Skip to main content
Jul 8, 2012 3:05 AM UTC
Implementation In Progress

Remove the limit of 31 characters in creo file name

Related products:Creo Parametric

31 characters are not enough for design. This limit sometimes is driving customer crazy. For CATIA the limit of file name is 81 characters.

87 replies

Apr 20, 2017 1:10 AM UTC

We definitely know there are a large number of users highly interested in making model names less restrictive.  It's just a question of balancing it against other potential projects that also have strong demand.

Apr 20, 2017 8:13 AM UTC

So, please tell me other project which are waiting so long for any realization. In my opinion it is the problem keeping such important long-term enhancements always on the list and give them a priority.

Apr 21, 2017 4:56 AM UTC

I agree.

We would like to know, what is more important than this highly important enhancement.

This is just a poor approach towards addressing customer needs.

Apr 21, 2017 12:19 PM UTC

This has become a no win situation for Matthew now.    There is no way PTC will divulge an enhancement priority list.

The current method that users can influence the direction of the software is by working groups. See Working Groups - What you need to know

This is a new process and I believe is replacing the technical committees.

Apr 21, 2017 4:28 PM UTC

Perfect job for a junior programmer to tackle. They will learn the code quickly as they go through the millions of lines to determine which arrays need to be expanded for a larger file name. Also don't forget all of the Windchill code that will be need to work with the Creo expanded filenames. ☺

Apr 22, 2017 4:32 AM UTC

Stephen hit the nail on the head here, and that's why I didn't respond earlier.  It's not my place to talk outside PTC about enhancement prioritization or work in progress or future plans.  If anyone does that, it's the product managers, and they generally don't.  And getting into details of why we implemented project X and Y but not project Z is just a morass that would leave no one happy.

Apr 24, 2017 12:12 PM UTC

The current method that users can influence the direction of the software is by working groups. See Working Groups - What you need to know

The official way is supposed to be the product ideas here on this community.  See Idea Submission Process.  Notice that there is no mention of technical committees or working groups. Unfortunately most of these product ideas seem to get ignored by management (or at least not responded to.)

Just once I would like to see a new major release that only includes bug fixes.  Between the existing product ideas here on the community and the thousands of open SPRs there are more than enough things to feed multiple new releases.  I wish PTC would focus less on the next big thing and more on just cleaning up what's already there..

Apr 24, 2017 12:37 PM UTC

Bug fixes don't bring in new sales, they only make users better. New sales drive the enhancements.

I agree that a push for a cleaner software would be nice. I seem to remmeber that release 18 or 19 was a lot like a big bug fix. I may be mis-remembering though.

A product idea rarely sells itself. They need an *advocate* to bring the most desirable ones to the top. That used to come in the form of TC's. I'm assuming from the chatter that TC's are being replaced by working groups. From the list of working groups at the link, it doesn't appear that much is happening.

*can also be read as the customers with the most licenses* or biggest accounts (paid maintenance dollars plus potential future sells)

^I've used sale and sell too many times....I'm sure I've gotten one or all wrong^

Apr 24, 2017 12:38 PM UTC

I personally appreciate your insight into the software. It's not always what we want to hear but it gives us all a better understanding of what is happening.

Apr 24, 2017 12:40 PM UTC

I think the biggest thing PTC should be looking are the competitors. UG, CATIA and Solidworks all have longer file limits, you don't want to keep falling behind the competition for very long because they will eventually steal your customers.