Skip to main content
Community Manager
Oct 6, 2017 10:34 PM UTC
Question

Subscribing the Label Issues

Ok @TomU and anyone else.  This might seem "off topic" but we are cleaning things up so I thought I would ask.  I spent over and hour trying different "subscribe to labels" and they seem to work.  The "only" odd thing was that when I was subscribed to both the board and option drop down menu far left AND to the label subscribe in the blue.  My notification says "The board" across the top of the notification email instead of the label name.  BUT when I clicked through the "Test 2" topic or thread link it brought me directly the topics in label I was subscribed to. So, what I am trying to understand is...if you are working the community mostly through email notifications why is this an issue.  You can subscribe to a label and be notified anytime anything comes into the label.  And, if you go directly to the board you can click on the label and sort and only see things under that label or topic area.  So, while I am sure this isn't working the same as Jive, I am trying to figure out from a task oriented process what really the issue is.  I think we might have to move on from this label discussion because after all my testing it seems it is working the way it is intended.  If someone wants to write up a cohesive request for me to submit to the Lithium Platform Idea Portal I am happy to as your  community manager.

 

 

 newsubscribingscreenshot.jpg

 

    4 replies

    Oct 6, 2017 11:49 PM UTC

    Here is the quick reply.  I can try to write a more comprehensive one later if I need to.

     

    According to Scott from Lithium, labels...

    • are node specific
    • can be set to "none", "optional", or "required" for new posts
    • can be pre-defined and/or can be defined on the fly (by the users)
    • are a filter (when viewing a discussion board)
    • cannot be used as a filter/criteria on the search page
    • cannot be subscribed to (he said you are really just subscribing to a particular post, not subscribing to the label - although I'm not sure this is accurate)

     

    For labels to work in place of categories, the following things must exist

    • must be able to search by a label
    • must be able to subscribe to a label
    • must be able to view content by label
    • must be able to easily create new posts with the correct label, and likewise prevent post creation without a label (otherwise everything ends up unlabeled in one big dumping ground.)

    Optimally users should navigate to the area they are interested in, and then once they are there only be able to create content within that area.  With labels this is not possible.

     

    For example, if we create a "category" for Creo Parametric and then create a discussion board within it called "Pro/Program", all new posts created inside this board will automatically stay inside this board.  Likewise, when viewing the "Pro/Program" board, no one will have to do any special filtering to only see content related to "Pro/Program".  By default they will only see content on that board.

     

    With the label approach, if the board was called "Creo Parametric" and the label was called "Pro/Program", to see just "Pro/Program" content one would have to first apply a filter to the "Creo Parametric" board's posts.  (This alone is probably not a huge deal.)  To create new "Pro/Program" content, they have to remember to pick the label "Pro/Program".  If they don't, the content will end up in the root of "Creo Parametric" (assuming that is allowed.) This is why when I was working with Toby I said that for this to work labels must be required (for ALL posts) and only one label should be allowed per post.  (These are not "tags", they are being used as a replacement for categories.)  Of course this gets messy when you're already in a board with a narrow focus that doesn't justify multiple labels.  (The labels "required" setting is site wide and I don't think there is currently any way to prohibit using multiple labels.)

     

    The other problem with labels is that they do not appear in email notifications from the discussion board they exist in.  This makes it nearly impossible to setup email filters to automatically organize content from the board.  (Many of us do this extensively.)  At the moment were stuck with three, less than optimal solutions (and much worse than what we had with Jive):

     

    1.)  Subscribe to the discussion board, but not the labels.

          Pro:  All content to the board will be delivered.

          Con:  No ability to tell what label has been applied to each message (the label is not present in the email.)

    2.)  Subscribe to just the labels currently present on the board.

          Pro:  Emails come in correctly labeled.

          Con:  Any unlabeled content or content to new labels will not be delivered (and the user won't know they are missing anything.)

    3.)  Subscribe to both the labels and the board:

          Pro:  You will get everything.

          Con:  You will get everything twice.

     

    Lithium has this concept of using labels to identify content and then when there is enough traffic on that label spawn a new discussion board.  I think this is fine, but that should only happen AFTER the structure is fixed.  For example, let's say we have a "Creo Parametric" category containing a "Drawings" discussion board.  Inside the "Drawings" discussion board someone creates a label called "Symbols".  If over time there is a large amount of content labeled "Symbols", then it would probably make sense to spawn a new discussion board called "Drawing Symbols" (again, inside the "Creo Parametric" category.) 

     

    Summary:  Labels simply don't provide the same functionality that categories offered on Jive or that discussion boards offer here on Lithium.  We need to stop trying to make them something they were't intended to be.  We need discussion board - lots of them - organized within product categories (just like the AutoCAD community you showed us.)

    Jaime_LeeCommunity ManagerAuthor
    Community Manager
    Oct 9, 2017 3:01 PM UTC

    Thank you, @TomU this helps.  Here is an example email of what I received when I am only subscribed to a label a"Forecasting" and the "Board Level-Servigistics."

     

    so this part below I agree was misstated.  I will exclude from my write up.

    "cannot be subscribed to (he said you are really just subscribing to a particular post, not subscribing to the label - although I'm not sure this is accurate)"

    subscribedonlytolabel.jpg