Skip to main content
Feb 22, 2016 6:51 AM UTC
Archived

borrow license for more than 14 days

Related products:Creo Parametric

For some users usually working in the company network with floating CAD-licenses, it is important on e.g. during an on-site installation to be able to work with Creo to open CAD models for a longer period than the 14days currently available for borrowing. Therefore 14 days seems an unnecessary and serious limitation of the flexnet-license server.

This idea proposes to unlimit the duration for borrowing a license or at least to set the maximum limitation to a much longer period e.g. 150 or even 365 days.

This will not affect PTC's sales possiblilities for licenses because there is already a workaround, by having one license and one license server running with a small exchangeable USB-network-card on the CAD-laptop.

In my feeling as user it would even increase the satisfaction with this nice piece of CAD-software if such an operation would not need a workaround but would be natively supported and easy to use.

P.S. As I can see, quite a few people were intrested and reading this idea. I would like to ask anybody who reads it and agrees with me, not to forget to vote for it. Otherwise it might not be considered by PTC.

26 replies

Feb 22, 2016 2:36 PM UTC

The workaround is to move a license from your server pool to be standalone on the laptop. When the laptop is not going on the road for a while, move the license back to the server pool. Might be a little extra work, but avoids hitting a license expiration while on the road. Where I used to work, we put all laptops on standalone licenses and only desktop workstations used the license pool.

fmuellerAuthor
Feb 23, 2016 1:12 PM UTC

Putting all Laptops with a standalone license is unforunately not a practicable solution for us. Also not the buerocratic paperwork which needs to be done for relicensing to another MAC-Adress. So we always hope, that traveling for more than 14days can be avoided. This limitation is really a disadvantage against competitors. As we can read here modify proe_borrow.bat for borrowing more than 14 days other CAD vendors do longer borrowing with the same license manager!

Please don't forget to vote 😉 here

Mar 11, 2016 7:59 PM UTC

It definitely should be increased.

Mar 15, 2016 5:43 PM UTC

Hi everyone,

Thank you for your comments and votes.  I am looking into increasing the borrow time but the question is what should be the default and for what reason.  If you could provide the use case it would certainly help me make the case for selecting a specific period

So which option and for what reason

1) 30 days - 1 month

2) 60 days - 2 months

3) 90 days - 3 months

4) 120 days - 4 months

5) 180 days - 6 months

I look forward to your comments, Jim

Mar 15, 2016 5:58 PM UTC

I think the default should still be a short time since I think that would cover 90% of the travel cases. Make it 10 days, check out Friday, be gone a week and it will expire on the second Monday. Longer periods, or shorter, would still be available for those other trips.

fmuellerAuthor
Mar 16, 2016 8:10 AM UTC

Dear Ben,

I disagree with you. In our business we are designing cusomized research instruments and it is usual that the designers  are also the ones who are installing the equipment at the customers site. During such an installation it happens that you need to look for certain dimensions or you need to make final adaptations to interfaces to existin equipment or similar. So you need a real CAD-System not just pdf-drawings or a viewer.

Such site installations may take for instance 6 weeks. Sometimes they are on other continents or simply far away. Not always you have a fast and reliable internet connection to borrow a new period of just 14days. Sometimes even customers security regulationd does not allow you to connect your CAD-Laptop via VPN with your Server at home.

That means we may simply not able to work when such an installation takes longer than two weeks. For that reason our workaround in former years was to license one of our floating licenses to a USB-LAN-Card and take that LAN-Card with us. This is however a pain, because when coming back you need to get that license back in the pool using a second flexnet-server that runs with the USB-LAN-Card. This is really not a practicable way and therefore we currently do have all licenses again on one Flexnet server and hope that we either have not such long installations or we have an internet connection fast enough to allow renew the borrowing via VPN.

My personal feeling is, that it was just a political decision by PTC not to allow longer periods. I can't understand that, because there are workarounds fully covered with the license conditions. My feeling is that PTC could gain customers satisfaction when it would allow longer borrowing periods or loose that satisfaction when it forces the customer to go complicated workarounds. As I have learnt from the discussions here in the community, other CAD-vendors with the same license server are allowing longer periods so I don't believe that just technical limitations of the Flexnet-server are the reason. So I am grateful to Jim wo seems actually to look into the details and consider the possibilities PTC have.

Dear Jim,

My personal favorite from your proposal above is: Leave it configurable but make the longest allowed period as long as technically (and politically 😉 ) possible e.g. 180days. So everyone can just choose the borrowing length by the duration of his trip. The current problem now is mainly the limitation of the max. borrowing period to just 15days.

Even better - if not perfect - would it be, to allow the user an "early return" of the borrowed license when the laptop is back in the network. This is something Autodesk does. You can just give back the borrowed license as soon as you don't need it anymore. So you could borrow a little longer than you actually need. Sometimes one has to extend an busines trip for reasons that were not foreseen. I would then just borrow for one week longer that I have planned my trip. In case I came back as planned I would then simply "early return" the borrowed license. In case I need a week longer than planned it doesn't matter and I do not have to worry about the availibility of my CAD-program.

Mar 16, 2016 12:44 PM UTC

Frieder,

Unless I am reading your response wrong Ben wasn't suggesting to keep the maximum amount of time short.  He was replying to the question of what the "default value" should be.  Ben suggests keeping the default short but still allow longer periods of time.

Mar 16, 2016 1:37 PM UTC

I agree that the LONGEST time should be what Flexera has which is 183 days, I think.

I only said the DEFAULT should be 10 days, but allow you to set any time length up to the software maximum.

Early return is allowed, so that issue has been addressed and solved.

Mar 16, 2016 1:46 PM UTC

I think as a default it should still be a short period of time.  7 10 or 14 days as the default should be fine.

fmuellerAuthor
Mar 16, 2016 2:00 PM UTC

@BEN

thank you for clarification. I agree for the default, that 7days or 10days seems a practicable default value that can be changed to shorter or longer periods.

Could you please give some more details about an early return? As far as I know from the PTC documentation that is not foreseen and not possible so far.