Skip to main content
Nov 13, 2017 6:05 AM UTC
Under Consideration

table with repeat region in 3D

Related products:Creo Parametric

Hi,

 

in optic of MBD, it was useful to have the capabilities to create some table in 3D with Repeat Region (with the same capabilities of the 2D)

 

table.jpg

 

 

 

27 replies

Nov 10, 2022 10:32 PM UTC

Im excited to see this thread.  I wonder If anyone is willing to make a google document or running list of missing functionality with respect to MBD? 

 

Bart Brejcha

Design-engine.com  

Jan 3, 2023 7:54 AM UTC

Hi @Mfridman

 

Wish you a Happy New Year...!!!

 

It is regarding the table functionality to be available in the 3d Part / Assembly Mode. I had a posted my comments a year back but trying to follow up to understand if we are really considering this scenarios and do we have a timeline defined for this functionality to be available for everyone to use  

 

Not having this functionality is a show stopper for the MBD/MBE (Digital thread across the organization) 

Having a simple table will also help

 

When I was typing my requirements in the comment I could see table functionality are available for this post too and not available in Creo

 

It will be good have a simple table like this 

slandge_0-1672731817427.png

 

 

GENERAL MBD TABLE PLATFORM-- Choosing where new tables should be created
-- Resizing table columns or rows to content
-- Adding semantics from table rows to model geometry ability to add
-- Manually supporting movement or updating movement of table
-- One click update of table contents (where the contents are not parameter based)
 
-- Able to add rows and columns for the table
-- Adding Text Note in the Cell
-- TABLES CREATED WITH TEMPLATE
-- Copy paste table from one combination state to other combination state
 

TABLE TYPE: REVISION HISTORY TABLE 1
Inserting Symbols in the Cells
- Merging of cells of the table
- Merge Rows
- Merge Columns

Auto BOM ballooning to the parts in the assemblies after generating the table

 

 

Good Have

- Auto BOM ballooning to the parts in the assemblies after generating the table

- Parameters for the Parts
- Parametric BOM table for assemblies
- Assign parameters to the Cells and Populate Cell Information

 

- Adding Windchill link of the part to track the revision and updates
- Adding link of Specification Documents in the part chart (Specification Present in Windchill)

 

 

Jan 3, 2023 9:41 AM UTC

Hi @slandge ,

Thank you for summarizing your requirements.

I have one comments about the request to be able to add semantics from the table to model geometry (surfaces): The way I see this, table is not defined as an annotation that carries semantic info like geometrical tolerance or a dimension. as a matter of fact there are also no specifications about tables in MBD in the detailing standards. The standards describes tables only for drawings.

 

I believe that tables are essentially a container of information that organizes the data in a tabular form. This means that the rows/columns themselves are not the one that needs to be assigned with semantic references. 

I believe that the main requirement/use case here is for someone to be able to highlight some geometry/surfaces/other annotations when selecting a specific table row/column/cell in the table. This is mostly a use case for human consumption of the data. at least for now.

Please confirm my understanding

 

As it goes for the timing for introducing tables for MBD, this enhancement is indeed being considered for implementation.

At this point in time I cannot provide a hard commitment for a specific release, however I can say that I hope to be able to introduce it in the short term. It will not be included in Creo 10, but possibly in one of the follow-up releases

 

Best Regards,

Michael 

Mar 29, 2023 7:17 PM UTC

Hi @Mfridman ,

 

In my experience the use case for tables is different than your example of "...highlight some geometry/surfaces/other annotations when selecting a specific table row/column...".  Our primary use case is when tackling an MBD TDP where we need to detail wiring harnesses, piping, and similar which are normally handled within a drawing table.  This cannot be done with current annotations.  Additionally, we have seen TDPs with the requirement to present a BOM (not a model tree) in a presentation state.

 

V/R,

 

Mar 30, 2023 6:44 AM UTC

Hi @AW47500 

Thank you for your feedback.

Indeed there are many different kind of use cases for tables, my example above was just one of them.

Regarding your use case of wiring harnesses/piping etc. - may I assume that in this case you are currently doing that using repeat regions (instead of manual tables)?

Mar 31, 2023 6:41 PM UTC

@Mfridman ,

 

Correct, using repeat regions.

Apr 2, 2023 6:06 AM UTC

Thanks for confirming @AW47500 

Dec 5, 2023 2:19 PM UTC

Please include detailed documentation such as screenshots, images or video.

1. What product and version are you running?
Creo Parametric 9.0


2. What is the problem?

As for 2D drawings you might want to add a table in a view but that only possible through a symbol which is time consuming to set up

3. Are you using a workaround? If yes, please describe it.
Create a symbol for each table needed

4. What is the use case for your organization? Describe how your idea would work in context or how it would apply to a practical situation.

In the active combined state just click to add a table - define it as in 2D and place it 

5. What impact does this problem currently have on your organization? (Number of users affected, hours of lost productivity, etc.)
Make the work on 3d drawings more effecient

Dec 5, 2023 3:34 PM UTC
Status changed to: Clarification Needed

Hi @PrebenJ!


Thank you for publishing your idea.


However, you give the bare minimum of information. The more details and context you give to document your idea, the better. Think about ways to educate and convince other Community members to support your idea and present your case to the product management team for consideration.

Here are a few examples of well documented ideas:

Make Shrinkwrap quality more scalable to data size... - PTC Community

Improve/fix the sheetmetal mirror feature - PTC Community

[Eztol] Rename action not synchronous in Eztol - PTC Community


Please elaborate within the next two weeks.

Additionally, I invite you to check out this topic where PTC executives explain product managers' approach to customer ideas and input for product roadmaps.

Dec 6, 2023 4:07 PM UTC
Hello,
 
This idea has been merged with another idea from user PrebenJ.
The votes are combined.
 
Thanks for your participation!
Feb 5, 2024 3:39 PM UTC

@Mfridman 

Greetings...!!!

Hope your doing good...!!!

Sorry for the late reply, was away from this for a while. Adding my comments in Blue 

 

I have one comment about the request to be able to add semantics from the table to model geometry (surfaces): The way I see this, table is not defined as an annotation that carries semantic info like geometrical tolerance or a dimension. as a matter of fact there are also no specifications about tables in MBD in the detailing standards. The standards describe tables only for drawings.--

  • Agree with your point but the Manufacturing team who operates on the shop floor needs to consume the information to manufacture a part. 
  • Having a Semantic table will always be a value add which will help to analyze the part or assembly very easily and review meeting will be very easy using PTC tools like Creo View and Creo Parametric  

 

I believe that tables are essentially a container of information that organizes the data in a tabular form. --- >

  • Hundred percent right and also provides the Product manufacturing information with links to the Standards and Specifications  .
  • Information about the parent and child parts like 
    • Raw Part and its different colors (Colors can be 10 to 20 also . So table is needed to add all this information on a MBD part )
    • Raw part with Specification, - Material , Colour, etc 
    • MBD Assembly - If Table is provided in assembly mode - Balloons can be generated which Quality and Supplier vendors can see that information 

This means that the rows/columns themselves are not the one that needs to be assigned with semantic references. 

I believe that the main requirement/use case here is for someone to be able to highlight some geometry/surfaces/other annotations when selecting a specific table row/column/cell in the table. This is mostly a use case for human consumption of the data. at least for now.

Please confirm my understanding  ----- >

  • Consumption of Data is important inhouse or when it is sent to suppliers. 
  • Revision Table to track what has changed in the present revision and earlier release is important for the people who are working on the shop floor 
    • Teams like Buyers, Manufacturing Quality , Tooling etc. When they export Creo Parametric data into creo view they will need see all this  information to consume the MBD data and manufacture a part on the shop floor 
  • Highlight the surface or geometry will be too good and you will save huge manual efforts and Users will be happy to use PTC products extensively 

 

As it goes for the timing for introducing tables for MBD, this enhancement is indeed being considered for implementation.---

  • We are waiting for this functionality to be implemented as this become a show stopper in our organisation for MBD 

At this point in time I cannot provide a hard commitment for a specific release, however I can say that I hope to be able to introduce it in the short term. It will not be included in Creo 10, but possibly in one of the follow-up releases

 

 

Michael we are moving to Creo 10 and we will be happy to have this functionally in upcoming version that will be helpful not for our organization but for all the organisation world wide. Looking forward to this 

 

Regards

Sandip Landge