Skip to main content
Feb 22, 2016 6:51 AM UTC
Archived

borrow license for more than 14 days

Related products:Creo Parametric

For some users usually working in the company network with floating CAD-licenses, it is important on e.g. during an on-site installation to be able to work with Creo to open CAD models for a longer period than the 14days currently available for borrowing. Therefore 14 days seems an unnecessary and serious limitation of the flexnet-license server.

This idea proposes to unlimit the duration for borrowing a license or at least to set the maximum limitation to a much longer period e.g. 150 or even 365 days.

This will not affect PTC's sales possiblilities for licenses because there is already a workaround, by having one license and one license server running with a small exchangeable USB-network-card on the CAD-laptop.

In my feeling as user it would even increase the satisfaction with this nice piece of CAD-software if such an operation would not need a workaround but would be natively supported and easy to use.

P.S. As I can see, quite a few people were intrested and reading this idea. I would like to ask anybody who reads it and agrees with me, not to forget to vote for it. Otherwise it might not be considered by PTC.

26 replies

Mar 16, 2016 2:35 PM UTC

Posted in another Borrow License thread by Martin Hanak on 19 Feb 2016:

according to https://www.ptc.com/appserver/cs/view/solution.jsp?n=CS31332, borrowed licenses can be returned early starting from:

  • Creo Elements/Pro 5.0 M150
  • Creo Parametric 1.0 M050
  • Creo Parametric 2.0 M020
fmuellerAuthor
Mar 16, 2016 2:59 PM UTC

@BEN

many thanks for this useful link.

@Jim

the link to the early return describes a command line way - which is in my point of view not practicable for all CAD users. Maybe PTC can combine borrowing and early returnin in one common ans simple to use GUI?

What about having in Creo a command button "borrow license", where the user can define the number of tays he/she want.

If the system "sees" its home network environment with the flexnet server again Creo could even ask the user if he/she wants to return the borrowed license. Otherwise a comand button "Return borrowed license" in Creo would do it.

Mar 22, 2016 1:57 PM UTC

All

Thank you for your feedback.  I am happy to inform you (subject to change without notice) PTC will increase the borrowing time by summer 2016.

As soon as the improvements to the borrowing time are available for I will post all the details. 

I will also investigate how we can improve the early return of borrowed licenses.

Thanks to your feedback on this subject I feel feedback such as this can really help us make a difference.

thanks

jim

Mar 22, 2016 4:17 PM UTC

That is fantastic news.  Thank you Jim.

fmuellerAuthor
Mar 23, 2016 7:25 AM UTC

Hi Jim,

that's very good news. Thank you very much for looking into the details and listening to the "strange requirements" some odd customers/users like us have.

I know that life for the programmers would be much easier if there were no customer/user. I hope however that it only makes your product better and even more competitive.

Thanks again

Frieder

Mar 28, 2016 7:27 PM UTC

Jim Barrett-Smith‌,

I see PTC has released the details:

Can I ask why perpetual license holders will not get the same borrowing duration as subscription customers?  I have to believe that > 95% of all Creo commercial licenses are currently perpetual.

Thanks.

Mar 28, 2016 8:24 PM UTC

That is very curious about the two different license types.

Mar 29, 2016 8:28 PM UTC

Tom - PTC is transitioning its business model from perpetual to subscription licenses. You are correct that the majority of our customers own perpetual licenses today, but that ratio is changing, and changing rapidly. There are many business benefits to subscription, which are enumerated more fully on PTC.com. From a product perspective, there are many benefits as well. We launched new subscription-only Creo packages in January that include 40 hours of eLearning, and Mathcad subscription-only packages that include worksheet templates, an animator tool and an SDK. We will continue to add capabilities and content to our subscription-only packages, further differentiating them from our perpetual offerings over time. The difference in limits for license borrowing is another example - an additional benefit of being on a subscription license is a longer borrowing window. But we've set both to meet the needs of all of our customers.

Mar 30, 2016 10:58 AM UTC

The only reason it's changing rapidly is because of the costs savings.  Once the majority of users change I'll bet the perpetual licensing goes away and the cost for subscriptions will rise rapidly to the point there wouldn't be much, if any, difference.

Mar 30, 2016 12:16 PM UTC

Is there a cost savings?  I did an preliminary analysis back in December that showed the subscription model costing more, potentially much more.  Not sure if the pricing structure has changed since then...

See Re: Subscription Licensing (w/o Cloud) VS Perpetual Licensing (w/o Cloud)