Skip to main content
Apr 27, 2012 2:11 PM UTC
Question

A Teaser

What is happening in this video? Can you describe the axes and what the curves represent?

 

When we have a good answer to those questions, more will follow. Stay tuned!

 

 

 

Unable to play video. Please try again later.
(view in My Videos)

12 replies

May 22, 2012 12:03 PM UTC

Good morning Harvey,

Second guess: It's a fixed-bed reactor (FBR). The video shows the transient response when a sudden change in the inlet temperature (a step down) leads to the variation on the hot spot temperature of the system (wrong-way behavior).

In Fig-1: X, refers to axial position and Y is the temperature. In Fig-2, X is again axial position and Y is Concentration.

What do you think?

Regards,

Oscar J.

May 22, 2012 1:43 PM UTC

Congratulations Oscar! You got it right. 

I'm going to fill in some missing description.  The reactor is a fixed bed tubular reactor being cooled on the wall.  The model is dynamic and 2D, in cylindrical coordinates.  Therefore, the red curves represent the behavior of either temperature or concentration along the axis at a given radial distance.  The hottest temperature is thus along the center of the tube (top curve in Fig 1) and the reactant disappears the most along the center (bottom curve in Fig 2).

The first half of the video is the startup of the reactor and establishes a steady state.  Then, the feed temperature (on the left in Fig 1) is dropped 1% on an absolute basis.  For a reactor operating at 500 K, that would be 5 K drop.  The colder reactant doesn't react as fast so more of it reaches the hot spot and then reacts all at once.  This is the classic "wrong way temperature runaway" behavior in a fixed bed, either adiabatic or tubular.

The 3D plot shows the same thing.  The spatial axes are not to scale because they are plotted according to indexes of the solution matrix.

I promised more questions, so here they are:

  1. What are your design options to keep the maximum temperature below a given value?
  2. Given the space time of the fluid, what four physical parameters are needed to estimate the time to reach a thermal steady state?
  3. What formula would you use to calculate this thermal space time using the given fluid space time and the four parameters?
  4. Of those four parameters, which two are the most important, i.e. they can be used on their own for a slightly less accurate estimate?

Anyone may still answer these questions, but thank you Oscar for identifying the process.  With the hints I supplied, I'm surprised it took this long to get the answer.