Skip to main content
Sep 9, 2022 10:46 AM UTC
Delivered

Fix Modernized Project and Offset Tools in Sketcher

Related products:Creo Parametric

1. Describe your environment: What is your industry? What is your role in your organization? Describe your stakeholders.
Product design studio, I'm a senior designer.


2. What version of Creo Parametric are you currently running?
9.0.1.0

3. Describe the problem you are trying to solve. Please include detailed documentation such as screenshots, images or video.
The Modernized Project and Offset Tools in Sketcher is proving to be very time-consuming as it adds many clicks to perform operation that used to be very fast.

Projecting or Offsetting a loop until Creo 8 used to require 2 clicks to select the command and Loop, then 1 click per loop. Now in Creo 9 it takes 4 clicks to set up, 1 click per loop plus 1 click to confirm each loop.

And, each loop is treated as a single entity where I cannot delete one or more segments of it using Delete segment, which again adds the time-consuming operation of deleting the loop and re-Projecting it as a partial loop.

I understand you're trying to improve this command, but I think you should take a better look at all the possible usage scenarios before implementing such a big change.

4. What is the use case for your organization?
The new Sketcher features are proving to be unnecessarily time-consuming, our work takes longer with no apparent benefit.

5. What business value would your suggestion represent for your organization?
It would make work lighter and faster.

28 replies

idrive101Author
Nov 2, 2022 11:26 AM UTC

@mneumueller 

I tried what you wrote in version 9.0.1 but I'm not getting the result I intended.

I double ckick on the loop, select Standard since I want each segment to have its own reference, but when I click Confirm only one segment remains.

Maybe I'm doing something wrong? (see video below)

And, even if it worked as intended, if it could ideally be done by pushing a single button (or right-click and pick Break-up references) would be even better.

 

(view in My Videos)

Apr 21, 2023 10:26 AM UTC
Status changed to: Delivered

Creo 10.0 further enhances the project/offset workflows to combine benefits of the previous and new approach. See

Broadened Support for Modernized Project and Offset Tools in Sketcher (ptc.com)

May 1, 2023 7:00 PM UTC

As a 29 year user, I see the new "Modernized Project and Offset Tools in Sketcher" as two steps BACKWARDS

 

I often want to offset a chain/loop and then modify the resulting sketch.  The functionality is no longer available.

idrive101Author
May 22, 2023 9:44 AM UTC

I finally had a chance to use the "improved" Project and Offset in Creo 10.

I still see some issues, and as @jschneider wrote I still end up taking longer than in Creo 8 (or earlier) to perform the same tasks.

 

A. I can't project/offset more than 1 loop at a time. I select the loop of curves then I have to Accept, then select the project/offset command again.

B. The projected/offset items are diffcult to manage or modify, and if I remove some segments the resulting lines are marked as not closed. See the attached video. I tried Corner to join the ends of those curves and it didn't work, I have to move one of the vertexes and the use Concide. Not the most efficient way to work and, honestly, it's quite disappointing.

(view in My Videos)

Jun 19, 2023 9:51 AM UTC

wrt to A: 

did you use the "repeat" button highlighted in blue below?

mneumueller_0-1687168105565.png

wrt to B:

thanks for raising it. Could you please file a Tech Support case for this so it can be looked into? 
Thank you very much.

Jun 19, 2023 7:46 PM UTC

I agree that the ability to "pin" a loop selection is missing.  As a workaround, I created a mapkey for "use edge loop" and "offset edge loop" that enters the loop selection dialogue immediately after selecting the first entity, then pauses to allow selection of the surface loop reference.  Then I use my universal mapkey for "resume mapkey" (RES, that I can trigger very quickly with my left hand on the keyboard) to accept selection.  I copy/pasted the mapkey content 10 times in config.pro to automatically retrigger the original mapkey after every loop selection.  It's not quite as fast as the old way of picking new loops one click at a time but much faster than repeatedly mouse clicking through the menus.

Nov 23, 2023 7:40 AM UTC

I hope very much that this new feature will be revised because it is really absurd to use it, it is from 1993 and back in the days it was difficult to use it but this new feature besides being wasteful in terms of use the composite curve is useless, on the offset you cannot convert to standard, in project you can but the radii become spline.... and this is another absurd thing.

Dec 19, 2023 2:06 PM UTC

@mneumueller , we have opened up a ticket about another 'regression'. 

Case 17144157: 

The Creo 9 offset, does not allow you to delete segments as you could in Creo 8. In creo 8, the offset creates ' individual segments' where each can be deleted. In creo 9, only one 'composite curve', is created, which prevents the ability to easily delete specific portions. Our design team is getting very frustrated. The article https://www.ptc.com/en/support/article/CS369607 states that we need to first divide segments before we can trim them. If we can reference certain elements of the segment in Creo 10 (reference your above video), we should be able to trim them as well.

See below video with demonstration

(view in My Videos)

 

 

 

Dec 20, 2023 9:27 AM UTC

Hi Joseph / all,

 

yes,  the trim & corner workflow seems to be impacted in the offset case and needing an implementation refinement.  

If you really feel you need to go back, you can mention that in your interaction with Support. We can give you a way to switch Creo 9.0 project/offset behavior to the previous Creo 8.0 project/offset tools. 

Dec 26, 2023 1:42 PM UTC

@mneumueller 

"We can give you a way to switch Creo 9.0 project/offset behavior to the previous Creo 8.0 project/offset tools"


Can you just post it here, so every customer doesn't have to create a separate support case to discover how to do this?