Skip to main content
Mar 16, 2011 9:39 PM UTC

Learning direct modeling

When you are following this blog, you will have noticed that I like to pick up the “big” topics in the industry and try to explore different viewpoints. Leaving the tech talk to the experts, I am more interested in how people react to market changes, stay on top of the latest industry trends, and -- as in the following case --  manage to adapt to new market situations, such as learning new things… like a new modeling paradigm.

At PTC, we have a huge global team of Application Engineers (AEs), who know their products in and out and give technical guidance to prospects and customers during all stages of the sales cycle. Historically, most of them are experts of either Creo Elements/Pro (formerly Pro/ENGINEER) or Creo Elements/Direct (formerly CoCreate). Through the acquisition of CoCreate in 2007, the “Direct Modeling” experts’ team has been integrated into the PTC landscape, but there had been little need for shuffling responsibilities and investing time into training parametric AEs to learn direct modeling or vice versa.

This, of course, has changed when we started defining our Creo strategy. Many AEs have undergone product training to be proficient in both paradigms and give a full Creo demo.

Being curious by nature, I was wondering how this process was for our AEs and started asking around for volunteers to do a little interview. Direct modeling has the reputation of being easy to use – but how is it to learn when you have worked parametrically for a decade or two? Is the change as drastic as the migration from 2D to 3D?

So I had scheduled a phone interview with Iain Lewis, Principal Application Engineer in the UK. I explained to him what kind of information I was looking for and asked him to send me a few bullets by email so I could write up the article. A few hours later, I got this rather long email full of good information that I decided to abandon the interview style, and post it here in its entirety.

Thanks, Iain, this is great insight and a good best practice. All others: I hope you will enjoy reading as much as I did!

“I have been using Creo Elements/Pro (formerly Pro/ENGINEER) for 15 years and it was my first exposure to any form of 3D CAD. With this is mind I have only ever worked within the context of parametric CAD. This first exposure was within the world of oil and gas extraction technologies in the form of valve and pipeline design.

Creo Elements/Pro was ideally suited to the needs of this industry as everything was based upon product families and product configurations. Everything was the same, but either a different size or a different configuration. Creo Elements/Pro really enabled us to manage this design variation and product families easily. What was always difficult was managing ad hoc change and change of ‘design intent’.

Over the past couple of months I have started to work in the “direct” space in the context of Creo Elments/Direct Modeling 17.0. This has been a massive eye opener when considering flexibility and what I would like to coin as ‘on the fly design intent’.

When working with any parametric modeler you are, from the start, thinking about the features you need to generate the geometry and how you want that geometry to be controlled in the future. Often this is not known or design intent changes later within the design process. I see the true benefit of direct modeling is that you don’t have to think about this upfront, you can think about it downstream and then build it accordingly.

Prior to starting down this path I realised that there would be a pretty significant change in the philosophy about building geometry, I would even go so far as to say that this change in philosophy is as big as going from 2D design to 3D design.

With this in mind and ensuring that I focused on what direct would be good at, I started by thinking about what is challenging in parametric modeling.

The list I came up with included

  • modification of imported geometry
  • late stage design change

  • changing many components at once without having prebuilt relationships and

  • new user ease of use.

This list proved to be invaluable and I would recommend this to any user looking at this different geometry creation method. This really enabled me to focus on the benefits of the new tool and not dwell on performing the same actions in the direct space that I previously performed in the parametric space.

I would like to dwell on these points:

Working with imported geometry This really is a failing when working in the parametric space and a massive benefit in the direct space. Whenever you open, for example an IGES file, in the parametric space there are very limited changes that you can make to the geometry, you can add features but changing the geometry is difficult. In the direct space, because it is ‘just geometry’, you can change it as you like. The direct tool doesn’t mind where the geometry has come from. This really means that you can truly reuse this information.

Late stage design change Often in the design process there will be late stage unforeseen changes. Within the parametric space this often causes all sorts of problems because the models do not have the inbuilt intelligence to be changed in the required way, with the direct methodology the design intelligence can be built at any time, in many different ways to enable this change.

Changing many components Selection with working within the direct environment is key to modifying existing geometry. Depending upon what you select and the way in which you select it can result in vastly differing characteristics when you implement a change on the geometry. These selection techniques also allow you to select geometry on multiple components at once and change geometry on multiple components at once. This is great when changing for example a shaft, washer, bearing, etc. These can selected with a single action and they can all be changed in a single action.

Ease of use This is always a funny objection as ease of use can mean so many different things. I, for example, find Creo Elements/Pro very, very easy to use because I’ve been using it for so long. Having said that, however, when using parametric modeling, the way in which geometry is created and modified is abstract, i.e. via features and parameters. When working in the direct space you simply select the geometry and change it.

In summary, now that I have started learning how to utilise the direct modeling approach I can see that there are many benefits. This is not to say that it is the panacea as there are capabilities which I will always want in the parametric world that are not present within the direct space. In my opinion, the panacea in the future would be an environment whereby I can have the best of both worlds, i.e. the flexibility of the direct approach but also the constrained parametric approach.”

Have you got any questions for Iain? Did you make similar experiences when exploring direct modeling? Let us know!

Bettina

PS: If you would like to try out direct modeling yourself, take a look at the free for lifetime edition of Creo Elements/Direct Modeling PE.

PPS: I lied when I said I didn't change Iain's answers to my questions: I changed the spelling of "direct modelling" to "direct modeling" for consistency reasons. I hope the readers in the UK & Ireland can forgive me...