Skip to main content
Jun 26, 2010 1:33 PM UTC

Forth of July fireworks to begin early next week

Peter Rosenthal has figured out a way to get WF5 to work with Intralink 3.4.  In a barbed post to PTC/User forum (login required), he details the steps.  Basically, it involves setting up workspaces with WF4 and then switching to WF5 to work on files. I commend him on his ingenuity but I have to reply with "so what".

I am not an Intralink user so I cannot share in the experience of converting to PDMLink or Intralink 8+ (though I have done a migration).  It was probably a step backward in some areas and a step forward in others.  From the ask the experts session at PTC/User, it was clear that there are a lot of customers who still have not switched and are angry about having to. PTC made this decision 2 years ago so there was plenty of time.  Profit may have been a factor but you have to appreciate the support aspects of carrying two products that basically do the same thing (I am speaking of big picture functionality).  Improvements have stopped a long time ago, and as of WF5, so does regression testing and technical support.

Peter mentioned it was a deliberate block. Of course it was. Its the same thing when you try to install a program on Window 98 when it says minimum XP. They check the OS and block the install. Could it work? Maybe. But they do not support it, so why bother letting you continue any further? It was never about it not working for some technical reason.  Look at website blocks today on people who still run IE6!

So, if you do this, it might work and you can use WF5.  But what do you really have? A very expensive CAD/PDM system that you will not get ANY technical support for related to PDM issues.  And you are still paying for that technical support. Fast foward a year when you do end up migrating to Intralink 10, will you have issue because there are WF5 files in the Intralink system? I doubt it would cause an issue but I would not fault PTC for saying you are on your own.

Link to Posting:

PTC "YOU LIE" WF5 AND INTRALINK 3.4 WILL WORK; YOU DID'NT COVER ALL OF  THE BLOCKS