Skip to main content
Sep 30, 2017 3:45 AM UTC
Question

CREO Community Structure Suggestions

I've presented this before but I've reworked it again to better align with the capabilities (and limitations) of Lithium.  I believe this is all possible.

------------------------------------------------------------

"Creo" and "Windchill" are way to broad and span way to many, completely unrelated products.  The current setup causes lots of confusion (Creo Parametric vs. Creo Direct and PDMLink vs. WPA).  I would strongly suggest that the top level groups or categories align with the broader PTC product areas.  For example:

  • Creo CAD
  • Creo Simulate
  • Creo View
  • Integrity
  • Servigistics
  • Thingworx
  • Windchill PDM & Process
  • Windchill Quality

 

By design, these top level categories are simply collectors for organizing the sub-categories underneath them.  These top level categories should not have their own discussion boards, blogs, or ideas.  They should not be able to be subscribed directly to.

 

At the next level down, break out into the more popular/common products.  Again, users come to the community to interact about a product.  I think it's very important that the community reflect this reality (and help get both people and content into the right areas.)  For example:

Creo CAD                                      (top level category)

  • Creo Layout                          (product specific sub-category)
  • Creo Illustrate
  • Creo Options Modeler 
  • Creo Parametric
  • Other Extensions

Windchill PDM & Process             (top level category)

  • Windchill FlexPLM                  (product specific sub-category)
  • Windchill MPMLink
  • Windchill PartsLink
  • Windchill PDM Essentials
  • Windchill PDMLink
  • Windchill ProjectLink

Each of these product specific sub-categories should be able to be subscribed to and followed without having to subscribe to anything else at a lower level (if so desired.)

 

Within each of these products (or sub-categories) we then add discussion boards to further separate content by subject matter (within a product).  For example, here are my suggestions for Creo Parametric discussion boards:

  • 2D Drawings
  • Modeling
  • Automation (Relations, Pro/Program, Drawing Program)
  • Customization (J-Link, VBAPI, Toolkit, etc.)
  • Sheetmetal
  • Mechanism
  • Assembly

*** For this to work, we MUST be able to directly subscribe to these boards (or subject matter areas.)  There are many, many people who want to subscribe and follow only certain subject areas within a product.  (For example, automation or customization.)  Without the ability to subscribe to the appropriate subject matter area, they either miss content they are interested in or get overwhelmed with a lot of other content they'e not interested in (even though the other content is still about the same product.)  Based on the limitations of the Lithium platform, these cannot be labels, they must be discussion boards.

 

Finally, since there are too many PTC products to give every one of them their own product level sub-category, it might make more sense to keep the Creo Parametric Extensions as just boards (subject matter areas) under a shared, product-specific sub-category (at least until their traffic justifies having its own sub-category.)  For example, these:

  • Creo Advanced Assembly Extension (AAX)
  • Creo Advanced Framework Extension (AFX)
  • Creo Advanced Rendering Extension (ARX)
  • Creo Behavioral Modeling Extension (BMX)
  • Creo Collaboration Extensions
  • Creo Complete Machining Extension
  • Creo Complete Mold Design Extension
  • Creo Computer-Aided Verification Extension
  • Creo Design Exploration Extension (DEX)
  • Creo Distributed Batch Extension
  • Creo ECAD-MCAD Collaboration Extension
  • Creo Expert Moldbase Extension
  • Creo Flexible Modeling Extension (FMX)
  • Creo Intelligent Fastener Extension (IFX)
  • Creo Manikin Extension
  • Creo NC Sheetmetal Extension
  • Creo Piping and Cabling Extension
  • Creo Prismatic and Multi-Surface Milling Extension
  • Creo Production Machining Extension
  • Creo Progressive Die Extension (PDX)
  • Creo Reverse Engineering Extension (REX)
  • Creo Tool Design Extension

(Sorry, I don't know the three letter abbreviation for all of these.  Also, it might make sense to drop the words "Creo" and "Extension" from the label names.)

 

The end result is something that looks like this (this is just an example of Creo CAD and is not complete):

Creo CAD  (category)

    Creo Layout  (sub-category)

  • Creo Layout (discussion board)
  • Creo Layout (ideas)
  • Creo Layout (blog)

    Creo Illustrate (sub-category)

  • Creo Illustrate (discussion board)
  • Creo Illustrate (ideas)
  • Creo Illustrate (blog)

    Creo Optons Modeler (sub-category)

  • Creo Options Modeler (discussion board)
  • Creo Options Modeler (ideas)
  • Creo Options Modeler (blog)

    Creo Parametric (sub-category)

  • 2D Drawings (discussion board)
  • Automation (discussion board)
  • Modeling (discussion board)
  • Administration (discussion board)
  • Creo Parametric (ideas)
    • 2D Drawings (label)

    • Automation (label)
    • Modeling (label)
    • Administration (label)
  • Creo Parametric (blog)
    • 2D Drawings (label)

    • Automation (label)
    • Modeling (label)
    • Administration (label)

    Creo Parametric Extensions (sub-category)

  • AAX (discussion board)

  • BMX (discussion board)
  • IFX (discussion board)
  • PDX (discussion board)

For some products the structure will be very shallow.  For others (like Creo), the structure will be much deeper, and frankly should be due to the large user base and wide range of topics.  To summarize, the community structure conceptually should look like this:

 

Top Level Category - Group of Related Products, ex. "Creo CAD"

---- Product Level Sub-Category - Specific PTC Product, ex. "Creo Parametric"

-------- Product Specific Subject Area (Board) - ex. "Pro/Toolkit" or "Pro/NC" (both under "Creo Parametric")

-------- Product Specific Ideas (if applicable for this product)

-------- Product Specific Blog (if applicable for this product)

 

Again, just to reiterate, for this to work everything other than the top level should be able to be subscribed to.  If someone subscribes to the product level sub-category, they should automatically get any content that is created underneath.  If someone only wants to subscribe to a product specific subject area (board), that too should be fully supported.

    37 replies

    3-Newcomer
    Oct 3, 2017 1:11 PM UTC

    I like the structure that Tom has laid out here.  It's logical and follows the products that PTC sells.  I realize this isn't necessarily comprehensive, but Creo Elements Direct and Creo Direct need their own subcategories under Creo CAD.

     

    Also, I don't think posts should be allowed at the top level or first sub category level.

    Oct 4, 2017 2:55 PM UTC

    I agree with Tom and Doug

    Community Manager
    Oct 26, 2017 11:12 PM UTC

    Hi, Champions,  I have been moving across the PTC organization working through some internal processes so we can put in our changes.  The major push for the changes and movement of content to different boards is going to begin the week of November 6th.   I will give a rundown soon on what those changes will look like.  As a heads up,  we are not going to be able to have separate "CREO Boards."  Our best practices review does mandate that we have to maintain boards that only have 5-10 posts per day.  That does mean that in order to hit that number we need to leave topics like Creo Parametric as a label in the discussion board area.  However, I am still going through the organization to find out how "ideas" are implemented at the product team level.  If there is a Product Manager responsible for soley these topics area (for example): 

     

    Creo Augmented Reality

    Creo Elements

    Creo Layout

    Creo Parametric

    Creo Simulate

    Creo Sketch

    Creo Schematics

    Creo Direct

     

    I will be able to set these up as categories or "buckets" so you can subscribe to only the ideas you want to see or comment on.

     

    Ultimately, the categories will be aligned with our product pipeline as suggested on the Community Refresh thread. 

     

    Another change is that we will no longer be able to support "siloed" conversations.  The old community on Jive had regional groups like "Addicted to Pro" or "Badgerland Group".  We need these conversations to happen in the greater community boards (i.e. Mathcad, CREO, Windchill).  I just wanted to give you a preview of what was coming.  I am working on the communication plan and execution of all this content move.  I will need advocates and voice of positivity to help me communicate this to our greater community.  I do have one action item for you (many actually 🙂 But, here is one more.  We need to revise our Community Blog space.  I need a place to provide continual Lithium release notes updates and changes to the communities to the greater community base.  What are your ideas for our naming convention???   What name would resonate with our users?  Community Connector   Your chance to get creative!  Any ideas?

    TomUAuthor
    Oct 31, 2017 5:55 PM UTC
    Another change is that we will no longer be able to support "siloed" conversations.  The old community on Jive had regional groups like "Addicted to Pro" or "Badgerland Group".  We need these conversations to happen in the greater community boards (i.e. Mathcad, CREO, Windchill).

    The broader community isn't going to be interested in announcements about meeting and agendas within the different regional user groups.  The end result is that these groups will just move their internal communications to a different medium.  (The local user group in my area already already moved their communication over to LinkedIn.)  Depending on your goals, this loss of traffic could be good or bad.  Either way, I hope this type of content doesn't start flooding the rest of the boards.

    Nov 1, 2017 11:06 AM UTC

    Houston PUG moved to LinkedIN also. I suspect PTC community became too restrictive.

    I prefer not to see anything more than an invitation to the regional group meeting within the overall community.

    Agendas, presenters, followups are really not something the overall Creo community wants to see a flood of notifications about.

    TomUAuthor
    Oct 30, 2017 1:24 PM UTC
    ... we are not going to be able to have separate "CREO Boards.

    There is some kind of disconnect going on here.  The current mess we have was created by previous community managers not understanding the differences between PTC's products.  Continuing to push a structure that doesn't align with the product offerings is just going further frustrate the user base and continue to perpetuate confusion.  You are literally making the community difficult to use.

     

     

    If there is a Product Manager responsible for solely these topics area (for example): 

     

    Creo Augmented Reality

    Creo Elements

    Creo Layout

    Creo Parametric

    Creo Simulate

    Creo Sketch

    Creo Schematics

    Creo Direct

     


    There are many different aspects to Creo Parametric with multiple project managers assigned to this one product.  Trying to lump all of the "Creo" ideas into a single area (like you are doing with the discussion boards) is only going to further clutter the ideas space and discourage engagement by the appropriate product managers.

     

    So frustrated.  Smiley Frustrated

    Oct 30, 2017 1:53 PM UTC

     I can certainly understand some areas being consolidated.

    CREO is not one software and I don't care how much PTC wants it to be known as "one thing".

    Creo Parametric, Creo direct, Creo simulate are VERY different programs. Lumping all that together in any form or fashion is a HUGE mistake.

    You are getting terrible advice.

    This is why the INDEPENDENT VOICE OF THE USER COMMUNITY is important. Void of corporate marketing.

    If the purpose of the community is to support the user base, you really need to listen to the user base.

     

    Oct 30, 2017 1:55 PM UTC

    Where's the poop emoji?

    poo.jpg

    Oct 30, 2017 4:15 PM UTC

    The bulk of the discussion in the Creo topic (both Creo modeling and Additional creo questions is about Creo parametric. The problem is we used to have the Jive forum that was reasonably setup. You can't see that anymore because it was completely destroyed in the move to lithium.

    We had this:

    CREO (referencing Creo Parametric) and users could post in it (unfortunately) with the several sub-categories (actual screenshot {credit @Dale_Rosema})

    categories.jpg

    Now we have 2 categories and unused labels.

    Make the community good for the users, not easy to manage for the administrators!

     

    @TomU has had some well thought out suggestions here. https://community.ptc.com/t5/PTC-Community-Refresh/Community-Structure-Suggestions/m-p/485669#M25

    At a miniumum, Creo Parametric needs to be it's own category with sub-levels for  modeling, Automation, analysis, manufacturing, administration (these were all popular until the lithium migration destroyed the structure)

     

    Creo Direct  (elements direct) needs to be separate outside of Creo parametric (it's a different program)

     

    3-Newcomer
    Oct 30, 2017 4:19 PM UTC

     

    @Jaime_Lee, can you elaborate or clarify some things?

     

    First, you use the words "board", "category", "label", "buckets" and "topics" and I'm not sure how that relates to the Lithium structure.  I know we have boards and sub-boards and labels in Litium.  Are there more things?  Can you be more specific, or at least educate me so I understand better?

     

    Second, Regarding this:

     


    @Jaime_Lee wrote:

    ...  As a heads up,  we are not going to be able to have separate "CREO Boards."  Our best practices review does mandate that we have to maintain boards that only have 5-10 posts per day.  That does mean that in order to hit that number we need to leave topics like Creo Parametric as a label in the discussion board area. ...


    Am I right in thinking that all of the Creo discussions are going to end up in one big area?  I cannot tell you how disappointing this is.  Creo Parametric, Creo Simulate and Creo Direct to name just a few all have very different user bases and command structure, as all of us have reiterated.  Creo Paratric, the software that started the company, is so diverse in itself that it may warrant multiple boards.  Yes, we can differentiate by labels within the boards, but there are well documented limitations to that from a user perspective.

     

    Also, I'm not sure what you are saying with the 5-10 posts per day and your internal policies.  Are you saying you don't want to create boards unless the topic is going to generate at least 5-10 post per day or that you don't want to create too many boards because even if it's only generating 5-10 posts per day you need to maintain it?  Either way, lumping unrelated topics together for the sake of streamlining back end maintenance would seem to only suppress participation due to dilution of the subject matter. To be blunt, I don't really care about your best practice policies, I want a forum that works for the user base.  If your policies get in the way of that, the policies are probably what needs to change.

     

    For example, if a user interested in Parametric modeling and the board traffic is 20% parametric and 80% other things, they may not stick around.  I've had users complain to me that all the posts now seem to be on things he has no interest in or knowledge of.  Not really the case, but it does feel that way and it's already driving users away.

     

    I mentioned that Parametric is what started this entire thing off.  At the start, Pro/Engineer (what Creo Parametric was originally called) was PTC's only product (it's what the P stands for after all).  The user base was established around it and PTC User was born to take care of those users.  Not long ago (OK, maybe 5-10 years) the PTCUser email exploders generated several hundred emails a day, most around what is now called Creo Parametric.  Even when the forums were moved to the PTC Community there would be ~100 emails about Creo Parametric per day. 

     

    That was largely true up until the move to Lithium.  Since, there are a few dozen in the Creo Modeling and Creo Additional boards and they are about Parametric, simulate, toolkit and other topics.  Traffic is way off since the move to Lithium.  There are a number of reasons for that, one being the haste in which it was implemented (and the numerous problems that came with that) and the lack of communication around it (which appeared to be largely due to the haste) but another is the diluted nature of the conversations now.  That dilution is directly related to the overly simple forum structure that came with the move to Lithium.  I think, or hope, that much of the activity can be brought back, but it's going to take some serious community engagement work to do so. 

     

    To be honest I'm getting concerned that PTC is seeing this community as more of a liability than an asset anymore and the needs of the users are taking a back seat. I hope not, because there was a lot of good will generated between PTC and the user base since the move from the independent PTCUser forums to the PTC Community. Frankly the move to Lithium has done great damage to that already.

    Community Manager
    Oct 30, 2017 6:05 PM UTC

    @@@@dgschaefer  I am sorry.  We definitely should put together a jive terminology to lithium terminology guide for the community.   I do have a tendency to speak in Lithium terms.  Let's look at the "Discussion Style"  Mathcad Questions for example:   This would be considered a Board.  This is what I am looking for 5-10 posts per day.  If inside that "board" we are getting 5-10 posts per day over x determined time period, there would be a benchmark that says our users are interested in ________topic and this topic can sustain its own board.  That another reason why the labels are very important.  I do not believe we have the correct labels set up.  For all the current boards, "Mathcad Questions, Windchill, CREO Modeling, and CREO Additional Questions (Which WILL BE RENAMED CREO General), we need the correct labels to be in the system for each "board" and possibly the threads re-edited to reflect these correct labels.  These 5-10 posts per day are not specific to PTC.  This is a benchmark across many industries that have communities.  I hear you about the Parametric Community and I am hoping that once we have this reorganization/architecture the dead or dropped off conversations will pick up again and we can relook at what our metrics are telling us and make some additional changes if the community proves to need more specific conversations. I have no issue with spinning out a board for a popular topic amongst community members. 

     

    Categories vs Buckets.....Sometimes categories are used during backend configuration which should not impact the end user (like yourself).  However, when we use (I use) the word category/bucket with an "end user" or community member I am generally referring to the idea exchange functionality.   The difficult thing  is that across any Lithium community the admin has the power to rename things any they want. See this Alteryx Idea Exchange.  What I have been calling idea exchange "categories" or "buckets" they decided on their admin console to call "Labels."

     

    Please take a look at their community:  https://community.alteryx.com/t5/Alteryx-Product-Ideas/idb-p/product-ideas. 

     

    We really just need a starting point to get this cleaned up and organized.  Regarding specifically CREO.  My thought is to have 2 Boards for Discussions

     

    Discussion Board 1:  CREO MODELING

    Labels TBD: <still need help with these>

     

    Discussion Board 2:  CREO General

     Suggested Labels (Still need to be approved by Product Line Managers).

     

    Creo Augmented Reality

    Creo Elements

    Creo Layout

    Creo Parametric

    Creo Simulate

    Creo Sketch

    Creo Schematics

    Creo Direct

     

    CREO Idea Exchange Buckets or Categories Alteryx "LABELS":  TBD

     

    Maybe this too, but I am not sure yet.  I need to make sure there like @TomU or another champion pointed out that these should be lined up with the internal PTC product mgr that can support them so they receive notifications that a user entered an idea to _________(bucket) to give their feedback. 

     

    Creo Augmented Reality

    Creo Elements

    Creo Layout

    Creo Parametric

    Creo Simulate

    Creo Sketch

    Creo Schematics

    Creo Direct

     

     

    I do appreciate the feedback. 

     

    Jaime_Lee

    TomUAuthor
    Oct 30, 2017 6:59 PM UTC

    We really just need a starting point to get this cleaned up and organized.  Regarding specifically CREO.  My thought is to have 2 Boards for Discussions

     

    Discussion Board 1:  CREO MODELING

    Labels TBD: <still need help with these>

     

    Discussion Board 2:  CREO General

     Suggested Labels (Still need to be approved by Product Line Managers).


    I don't know how else to say it.  This is BAD.  VERY, VERY BAD.

    You can't model in Creo.  You can't buy Creo.  Creo is not a product!!!

     

    Fundamentally the "Creo Modeling Questions" board IS "Creo Parametric Modeling", but the poor naming has allowed all kinds of completely unrelated stuff to clutter it up to the point that it's almost usable.  Everything "Creo sounding" is getting dumped in there because these other (similar sounding but completely unrelated) products don't have their own dedicated spaces.

     

    Low traffic volume does not justify mixing unrelated products with a different single product that has high traffic volume.  If you can't bring yourself to make a dedicated category (or sub-category) for each product, then at least create a dedicated category for Creo Parametric.  It has by far the vast majority of the traffic and the sub-topics underneath Creo Parametric need to be broken up by discussion board, NOT by just labels or tags.

     

    Creo Parametric    [Category]

    --- 2D Drawings     [Discussion Board]

    --- Automation       [Discussion Board]

    --- Modeling           [Discussion Board]

    --- Administration   [Discussion Board]

    --- Assembly          [Discussion Board]

    --- Manufacturing   [Discussion Board]

     

    Other Creo Products  [Category]

    --- Creo Elements   [Discussion Board]

    --- Creo Sketch       [Discussion Board]

    --- Creo Simulate    [Discussion Board]