Skip to main content
Community Manager
Jul 20, 2018 6:36 AM UTC
Question

Is the Exploder Back?

Hi, Friends, 

 

I stumbled upon a new Lithium community feature that I can enable on our community.  We can reply by email which I believe is what some of our veteran community users were able to do on  "Exploder."

 

I demoed on the Lithium Community site so I could grab these screen shots for you all:

 

Step 1:  User Posts on the community

 

replybyemail1.png

 

Step 2:  User is “Subscribed” and the Reply Post comes into the User's email

 

replybyemail3.jpg

 

Step 3:   User Can Click “Reply” at Bottom 

 

Step 4:  User inserts desired text that will show up directly on the community

 

replybyemail3.5.jpg

 

Step 5:  User goes to the community to see the response

 

replybyemail4.png

 

 

That is how the process will work in a nut shell.  Any questions?  Any reason I should wait on adding this feature?

    7 replies

    Jul 20, 2018 12:17 PM UTC

    If you don't type the reply above the line will it still get posted?

     

    Most spam bots aren't going to be smart enough to type in a certain area, so this could help prevent spam and automated (out of office) replies from going to the community.

     

    Maybe you should turn it on for only one board and see how it works out before turning it on everywhere.

    Jul 20, 2018 12:23 PM UTC

    I would use it. I would prefer NOT having to log in to the community directly to answer a simple question or even a complicated question.

    Will it work with images?

    I agree with Tom, the exploder occasionally had spam issues...but i guess the community occassionally has spam issues...

     

    Jul 20, 2018 12:31 PM UTC

    One more thing.  Replying to email messages directly can be challenging because some boards don't display images in the email messages.  To view all the content in the post you have to view the post on the community.  If you can make the image behavior consistent across the entire community (show up in all emails), then replying directly makes more sense.

    3-Newcomer
    Jul 23, 2018 7:21 PM UTC

    I see two issues with this.

     

    First, on the exploder, emailed replies made the online forum view an absolute mess.  Each reply typically included the entire original post and the user's signature.  So, if a user was replying to a reply of a reply of the original, a lot of duplicate text was posted.  And sometimes the forum software would see replies as new threads and new threads as replies.  The result was that the online experience was pretty much a useless mess.  Unless the Lithium implementation has these issues resolved, I'd vote no.

     

    Second, right now the email notifications are missing a lot of formatting.  Quotes come through as text and images are not included, for example.  I think this will make for misunderstandings and odd emailed replies because of those misunderstandings.  I think the email notifications need to be a lot better before this would work well.

     

    That said, I think we might bring a few old timers back if we could address these issues and make this work.

    Jaime_LeeCommunity ManagerAuthor
    Community Manager
    Jul 24, 2018 2:06 AM UTC

    Hi, I am testing this on the Lithium Community which has reply by email.  My image embedded in my email did not go through.

     

    This is what I found out about images:

     

    Re: Replying to a community post by email

    Hi @Jaime_Lee,

    Looking into this further, that is expected behavior.  The image that you have in your email would be considered an email attachment and that is not supported.  Here are other notes from our article on Reply by Email:

    Notes

    • Rich text formatting supported by the community can be entered and sent via Reply by Email.  If users do not have permission to use certain HTML tags in their posts, their post will not go through.
    • Reply by Email does not support email attachments.
    • Posts made using Reply by Email look just like normal community posts.
    • For security reasons, the Reply by Email link is active only for the first usage. 

    In this case, if a user wanted to add an image, they'd have to go to the community to edit their post.