Skip to main content
Community Manager
Apr 13, 2018 10:14 PM UTC
Question

Insert Image "BUG"

@WernerE  and others (Monitor Sizes please)

 

From Lithium:  Hello Jamie,

Just checking in to see if you had a moment to review Dereck last comment to the case which stated:

I've been testing this behavior on Stage and Production, but haven't been able to replicate the behavior with the Insert Image pop-up screen as of yet.

So I'd like to confirm with you that I'm doing the correct steps here to replicate the behavior.

1. Be logged in as a user.
2. Navigate to a post, click reply on a post/response there.
3. Add some text, click on the "Add image" button in the toolbar.
4. Have the "Add Image" pop-up appear on-screen.

Also, are you only seeing this on certain types of monitors or does it seem to occur for any monitor? I ask this to narrow down the possible causes for my not replicating the behavior if my steps are correct.

Lastly, does the behavior occur on every board that you would do the steps on or only on certain ones?

Best Regards,

    46 replies

    Apr 14, 2018 1:12 AM UTC

    The pop-up dialog doesn't scale with the screen size, doesn't include scroll bars, is longer than the vertical real estate of the browser window, and it's not apparent that it can be moved around.  Depending on the screen resolution it doesn't even look like attaching the image worked until it's moved up the page.  Here are a couple of videos showing the problem. 

     

     

    Apr 14, 2018 1:15 AM UTC

    And why does every video start by playing fuzzy.  Even once it clear up, dragging the slider back to the beginning makes it all blurry again.  It's very annoying.  

    Apr 14, 2018 8:55 PM UTC

    @TomU wrote:

    And why does every video start by playing fuzzy.  Even once it clear up, dragging the slider back to the beginning makes it all blurry again.  It's very annoying.  


    I agree that the quality of the mediaplayer embedded in this forum is mediocre. But to be honest I seldom come across a forum where the quality of the used media player is satisfactory. All those Flash-, Script-, HTML4- etc -Players are usually quite limited in functionality, comfort and quality. The player used here comes from ooyala.com and is limited, too. The player in Jive also was a good example of how it should not be done. So the best option still is to simply attach the video rather than to embed it, let the user download and watch it using his favorite locally installed player. So we have the full resolution and quality, can step through the video frame by frame if necessary,  export single frames, can store it locally, etc.

     

    Speaking of attachments. I noticed a change here.  Now we have to click the tiny symbol to the right of he file name to download it. Why not the filename itself? Its not a big thing but nevertheless its annoying and a bit more uncomfortable. Clicking the filename opens a "preview" window which is way to slooooooooooooooooooooooow to be called useful. Its hard to understand why externals sites (box.com & boxcdn.net) have to be called just to view a picture. As it is now it may be faster to download the pic and view it using a local viewer - not what a preview should be all about.

     

    P.S.: This reply to Toms post is indented, but is not placed directly under Toms post as it should. So there is no way to determine where this reply belongs to (other than me having to quote Toms post). Thats quite irritating

    Apr 14, 2018 8:44 PM UTC

    I guess that Toms Videos will show the dilemma, but alas I am not able to view them. When I mousover  them the cursor turns into kind of a red "forbidden" sign.

    EDIT: Solved. We have to allow scripts from the site ooyala.com to be able to view videos. Lithium seems to use a lot of third party software directly from the owners sites.
    So I can see that Toms video at least shows partly the problem. Guess he has just decreased the browser window to simulate a smaller screen resolution. In fact in the real situation its not possible to drag the popup window any higher when the cursor reaches the top of the screen.

    Anyway, I attach some pictures. Please not that those pictures show my full screen, not part of it or just a decreased window. BTW, I am using a 15,6" display with 4K resolution and windows zoom usually is something in the range of 250%  to 300%.

    You will note the the InsertPicture or insertVideo popup don't show the insert button. There is no scroll bar (which would be very uncomfortable, too) to get there. For picture insertions it possible to move the pop up up with the mouse far enough so the button gets accessible. For the insertVideo popup that's not possible. I would have to zoom the browser window to access that button.

    If I also would like to see the (extremely slow) preview, I would have chose a zoom of 60% !!

    Its sure not a very clever idea to make a settings window narrow and very high, given that the format of most monitors give you more width than height.

    And its truly astounding that nowadays (we are writing 2018, right?) menus and that kind of windows are of fixed pixel size and not aware of the screen resolution set and do not even provide scroll bars (actually the window should rearrange items to make it most comfortable for the user, whether he is using a full screen, tablet or smartphone).