Skip to main content
Community Manager
Sep 29, 2017 11:21 PM UTC
Question

General Customer Ideas (Not Ideas in Closed Working Groups)

For the purpose of this thread, this topic centers around "general" customer ideas (not ideas being developed in private working groups). The power of the idea exchange in Lithium is to take advantage of "crowd sourcing".  To use the interest, votes, and activity on the idea exchange to help prioritize the product implementation roadmap.  Ideas in the PTC Community have an extra level of customer involvement and security.  Currently, only PTC Community Members with an active maintenance plan can submit an idea to PTC.  The Community Team is exploring  the possiblility of having a centralized general idea exchange for PTC Products and Services (i.e. CREO, Mathcad, Windchill, Integrity, Servigistics, FlexPLM, Arbortext ...etc).  Specific categories could be "defined"  and they could become "buckets" to collect ideas.  Specific product line managers (or customers) can subscribe to an idea category and be notified when a new idea is entered.  The appropriate Product Line Manager will be able to flag each idea with the apppropriate status change as the idea goes through the ideation phase.  (Ex. New/Acknowledge/Under Review/Implemented...etc)  The attached screenshot shows how the idea exchange can display to the user.  Your thoughts on moving the individual idea exchanges to a more central idea exchange?

 

ideaexchangeexample.jpg

    4 replies

    Sep 30, 2017 3:46 PM UTC

    I'm a Creo Parametric user. I have ideas for Creo Parametric. I look at ideas for Creo Parametric.

    I do not want to see or have any interest in seeing ideas for Creo Direct, Creo Simulate, Creo Illustrate.

    They are not the same program and also they have different Product Line Managers.

    In general, having a single Creo Parametric Idea area is what we had previously in Jive. I have no problem with that setup.

    The current "poor" lithium setup is Creo Ideas is a dumping ground for all the programs with Creo as the first word in the name of the program. That doesn't help anyone, user or PTC Product Line Managers.

    And, in my brutally honest opinion, looks like a simplification technique to make the forum managers job easier at the expense of the users who were quickly turned off by the new forum.

    Jaime_LeeCommunity ManagerAuthor
    Community Manager
    Sep 30, 2017 4:23 PM UTC

    @StephenW  So your vote is to have separate "idea category" to collect Creo Parametric ideas separately.  The numbers are showing that Parametric is beating out the other Creo labels for sure on the regular Forum discussion boards.  Definitely worth a consideration!  Did you see this thread? https://community.ptc.com/t5/PTC-Community-Refresh/Idea-Exchange-quot-Buckets-quot-or-Categories/m-p/485662#M23  The screen shot up above is actually only 1 view.  Could the sidebar widget access help?  Community Members reading with an open forum Creo discussion session and then click to the right to enter an idea in the sidebar widget area.  I believe we can even have the top idea threads streaming on the side underneath.  We would definitely demo this in a staging environment first and talk about the layout here if we were going to try something like this! 

     

    Oct 2, 2017 11:35 AM UTC

    Correct, my vote is to have a separate Creo Parametric Idea bucket. I don't see how you could do anything other than separate buckets for each software. They are not the same software so even though there is not much traffic for certain software, having a bucket for each is a necessity (in my opinion).

    The way I use the community is generally through email notifications so I don't believe "widgets" will help me.

    I want to be able to subcribe to "areas" within the community that directly pertain to the software that I use.

    If the bucket for Ideas is all inclusive, then when I subcribe to that bucket, I get Ideas from all things Creo and not just Creo Parametric. I would think it would be the same for users who come to the forum to view content. They want to look at just Creo Simulate (for example) and not all things Creo.

    Email notifications are VERY important to my participation in the forum. I do NOT come to the forum to look for content to reply to. If I see a notification in my email that I am interested in, I visit that specific link. I rarely browse the forum. If I need help, I use the search.

    I see no value in "top ideas" streaming. If i'm looking for an Idea, I use the search functionality.