Skip to main content
Jun 18, 2015 7:38 AM UTC
Archived

Change notice facility to up-itaration as well as revise

Related products:Creo Parametric

Currently only one option to automatically create resulting objects is available when change a notice is being created.

This is the revise button.

This creates a new revision and in our workflow sets the resulting newly revised object back to In "Work status" from its "Released" status which means the previous revision is still the Released revision until the change has been completed and then the newly revised object gets upgraded to "Released"

Fig1.JPG

However if I want to create a change that will have a minor effect on an object such as a spelling mistake on a drawing or an incorrect mating in an assembly etc. it does not warrant a full revision it makes the transition by iteration for example V 1.1 to V 1.2 instead of V 1.1 to V 2.1.

This is not currently possible. As there is no way to up-iterate then no resulting object can be created. If the Object in question is at"Released" then the change is happening to a "Released" Object (in our system no one can check in a modified released part). It becomes impossible to make an iteration change on a "Released" part without the intervention of a Library Manager or Administrator to set the permissions for the assignee to modify and check in a "Released" part. This is not good.

I would like to see an additional button alongside the Revise button that says "iteration". selecting this will create a new iteration of the object,(exactly like the way the "Revise" button works) and set it to "In Work" status such that it can be modified and checked in.

the Change process can then take it through to "Released" exactly the same way a Revised object is processed.


This would be an incredibly useful feature.

    12 replies

    Jun 19, 2015 11:50 AM UTC

    Daniel,

    Not really sure who you were responding to but I will give you background from my perspective.

    Our shop is not that large, and there has been lots of transiency so different skill sets have been applied to our drawings.

    We allow modifications to drawings without authorization so long as they are clerical.  We try to incorporate them with other authorized changes but sometimes it can not wait or it is discovered a step or two before the production floor.  Authorized changes are revision changes (A.x, B.x).  We do not utilize the promotion request to its full ability.  Its a method to set the state from design to released then use the revise to move to the next revision.  Iterations of a revision level is just saved design states.  The latest version is always promoted as "released".

    We are, hopefully, going to look into changing our processes here.  I have been enlightened with your insight as I am looking for ways and methods that may suit our needs.

    Thanks

    Ron

    olivierlp
    Community Manager
    Jan 4, 2022 4:38 PM UTC
    Status changed to: Archived

    Hello,

    We are archiving your idea as part of a general review. This action is based on the age of your idea and the total number of votes received, as per this announcement.

    You can always post a new idea with all the details required in the form.

    Thank you for your participation.

    Olivier