Skip to main content
Sep 9, 2022 10:46 AM UTC
Delivered

Fix Modernized Project and Offset Tools in Sketcher

Related products:Creo Parametric

1. Describe your environment: What is your industry? What is your role in your organization? Describe your stakeholders.
Product design studio, I'm a senior designer.


2. What version of Creo Parametric are you currently running?
9.0.1.0

3. Describe the problem you are trying to solve. Please include detailed documentation such as screenshots, images or video.
The Modernized Project and Offset Tools in Sketcher is proving to be very time-consuming as it adds many clicks to perform operation that used to be very fast.

Projecting or Offsetting a loop until Creo 8 used to require 2 clicks to select the command and Loop, then 1 click per loop. Now in Creo 9 it takes 4 clicks to set up, 1 click per loop plus 1 click to confirm each loop.

And, each loop is treated as a single entity where I cannot delete one or more segments of it using Delete segment, which again adds the time-consuming operation of deleting the loop and re-Projecting it as a partial loop.

I understand you're trying to improve this command, but I think you should take a better look at all the possible usage scenarios before implementing such a big change.

4. What is the use case for your organization?
The new Sketcher features are proving to be unnecessarily time-consuming, our work takes longer with no apparent benefit.

5. What business value would your suggestion represent for your organization?
It would make work lighter and faster.

28 replies

idrive101Author
Dec 27, 2023 8:01 AM UTC

@mneumueller 

I opened this thread over a year ago and only now you leak that there IS a way to switch back to pre-Creo 9 behaviour?

While I undestand that this behaviour change followed the requests of many users, I totally understand the frustration of the peole who posted here, and yes please, please, tell us how to switch back!

I'm using Creo 10 and the improvements from 9 have been very marginal, the core of this issue persists.  Why not adding a settings checkbox, or a config.pro option to select the desired sketcher behaviour?

Thank you

Jan 9, 2024 8:11 PM UTC

The ability to switch back was not available initially, but has meanwhile been implemented. For current Creo 9.0 maintenance version it requires Support interaction.  
The plan is to generally provide a (hidden) config  starting with 9.0.8.0 & 10.0.4.0. Starting with those versions, we plan that just setting SKETCHER_USE_CREO8_PROJ_OFFSET to yes should work.

 

 

May 9, 2024 9:07 PM UTC

It seems this issue is still not resolved. I have just up-revved my entire team from Creo7 to Creo11 and we are having a very difficult time with the offset curve command in sketch mode. The trim command in particular - only trims one way and will connect unwanted sides - much like a circle will trim back onto itself. This is very frustrating and is slowing our workflow significantly. I have watched the videos, etc but there seems to be no resolution yet. BTW, I tried to find the SKETCHER_USE_CREO8_PROJ_OFFSET but none exists as far as I can tell.

What am I missing to make this work?

Thanks

May 10, 2024 6:50 AM UTC

This is a hidden config, so you will not find it when you search for it. Just type it in, along with the value of "yes" and you will be able to add it.
Or just add a line

SKETCHER_USE_CREO8_PROJ_OFFSET yes

manually to your config.pro.

Jun 27, 2024 9:23 PM UTC

@mneumueller I just found this thread while trying to figure out why the corner tool wasn't working well with my offset sketches. I noticed the offset tool was making "composite curve" sketch entities, which were the source of the issue. I understand that these composite curves are useful in certain situations, but they make further manipulation (like with the corner tool) basically impossible. I was hoping there was perhaps a toggle that could be used to switch between composite and regular old segmented curves, but it seems there isn't one. I am using this hidden config now to revert to the old project/offset tool, but I'm a bit disappointed to have to revert to that just for the resulting geometry to play nice. Perhaps PTC can consider making a toggle for these tools?