CREO Community Structure Suggestions
I've presented this before but I've reworked it again to better align with the capabilities (and limitations) of Lithium. I believe this is all possible.
------------------------------------------------------------
"Creo" and "Windchill" are way to broad and span way to many, completely unrelated products. The current setup causes lots of confusion (Creo Parametric vs. Creo Direct and PDMLink vs. WPA). I would strongly suggest that the top level groups or categories align with the broader PTC product areas. For example:
- Creo CAD
- Creo Simulate
- Creo View
- Integrity
- Servigistics
- Thingworx
- Windchill PDM & Process
- Windchill Quality
By design, these top level categories are simply collectors for organizing the sub-categories underneath them. These top level categories should not have their own discussion boards, blogs, or ideas. They should not be able to be subscribed directly to.
At the next level down, break out into the more popular/common products. Again, users come to the community to interact about a product. I think it's very important that the community reflect this reality (and help get both people and content into the right areas.) For example:
Creo CAD (top level category)
- Creo Layout (product specific sub-category)
- Creo Illustrate
- Creo Options Modeler
- Creo Parametric
- Other Extensions
Windchill PDM & Process (top level category)
- Windchill FlexPLM (product specific sub-category)
- Windchill MPMLink
- Windchill PartsLink
- Windchill PDM Essentials
- Windchill PDMLink
- Windchill ProjectLink
Each of these product specific sub-categories should be able to be subscribed to and followed without having to subscribe to anything else at a lower level (if so desired.)
Within each of these products (or sub-categories) we then add discussion boards to further separate content by subject matter (within a product). For example, here are my suggestions for Creo Parametric discussion boards:
- 2D Drawings
- Modeling
- Automation (Relations, Pro/Program, Drawing Program)
- Customization (J-Link, VBAPI, Toolkit, etc.)
- Sheetmetal
- Mechanism
- Assembly
*** For this to work, we MUST be able to directly subscribe to these boards (or subject matter areas.) There are many, many people who want to subscribe and follow only certain subject areas within a product. (For example, automation or customization.) Without the ability to subscribe to the appropriate subject matter area, they either miss content they are interested in or get overwhelmed with a lot of other content they'e not interested in (even though the other content is still about the same product.) Based on the limitations of the Lithium platform, these cannot be labels, they must be discussion boards.
Finally, since there are too many PTC products to give every one of them their own product level sub-category, it might make more sense to keep the Creo Parametric Extensions as just boards (subject matter areas) under a shared, product-specific sub-category (at least until their traffic justifies having its own sub-category.) For example, these:
- Creo Advanced Assembly Extension (AAX)
- Creo Advanced Framework Extension (AFX)
- Creo Advanced Rendering Extension (ARX)
- Creo Behavioral Modeling Extension (BMX)
- Creo Collaboration Extensions
- Creo Complete Machining Extension
- Creo Complete Mold Design Extension
- Creo Computer-Aided Verification Extension
- Creo Design Exploration Extension (DEX)
- Creo Distributed Batch Extension
- Creo ECAD-MCAD Collaboration Extension
- Creo Expert Moldbase Extension
- Creo Flexible Modeling Extension (FMX)
- Creo Intelligent Fastener Extension (IFX)
- Creo Manikin Extension
- Creo NC Sheetmetal Extension
- Creo Piping and Cabling Extension
- Creo Prismatic and Multi-Surface Milling Extension
- Creo Production Machining Extension
- Creo Progressive Die Extension (PDX)
- Creo Reverse Engineering Extension (REX)
- Creo Tool Design Extension
(Sorry, I don't know the three letter abbreviation for all of these. Also, it might make sense to drop the words "Creo" and "Extension" from the label names.)
The end result is something that looks like this (this is just an example of Creo CAD and is not complete):
Creo CAD (category)
Creo Layout (sub-category)
- Creo Layout (discussion board)
- Creo Layout (ideas)
- Creo Layout (blog)
Creo Illustrate (sub-category)
- Creo Illustrate (discussion board)
- Creo Illustrate (ideas)
- Creo Illustrate (blog)
Creo Optons Modeler (sub-category)
- Creo Options Modeler (discussion board)
- Creo Options Modeler (ideas)
- Creo Options Modeler (blog)
Creo Parametric (sub-category)
- 2D Drawings (discussion board)
- Automation (discussion board)
- Modeling (discussion board)
- Administration (discussion board)
- Creo Parametric (ideas)
-
2D Drawings (label)
- Automation (label)
- Modeling (label)
- Administration (label)
-
- Creo Parametric (blog)
-
2D Drawings (label)
- Automation (label)
- Modeling (label)
- Administration (label)
-
Creo Parametric Extensions (sub-category)
-
AAX (discussion board)
- BMX (discussion board)
- IFX (discussion board)
- PDX (discussion board)
For some products the structure will be very shallow. For others (like Creo), the structure will be much deeper, and frankly should be due to the large user base and wide range of topics. To summarize, the community structure conceptually should look like this:
Top Level Category - Group of Related Products, ex. "Creo CAD"
---- Product Level Sub-Category - Specific PTC Product, ex. "Creo Parametric"
-------- Product Specific Subject Area (Board) - ex. "Pro/Toolkit" or "Pro/NC" (both under "Creo Parametric")
-------- Product Specific Ideas (if applicable for this product)
-------- Product Specific Blog (if applicable for this product)
Again, just to reiterate, for this to work everything other than the top level should be able to be subscribed to. If someone subscribes to the product level sub-category, they should automatically get any content that is created underneath. If someone only wants to subscribe to a product specific subject area (board), that too should be fully supported.
