Skip to main content

Filter by idea status

Filter by product

6851 Ideas

Add a way to prevent views from moving after changesArchived

We rely heavily on drawing compare to keep track of changes to a drawing and validate what hasn't changed. We have found an issue where if you have a drawing and skeletons, components, or geometry changes such that the view border or model border changes the view will shift. This causes drawings to drastically change when skeletons update, and countless hours have to be taken to fix the drawing views. So there should be a function/preference to either prevent views from moving and/or to prevent hidden items from affecting view locations. If you have the origin set to view center, the view will shift to re-center based on the new outline. This means shifting views and related annotations. If you have the view set to base off an unchanging item, like CSYS, the view will stay put, but only if you change this when you make the view initially. If you change this afterwards it will shift and you'll have to fix it anyways. Annotations will still move based on the size of the new border.If you have a partial view, it will shift the view based on the theoretical view boundary for the entire model, not the boundary of the partial view. There is "lock view movement", but this only prevents you the user from moving it, if the models change, or origin changes it will still shift the view. Here's another extreme example that I used to test the results from a PTC support ticket and verify how the views were changing. The response from them was "Works as specified". (Case 12653660)On the following sample part- All the Red Flags are related to the view. All the blue flags are not related to the view. Dimensions are all model dimensions.I added a large piece that would alter the size of the view so it would be clear what would move. Original part is marked in grey.It’s a bit difficult to see, but the blue flags are all lined up in their original orientation around the view center. They’re not lined up with the original view geometry. The view stays centered relative to the overall center. it’s not based on say the CS0. Even if the view movement is locked it will still re-center because it doesn’t see that as a move. The red ones and dimensions moved proportional to the size of the view and also moved with the view based on how the view changed. If the view expanded to the right, the flags expanded to be equally spaced along that side of the view. So I’ve found the followingView associated symbols, and dimensions will scale relative to the overall size of the view, even if those individual features didn’t changeViews will adjust so that the center point is still at the center of the original view, this includes some changes to the skeletons Non-associated symbols or annotations will remain in the location that they were placed (though everything around them could change)Datum features on a skeleton will not update view sizeShapes and sketches on a skeleton will update a view size even if not visibleChanging View Origin from Center to a picked location will move that picked point to the center location, or sometimes off the pageLock view movement only locks manual user movement