea as part of a general review. This action is based on the age of your idea and the total number of votes received, a
1. Describe the ProblemAnnotation orientation cannot be selected prior to placing GD&T Advisor annotations. They require post-processing of setting orientations if GD&T Advisor defaults to an orientation that doesn't work for our All combined state.2. Are you using a workaround?Yes- manually redefining the annotation to preferred orientation after creating it in GD&T Advisor.3. What is the use case for your organization?After selecting the feature you want to annotate in GD&T advisor, there would be an additional tab in the ribbon that would allow you to select the orientation plane for your new annotation.4. What impact does this problem currently have on your organization?Slows down designers by making them perform additional operations while creating parts.
1. Describe the ProblemMy family tables utilize many dimensional changes as well as measurements for multiple instances. This can get quite cluttered and difficult scroll horizontally for a long time to find certain columns. Organizational groups or other organizational tools would be very helpful. It would also be helpful if their was a way to locate the FT dimension within the part features.2. Are you using a workaround?No3. What is the use case for your organization?This would help us locate dimensions easier within the family table.4. What impact does this problem currently have on your organization?More time and difficulty when using family table instances
1. Describe the Problem Hi, In Creo, it is not possible to easily copy the name of a component (part or assembly) directly from the Model Tree.Copying a component name is possible only through workarounds. For example, one method: opening the component, selecting Save As, and then copying the name from the File name field. This approach is cumbersome and inefficient. In many workflows, component names need to be copied, for example to paste into documentation, search dialogs, or to re-insert the same component into the assembly using the Assemble command. Adding the ability to copy a component name (only text) directly to the Mini Toolbar in the Model Tree would significantly improve productivity and usability. I believe that this enhancement will increase the usability and efficiency of Creo users.It is a quick win that likely requires only a few hours of development time but has a big impact on usability and efficiency. Thnaks. 2. Are you usi
1. Describe the Problem The Select Related Tree could use several improvements: External references are not currently displayed. It would be very helpful to be able to select a feature/model and also display the external parents / children, Note: external children might only be possible for the currently open assembly or models in session. When working in assemblies, you first need to activate a part before being able to see Direct Parents / Children which is misleading / confusing for users. It's hard to trust the results if you have to remember to activate first. Or at very least the Creo UI should tell the user "Activate the model for more detailed results". When selecting components in the model tree, it would be very helpful if there could be a summary of external references for the selected component. 2. Are you using a workaround?The current Select Related Tree is not very useful without displaying external references since it only provides a p
1. Describe the ProblemWhen constructing a parametric note or dimension it would be helpful to be able to enter dimensions and parameters using a list or graphical method. The dimension and parameter selections would work exactly the same as the tools already available in the "relations" dialoge box.Suggested location for new parameter and dimension selection option boxes. Example legacy "Select Parameter from List" capability in the relations interface.2. Are you using a workaround?Either the user must know how to manually construct a parameter or, they can open the Relations interface, then use the "Insert Parameter Name from List" function there.3. What is the use case for your organization?Parametric notes can help reduce the chances for error as the design develops. Its really easy to type "4X" for a pattern, but that can change with time. It would be helpful if it was easier to construct parametric notes/dimensions to aid in adoption.4. What impact does this problem currently hav
An option should be added to allow users to change and save the default settings in the PDF Export Settings window. It would be nice to be able to change settings such as "Color" to monochrome instead of color or "Fonts" to stroke all fonts instead of use truetype fonts and have that be the default settings. Currently in Creo 2.0 you have to remake these changes every time you open the software.
This topic has not been fixed within the last 25 years so I make another attempt here 😉:When creating a new drawing with the drawing template:You cannot click OK without selecting a 3D model - the button is inactive:There are many use cases where this makes no sense:Import of 2D IGES or DXF data into the drawingA drawing that contains only notes and tablesA user just wants to start a drawing, place the drawing frame but doesn't have the 3D model from his colleague yet.Since using the template is not possible in those scenarios users tend to select "Empty" to activate the OK button. By doing so they don't use our template and therefore don't have any parameters for the drawing frame. This results in Creo asking for a value for every parameter in the drawing frame when you place it thereby overwriting the parameter with simple text making the drawing frame non associative. All because Creo forces you to select a 3D model when creating a drawing from template.Please fix this nuisance onc
If we have provision for saving the Hole Table columns after adding necessary parameters, it can be reused. Now we are in need to add Hole table columns and parameters manually each every time. This is time consuming work.
1. Describe the ProblemOur users prefer to work in Creo in their mother language. This leads to the effect, that the Windchill attribute "PTC_WM_Lifecycle_State" is shown in this local language. But we want to show teh value of this attribute in the drawing always in English language.2. Are you using a workaround?We could use another parameter and create a "translation" operation in 3D relations or drawing program. But this adds possible error possibilities.3. What is the use case for your organization?Our idea is, that there's either a Creo option: E.g. "data_locale" that you can set to define the data locale independent from the application language or there can be a second environment variable next to "lang" e.g. "data_lang" to set the locale there.4. What impact does this problem currently have on your organization?The lifecycle state on our drawing, that should be shown in English language, is shown currently in a different language.Status changed to: ArchivedHello,We are archivin
1. Describe the Problem Company-specific logic added to a UI command using Toolkit function ProCmdBracketFuncAdd can't be removed because there's no corresponding opposite function (as is the case with ProCmdAccessFuncAdd, for example, which has ProCmdAccessFuncRemove as its counterpart).Therefore, you've to resort to a workaround that complicates the program logic of the bracket function. 2. Are you using a workaround?In the bracket function, you've to use conditions to check whether the function should continue to be executed or be aborted.3. What is the use case for your organization?We would like to create a toggle button that allows users to activate (add) and deactivate (remove) a bracket function.4. What impact does this problem currently have on your organization?The absence of a counterpart to ProCmdBracketFuncAdd makes life more difficult for the approximately 10 Toolkit developers in our company.Status changed to: ArchivedHello,We are archiving your idea as part of a general
1. Describe the ProblemCurrently, in the repeat region relations, no drawing parameters or information about the drawing can be references.2. Are you using a workaround?Using parameters stored in the member itself to set flags, rather than automate. Or setting the relations to compare to the string of the drawing number, rather than referencing the drawing number, again, no automation.3. What is the use case for your organization?I need to compare a member parameter to the drawing number to determine sorting and other factors, but that cannot currently be done. It can be done manually, for each drawing, using the workaround, but I want it on the template in a way that works automatically.4. What impact does this problem currently have on your organization?Extra work creating non-parametric data.Status changed to: ArchivedHello,We are archiving your idea as part of a general review. This action is based on the age of your idea and the total number of votes received, as per this announce
1. Describe the Problem During a Creo check-in to Windchill if an item already exists the upload fails with the message "XXXX is not unique". Often this is because a user has downloaded the same vendor STEP file as another user or the user has accidentally assembled CAD from a network drive instead of from the Windchill repository. For our organization, the items that are in Windchill already are exactly the same that a user is trying to check in. There should be an option for "replace with items in Windchill" to make it easier for users to check in the parts without needing to search and add the files to their workspace (remembering to uncheck the "Reuse modified workspace content" box). There should be a drop down option just like there is for the option to remove items from workspace when deleting an item. 2. Are you using a workaround?Yes, searching, adding the items from Windchill to the workspace and remembering to uncheck the "Reuse modified workspace content" box.3. W
1. Describe the ProblemWhile replacing components in assemblies Creo evaluates reference pairing by component interfaces, same name, same history, same parameters, and same ID basis. Creo does not compare references based on geometry. This forces users to make thousands of "no brainer" clicks to reattach references in assemblies form which parts have been replaced.2. Are you using a workaround?Manual clicking of all interfaces is often the only way forward. Sometimes one has to do3. What is the use case for your organization?When creating new versions of components that are used in big or multiple assemblies. When replacing components in assemblies having multiple parent assemblies. When remodeling features for better editability or added features.4. What impact does this problem currently have on your organization?Each user may lose approximately 15 minutes per week without this feature.Status changed to: ArchivedHello,We are archiving your idea as part of a general review. This actio
1. Describe the ProblemModeled which have been modified using the "Dimension Boundaries" tool in the analysis tab do not show as a feature. It would be good if ModelCHECK reported that a modification has been made in the model using the Dimension Boundaries tool ("Dim Bounds" in the help)2. Are you using a workaround?Not telling users about the feature is the current work-around. May remove the button from the Analysis Tab.3. What is the use case for your organization?Dimension Boundaries could be useful for mass or tolerance analysis.4. What impact does this problem currently have on your organization?Currently if a model is checked in with the modifications active, then the derivative files maintain those changes, this could lead to downstream users or manufacturing building components to the wrong dimensions. Model/Drawing dimensions show .250+/-.050, but the part is modeled to .300 or .200 because Dimension Boundaries has been used.Status changed to: ArchivedHello,We are archivin
1. Describe the ProblemWhen the Dimension Boundaries feature is used and active, there is currently no indication in the model tree. The risk is that an analysis could easily be left active in a production model.There should be some visual indication in the model that the dimensions have been altered using the Analysis -> Dimension Boundaries tool (referenced as Dim Bounds in help). An analysis feature in the model tree would be helpful, (This would also be helpful for turning on and off the analysis, or having different analysis scenarios)Also highlighting of the alerted surfaces would also be helpful. One color for more material another for less material. Or, one color for upper boundary, and another for lower boundary.2. Are you using a workaround?Not telling users about the capability.3. What is the use case for your organization?When the Dimension Boundaries feature is used and active, there is currently no indication in the model tree. The risk is that an analysis could easi
1. Describe the ProblemWhen creating an Excel Analysis, there are two buttons, New, and Load. If you do not have an existing worksheet, the process is:NewIt opens an excel sheetSave (saves as xlsx)CloseLoadChange file type filter from .xls to AllLocate, or realize you have no idea where you saved it and start overIt opens the excel sheetPTC has confirmed that this is the expected behavior. But why are these not one step? If you create a new sheet for use in this new analysis (which doesn't already have one), why isn't it loaded immediately? You'll notice that the results of New and Load are the same, the sheet is open. The only difference is the buttons are not enabled after New, only after Load. It feels redundant and confuses people. The IdeaWhen there's no Excel sheet already loaded, and one is created, load it.While you're at it, fix the default file type filter, which is still .xls2. Are you using a workaround?Am I using a workaround? Just following the confusing roundabout proces
Please include detailed documentation such as screenshots, images or video.1. What product and version are you running?Creo Parametric 7.0.8.02. What is the problem?Mass tolerance is estimated not calculated- Creo mass does not have the ability to show maximum material condition and minimum- ie max mass and min mass. Creo Parametric's dimension boundary tool does not understand that for the mass to be maximum, the external dimensions must be max and the internal dimensions must be min.3. Are you using a workaround? If yes, please describe it.Estimation4. What is the use case for your organization? Describe how your idea would work in context or how it would apply to a practical situation.Would allow all parts to have a Max, Min and nominal mass (and also a mid limit mass- ie for machining of non symmetric tolerances)5. What impact does this problem currently have on your organization? (Number of users affected, hours of lost productivity, etc.)No-one trusts Creo's mass, this is one iss
1. Describe the ProblemMy idea here is that during Hole Festure user should be able to add more axis if the holes are the same shape2. Are you using a workaround?each hole need to be made separate3. What is the use case for your organization?low4. What impact does this problem currently have on your organization?lowStatus changed to: ArchivedHello,We are archiving your idea as part of a general review. This action is based on the age of your idea and the total number of votes received, as per this announcement.You can always post a new idea with all the details required in the form.Thank you for your participation.
Already have an account? Login
No account yet? Create an account
Enter your E-mail address. We'll send you an e-mail with instructions to reset your password.