Skip to main content

Filter by idea status

Filter by product

6851 Ideas

Make pattern table editing fully compatible with ExcelArchived

Editing Creo Pattern Tables in Excel should be as easy as editing Creo Family Tables in Excel.  There is a config option "part_table_editor=excel" that can make editing a pattern table easier than Pro/Table (the default editor) or a text editor like notepad.  However, this config option simply sends the default .PTB file to Excel.  Now when you try to save any changes to the .PTB file, Excel will offer you several options to save this file in another location or another format (.XLSX) instead of just saving back to the .PTB file in your working directory.  If you have successfully chosen the correct option to save the file (see examples below), you next have to close Excel.  Excel will prompt you AGAIN to save the file (even though you just did)!  If Creo would simply start the process of editing the pattern table by using a .XLS file, Excel would have no concerns about what format to save to.  Note that pressing the “Edit in Excel” button in a Family Table does exactly that (opens a .XLS file).  See below for examples. How editing a pattern table works today (in PTC Creo Parametric 4.0 F000 and Excel 2016)  Set the config option as shown.Create a table driven pattern and edit the table (Excel should open).Make a change to the table and press Save in Excel.  I have circled the correct choice.Close Excel.  A second prompt to save appears.  I have circled the correct choice.Now you can return to Creo and complete the pattern feature.If you failed to select the correct options above you will end up making changes that don't save, or create extra Excel files on your hard drive that you don't need.How saving a pattern table should work! (Using the current Family Table function as an example)  This is the proposed product idea.Set a config option (new or existing) or provide a button to edit in Excel like in the Family Table editor.Create a table driven pattern and edit the table in Excel.  Note the file format underlined.Make a change to the table and press Save in Excel.  The file is saved with no confusing prompt.Close Excel.  Excel closes with no confusing prompt.Complete the pattern feature.I frequently get users complaining that they have wasted a significant period of time attempting to save changes to the file in the right format and location to keep the changes.

Creo Simulate installationAcknowledged

Please include detailed documentation such as screenshots, images or video.1. What product and version are you running? Creo 8 to Creo 102. What is the problem?Since Creo 8 was introduced, when installing Creo Parametric,  the tick box to install Creo Simulate has been disabled so Creo Simulate does not install unless you tick the box. This is the opposite behaviour of earlier versions where the Creo Simulate installed by default as this box was ticked.  3. Are you using a workaround? If yes, please describe it. Tick the box!4. What is the use case for your organization? Describe how your idea would work in context or how it would apply to a practical situation. We provide Technical Support for PTC  products and the change in behaviour has caught out many customers, especially those upgrading from a version lower than Creo 8 who did not expect this change. We believe Simulate should install by default unless the customer decides they don’t want it installed. Especially as almost everybody has access to the application as Creo Simulate Elite is included with a Creo Design Essentials license5. What impact does this problem currently have on your organization? (Number of users affected, hours of lost productivity, etc.)This has caused a lot of hours in lost productivity for many of our customers who have then had to go back to the installation media to install Simulate. This week alone, we have had reports of 180 users being affected after upgrading to Creo 10 from an earlier version where Simulate installed by default. To say they have been frustrated is an understatement.

Motion envelope: Add datum features from contributing partsAcknowledged

Please include detailed documentation such as screenshots, images or video.1. What product and version are you running?Currently creo 7.0.10, soon creo 9.0.8.2. What is the problem?Motion envelope functionality delivers a quick faceted surface as a result. When created, it consists only of geometry and the datums included in its startpart.It would be great to enable creo to copy datum features (mostly axes, datum planes) from relevant, contributing parts into the motion envelope. They will be useful to place a motion envelope- model into a different assembly. This action should be done directly in "CREATE MOTION ENVELOPE"-UI.3. Are you using a workaround? If yes, please describe it.It is possible to use e.g. like copy geom, but this would take longer than select datums during creation.4. What is the use case for your organization? Describe how your idea would work in context or how it would apply to a practical situation.-Time saving (1. while creation,...2. while assembling into another assembly)- Better data quality as assembly placement definition would be more precise as more elements would be incuded- Optional: Better data (2) quality as resulting model could deliver information, how it was made (more elements would be incuded) Please take a look at my simple example:The aim of this idea is to select an add both axes marked with arrows from motion skeleton (or further parts) while creating the motion envelope.  Of course, more complicated assemblies can deliver more relevant datums.   Resulting motion envelope (as it is currently): Depending from its placement, only default datums coming from startmodel are available. The rest is just geometry.  Resulting envelope should look like this: 5. What impact does this problem currently have on your organization? (Number of users affected, hours of lost productivity, etc.)We are an automotive OEM with >500 users plus external suppliers worldwide.See point 4.: faster, better & more information in motion envelope) 

Motion Envelope Improvement IdeasAcknowledged

I've been working with motion envelopes a lot over the last several years.  This is an incredibly useful tool and my organization creates and uses them frequently.  However, they're difficult to create, difficult to use, and difficult to update.  It's time PTC gave this tool an overhaul with the end-users in mind. Ribbon toolbarReplace the pop-up dialogue box with a ribbon based menu.Separate this from the Playback tool.This is where I should be able to select mirror planes, body options, frame of reference options, output options, etc.More envelope output optionsOption to export a separate mirror part instead of, or in addition to, the regular envelope part.Option to add a mirrored envelope to the same body as the regular envelope or add it to a separate body.An ability to select the mirror plane.Option to export and assemble the envelope to the mechanism assembly it came from.Option to update an existing envelope if it was associated to the mechanism model in this way.Aligned output options between MDX's envelope tool and BMX's Motion Analysis tool.BMX's Motion Analysis tool has the ability to create an envelope feature directly in the feature tree of the mechanism it was generated from.MDX's envelope tool can't do this. It only exports to the startup folder.Both tools should have the same output capabilities.Change the frame of referenceAdd an ability to change what reference frame (coordinate system) the envelope uses.Currently, the top level coordinate system, or the ground, of the assembly is used. There's no option to change it.I want to be able to change the coordinate system/reference frame used and have the resulting envelope represent the motion of parts with respect to it, not the ground.This is similar in concept to a "paper part" in the Trace Curve tool where the paper part serves as the frame of reference for the motion.I know of at least two Pro/Workarounds© to do this, but they're labor intensive and I don't want to have to use them. I want Creo to do this for me.See this post from 2010 (@PAULKORENKIEWIC): https://community.ptc.com/t5/Analysis/mechanisms-trace-curves-and-designing-the-largest-parts/m-p/38...Add a smoothing functionAll envelopes have jittery facets that shouldn't be there.Even flat surfaces have raised and recessed facets.  And because of how Creo merges coincident surfaces into a single surface, this seems to be a cause of export failures.An optional smoothing operation should be added to the envelope tool. The user should be able to turn this option on or off with the understanding that smoothing adds computation time.Sharp edges should be preserved.OR just make the envelope tool better at generating smoother, less jittery surfaces without an added function.See my post here: https://community.ptc.com/t5/Analysis/Motion-Envelope-Refinement/td-p/199024Add an option to update existing motion envelopesCurrently, envelopes are stand-alone objects with no connection to the mechanism model they were generated from.Methods for updating an existing envelope depends on its part type:If an envelope was created as a "Part", then the only way to update it is to manually overwrite it with a new envelope which is time consuming and cumbersome.If an envelope was created as a "Lightweight Part", then you have the same option of overwriting as with a "Part" type envelope, but also by copying and pasting the "facet" object. Still time consuming and cumbersome.There should be a way to update existing motion envelopes via the motion envelope creation dialogue box, regardless of the part type or other options selected (mirror solid, mirror body, mirror part, etc.)This could be an option in the envelope tool which the user can choose in order to link the created envelope to the mechanism model it was generated from.Envelopes which have been linked to their generating mechanism would then have the ability to be updated later.Add an ability to create compound motion envelopes directlyCurrently, the motion envelope tool can only process one analysis file at a time.If a compound envelope is needed, then the user must create one envelope, assemble it into the mechanism, and then create a second envelope using the first one. Time consuming and cumbersome.You could generate a compound envelope with a single motion path, but this would not capture the entire possible range of motion and this becomes extremely cumbersome with more than two DOF's.The envelope tool should have the ability to process two analyses at the same time in order to generate a compound motion envelope in one go.Order of precedence matters when creating compound envelopes (which analysis is used 1st, 2nd, 3rd, etc.) so the user should have the ability to specify this or more ideally, Creo should automatically detect the correct sequence.Add debugging toolsWhen an envelope fails to export, what do I do? Where is the problem geometry? What are possible solutions? Currently, the user is on their own.If I was able to export a part-type envelope without the solidification feature then that could be a way to get past an output error, do the export, open it in Creo, and attempt to repair it manually with the IDD.The Invert Triangle Pairs tool is effective at resolving export problems, but it's difficult to tell where problem areas are.When Fix Triangle Pairs is started, mesh statistics should be plotted on the previewed envelope and color coded.Better yet, give an option to have Creo attempt to repair bad geometry.Better yet, make this automatic when an export fails. Creo attempts to fix suspicious geometry and attempts to export again. If it fails again then it prompts the user.But if Creo is able to identify and fix bad geometry, then why should there be an error in the first place?Enable edge display for envelope previews. Currently, you can only see shaded with no edge display.Putting this here since displaying edges during the preview could help the user ID problem areas.The only immediately obvious way to see the envelope edges when troubleshooting a bad envelope is to export a lightweight part.However, you can see the edges when you enter the Invert Triangle Pairs tool.So it is possible to display them during the preview. So let the user control that with the regular edges/no edges display option.Creo should detect if an exported envelope is going to fail upon solidification.And it should tell the user where/why so the user can fix the problem with Fix Triangle Pairs if Creo can't itself.Add envelope statisticsThe number of "triangles" is reported when an envelope is created and that's it.What's their average size?How long did it take to generate the envelope?How many triangles have a good aspect ratio and how many are warped and how severely?Plot the statistics on the previewed envelope as color coded values for aspect ratio, etc.This could be a tool for debugging, help with spotting problem areas.The Motion Analysis tool (BMX)Envelope creation by this BMX tool seems to take much longer than the MDX toolLet's speed it up, please. The ability for this tool to put an envelope quilt in the feature tree of the mechanism it was generated from is too valuable for this slowdown to happen.RegenRequestWhen the analysis feature is changed from "Always" to "Read Only", the envelope quilt feature should be retained. Currently, it disappears.  If it was retained, then publish geometry can still reference itBetter yet, this tool should be able to export a standalone envelope quilt feature that exists independently of the analysis feature that it came from, but still be able to be updated by it.Component SelectionComponent selection for the envelope ignores assemblies and grouped parts.  In order to select the parts contained within them you must select them all individually.MDX's envelope tool at least allows the selection of assemblies.Update IntervalHow does this work, exactly?  Documentation is not clear.http://support.ptc.com/help/creo/creo_pma/usascii/index.html#page/model_analysis%2Fbemod%2FTo_Create...At first, I thought it was overriding the frame rate in the mechanism analysis definition.  But that's not the case.Then I thought it was how frequently the graphical display was being updated. But that's not the case either.It appears that this controls how frequently the measures are updated.Can we get better documentation of this?Better documentationThe accuracy of an envelope depends on shading quality and the absolute size of collected objects in addition to the envelope accuracy settingNowhere in the help files is it mentioned that shading quality affects envelope accuracy.Is this an error? I've never encountered the parts below in formatted in bold comic sans.http://support.ptc.com/help/creo/creo_pma/usascii/index.html#page/simulate/mech_des/results/ToCreate...1) Click <symbol>. The first time you create a motion envelope with a result set, a message box appears for you to confirm that you want to create a frame file named result_set_name.fra.2) Click Yes. The Create Motion Envelope dialog box opens."About Motion Analysis"http://support.ptc.com/help/creo/creo_pma/usascii/index.html#page/model_analysis%2Fbemod%2FAbout_Mot... This page says this tool can create "A graphical display of the motion envelope" which is true.However, it does not mention that the tool can actually create an envelope feature.This is a huge oversight since the ability to create an envelope feature inside the mechanism it came from is huge.  This is a way to automatically update envelopes instead of the manual way via MDX's envelope tool.http://support.ptc.com/help/creo/creo_pma/usascii/index.html#page/model_analysis%2Fbemod%2FTo_Create...This page is the only place that mentions the ability to create an envelope feature and it does so only indirectly and in passing.Motion Analysis Update Interval DocumentationThe following two pages have slightly different descriptions about what the Motion Analysis update interval does.  They both say this controls how frequently the "graphical results" are displayed.What exactly does "graphical results" mean?  In my experience, the graphics window is updated with every frame as per the analysis definition, regardless of that this update interval is set to.http://support.ptc.com/help/creo/creo_pma/usascii/index.html#page/model_analysis%2Fbemod%2FTo_Create..."Update interval—Enter the number of frames between two update events. This number determines how often the system updates the graphical results."http://support.ptc.com/help/creo/creo_pma/usascii/index.html#page/model_analysis%2Fbemod%2FTo_Create..."Update interval—Enter the number of frames between two update events. This number determines how often the system updates the graphical results of the computation."  1. Describe your environment: What is your industry? What is your role in your organization? Describe your stakeholders.Industry:  wheeled machineryRole:  product engineerStakeholders:  Every end-user who uses this tool and every designer who designs parts around other moving parts and depends on accurate and up-to-date motion envelopes2. What version of Creo Parametric are you currently running?Creo 7.0.4.1Windchill 12.0.0.43. Describe the problem you are trying to solve. Please include detailed documentation such as screenshots, images or video.Generally speaking, the problem we need to solve is the difficult and inefficient process of creating and updating motion envelopes.Refer to the above text for all the detail you need.4. What is the use case for your organization?Every organization that creates motion envelopes would benefit from improvements to this tool, not just mine.5. What business value would your suggestion represent for your organization?Time saved inefficiently operating the program which can instead be spend on design work

Allow for "Add Model" within a drawing to reference an embedded model within an existing assemblyAcknowledged

Please include detailed documentation such as screenshots, images or video.1. What product and version are you running?Creo 9.0.8.0 2. What is the problem? Reference:  Ticket - 17240546 Article - 388493 There are use-cases where we embed submodels into an assembly using the relatively new "Inseparable Assemblies" functionality. Predominantly this happens when we are buying an assembly with multiple subparts. There are situations, when creating a drawing of this assembly, that we want to highlight a specific submodel in a separate view. We can not add that embedded submodel as a new model. It would be great if we can allow for embedded models as well, if the assembly in question is already in another view.   In addition, if a drawing already exists with a specific view of a part, embedding that part in the assembly keeps a copy of it for the drawing view or causes issues when opening the drawing. There should be a better process. If the idea is to embed the object, the drawing should be updated accordingly. 3. Are you using a workaround? If yes, please describe it.For a new drawing: We are using simplified reps and component display in the drawing. However, users are confused why functionality doesn't seem to work. For an existing drawing: We need to delete the view, recreate it, and rename the old model to DO_NOT_USE. This is a big pain.4. What is the use case for your organization? Describe how your idea would work in context or how it would apply to a practical situation.We would design a subassembly that is being purchased as one object. All submodels would be embedded. We would then have one drawing of this object, with different views for some of the embedded models. Users would be able to use the current functionality as-is, without being confused or having to redo lots of work. 5. What impact does this problem currently have on your organization? (Number of users affected, hours of lost productivity, etc.)This would allow for users to embrace the Inseparable Assembly functionality without needing to redo logs of work or not understand all of the intricacies involved. About 100 users.

Assembly family table Y/N configuration looses relations with partsAcknowledged

 1. What product and version are you running?Creo 8.0.42. What is the problem?We have encountered an issue with assemblies configured with Family table (components Y/N) function.Let’s say you create an assembly with two parts (A,B) which both are referenced to the assembly datum planes. The two instances where only A or B are shown are good.But if you set up the assembly so that part B is referenced to part A (which is normal in an assembly) when you then open the instance for part B an empty file will open.PTC support said that this works to spec as creo does not load the first part in and therefore does not show the second part in the Model tree.3. Are you using a workaround? If yes, please describe it.There is no workaround, at the moment the technical designer has to be careful when he configures such family tables. Which is hard as the assemblies can be quite big.4. What is the use case for your organization? Describe how your idea would work in context or how it would apply to a practical situation.From the family table configured assembly we decide which parts are needed for the top assembly. 5. What impact does this problem currently have on your organization? (Number of users affected, hours of lost productivity, etc.)Family table Y/N parts functionality does not give warning to user when it is not showing a part which it should, therefore users cannot rely on it.