Skip to main content
May 30, 2010 2:04 AM UTC
Question

Modeling Extrasolar Planets

This animation illustrates the motion of an extrasolar planet about its star, or the motion of the secondary star about its primary in a binary star system.

 

A Mathcad 11 worksheet, Modeling_Extrasolar_Planets.mcd, was used to generate this animation. To view and/or download the worksheet, see my PlanetPTC document, Kepler's Laws, Extrasolar Planets, and a Cycloid Sweeper.

 

 

Unable to play video. Please try again later.
(view in My Videos)

4 replies

Jul 1, 2010 6:09 AM UTC

This animation

http://twt.mpei.ac.ru/TTHB/1/3-Planets-1.avi

illustrates the motion of three planet from its star: one case - intersept of the satelite.

The Mathcad 14 file is here http://twt.mpei.ac.ru/TTHB/1/3-Planets.xmcdz

Jul 9, 2010 2:58 PM UTC

Valery,

This is a very extraordinary video. You should upload it to the Mathcad video page or one of the other Mathcad sub-communities.

-BostonDan

Jul 16, 2010 5:28 PM UTC

Valery, I agree with Dan.

Your 3-Planets video and worksheet model the gravitational interaction of three Newtonian particles. When the video starts, the blue body is in orbit around the red body, and both head toward the black body. But as the three bodies move closer to each other, the black body "captures" the blue body from the red body, yet the red body is not itself captured.

Two comments: (1) when I change node to node*10, the black body no longer captures the blue body. So it appears that the numerical integration does not follow the physics. (2) There is a "kink" in the black body's path. This would seem to indicate a discontinuous derivative somewhere.

Roger L. Mansfield

Aug 9, 2010 3:48 PM UTC

Thanks Dan and Roger for the interesting on my work.

It is described in the russian article - see here http://twt.mpei.ac.ru/ochkov/Mathcad_12/Planet/index.html

I have translate (sorry - my computer has translated) a begin of the article (and I can translate all text with your help):

"The article describes how the lessons of physics, mathematics, computer calculations can be used, open the Internet and how to open their own calculations in the World Wide Web through technology, Mathcad Application Server (MAS)

Epigraph

Dialogue Session on computer modeling.

Student: "Look, as I have on the screen two bodies neatly in orbits whirl!"

Teacher, silently gazing at the display: "Here you have not two bodies whirl, but three - Isaac Newton in the coffin, too, turns ..."

Let's start with "disturbed" Newton.

We often hear such a rhetorical question: "How would now look calculus, if Newton had a computer?" From history, as we know, there is no subjunctive mood, but ... Some believe that if the Newton was the computer, then. .. No differential calculus would not be. And it would be resolved and the alleged accumulation of unsolved problems, many tables and curves on your computer screen from which any conclusions, but the more general laws to make it would be extremely difficult - "beggars (people without a computer), the mother of invention." Others argue, in the sense that "a computer-Newton would have helped us to avoid many mistakes and errors, has protected to the quest for analytical solutions where they do not, and, eventually, would lead to more rapid development of science and technology in general and mathematics in particular. But the answer probably is: "If Newton was a computer, then it would mean that ... differential calculus as a science has existed for three hundred years before Newton, but Newton himself (one of the founders of the differential calculus) would carry a different name ...».

Everything said about the differential calculus can be applied to the law of universal gravitation - the second grand creation of the Great and nekompyurizirovannogo "Newton, who is considered the law" came to mind, along with the falling apple. " Let's see how modern computers can help us or conversely hinder understand a well-known physical problem... (a continiue in the work)"