Skip to main content
Oct 31, 2017 1:14 AM UTC
Question

Feedback about naming/board architecturefor MATHCAD in Champion Private Board Discussion

My two cents worth (and over recent years I've realized that's all the attention Mathcad will get from PTC; although that's certainly not anything you are to blame for), I agree with others that the five posts a day policy is flawed. It's too arbitrary. For example, in the Mathcad forums we had a "board" for Homework problems. There was a very good reason for that, because we didn't want them mixed in with content that was pertinent to the users that used Mathcad for real engineering and science problems. Now, in the Mathcad forums we have 20 posts out of 170,000 that have the label "Math Homework". How could that happen? When the labels were created you knew which "board" the thread came from! I don't care how many posts there are a day to "Math Homework", I just don't want them mixed in with "real" content!

 

Back well before your time the transition of the Mathsoft (the creators of Mathcad) "Collaboratory" to the PTC  Jive forums was a disaster, in which 70% of everything the Mathcad community created was destroyed by incompetence at PTC (really, I'm not just being nasty, it was incompetence). The structure of the Jive forums was mostly inherited from the Collaboratory, and imperfect as it was, it was something. The transition to Lithium has largely destroyed even that. I won't even get into what PTC has done to Mathcad as a product, because that deserves it's own rant. So if you are wondering why the traffic to the Mathcad forums is so low, look in the PTC mirror.

    1 reply

    Oct 31, 2017 7:54 AM UTC

    Agree with Richard.