Recently active
Calum,Are you attempting to run the stress analysis in Creo Simulate? If so, I'm very curious as to how you're going to mesh the assembly. I just attempted to a mesh a simple plate (shown below), and I made the plate as thin as possible (0.0009-inch or 28.86 um), and for now, that's as thin as I could get it using absolute accuracy. Both of your coatings added together are 0.0006-inch. I've never attempted to mesh geometry this thin before (never had a need too). For the moment, I don't know how thin Simulate will go, as I'm still experimenting. I would really like to know the outcome of your mesh, if you're willing to post it.
Look at the attached video and see if this helps. It switches to Mechanisms after about a minute of play.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7leLhYQj3qo
Domen,If you don't mind me asking, what software version do you use?
Here is some related info on bending a pipe: https://community.ptc.com/t5/Creo-Modeling-Questions/bend-unbend-of-hollow-pipe/td-p/310191
If you're viewing a drawing with dimensions and without a csys, you should still be able to make the pipe. Sketch a curve (trajectory) and make a sweep on that curve.
So you answered your own question. Can you mark your own question as Correct?
Erik,I greatly appreciate you posting your findings, as it gives us all insight, and what not to do with a 360-degree cone with a pressure load, something I wasn’t aware of.If PTC has resolved your problem, could you post the discussion as Answered? This will benefit others who are searching for solutions.I very seldom run SPA .
Were you able to solve the problem?
Frank,If my suggestions have resolved the problem, could you mark the discussion as Correct. This will benefit others who are searching for solutions. Thanks.
Alvin,If my suggestions have resolved the problem, could you mark the discussion as Correct. This will benefit others who are searching for solutions. Thanks.
From a design point-of-view, what would be the difference in your margins of safety using symmetry/mapped meshing vs a perfectly coded software with 0% error?
Did symmetry and mapped meshing resolve the problem?
Agnes,Thanks for keeping us posted. I couldn't locate the SPR in the Knowledge Base (as shown below).
Add the capability to shrink the elements with a fringe plot to view the stress contours within the model, as shown below.
Von Mises and convergence (shown below):
Alvin,If you want the mesh to look like your desired post, you will have to rotate your hole 90-degrees. I've posted the solution below, as I think this is the type of mesh you're looking for.
The *.avg file is not a user-readable file, which lists the h-nodes and the corresponding p-elements where stress averaging should not occur due to shell tangent discontinuity.
Can you change this post to a discussion instead of a question?
I found them all but .avg, and I'm still searching that one in some of my older references.
Barry,This looks like a thermal analysis on a component without a force load, and the component is constrained in such a way that you're receiving the warning. This analysis is a Quick Check (p3 to p3), and there are no measures in your summary file.Can you upload an image of the part, or is it classified?
Can you post an image of the pattern?
Alvin,I'm only posting these results to make a point. I made a simple plate with a hole, ran a mpa analysis with about 1000 shell elements, and it only took five seconds to run and obtain convergence within 1% (spa about two seconds). I've seen a lot of models where people try to break up the elements around a hole to make it look like a hand mesh, but with the p-element, you don't really have to do this. I created a lot of elements on purpose, and I certainly don't need this many to meet convergence. Try auto-meshing your model without Edge Distribution and check your results. Hope this helps.
Frank,They are defined in the Help Center, as I stated before.http://help.ptc.com/creo_hc/creo30_sim_hc/usascii/index.html#page/sim/simulate/online/filelist.htmlFor example:.a01 is listed as study.a## (then read the right-hand column).d01 is listed as study.d##
Barry,Did you receive a fatal error, and that's why the run doesn't complete or are you just getting warnings? Upload the .rpt file (run summary file).
I assume that there is currently no provision to post a Product Idea in the specified topic.
Already have an account? Login
No account yet? Create an account
Enter your E-mail address. We'll send you an e-mail with instructions to reset your password.