Skip to main content
Jul 21, 2011 7:45 AM UTC

Engineering & Bananas

This post is for Greg Frankland –


Greg, thanks for your suggestion. You actually picked an easy topic as there is a ton to say about engineering in the food sector. We have even sponsored an episode of the Product Design Show on engineering.com recently where we featured a couple of Creo Elements/Direct customers and how they used the product to design their food processing equipment…


'Bananas' photo (c) 2006, gailf548 - license: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0/When I read your suggestion, however, what immediately came into my mind was fruit picking! Maybe because I own a garden myself and now, in summer, am going through a busy time picking fruits and vegetables, cleaning, and cooking marmalade.


I did a quick search to see if “banana picking machine” would bring up anything. Thinking about all the creepy animals that usually live in the regions where bananas grow, I thought having a machine to do the actual picking on the plantation would be desirable...


Instead I found that some automation exists for various fruits. Fruit picking overall still seems to be a very manual process which involves high labor cost. Thus, many farmers would certainly welcome a higher degree of automation.


Although being a total layman in this field, I ad hoc see a couple of design challenges here:

  • Not all fruit can be picked at the same time – some may be not yet be ripe when others are: this would require sensors to check color, softness etc. of the fruit.
  • Fruit needs to be handled with care, stress marks will not be a problem when the fruit is meant for further processing, but nobody buys a banana with black marks. Again, this sounds like super high-tech to me…
  • On the other hand, the equipment would need to be very robust as it would have to work in all weather conditions, dust and dirt.
  • Maintenance must be easy – farm staff may certainly be able to fix mechanic components, but E&HT components would certainly be trickier to handle.

Just from taking a look at the above bullets, such a design would require a high degree of customization depending on the fruit, the climate, the size of farm, etc. and would certainly be very costly.


I have seen a couple of examples of machines when I looked this up – maybe some of you have worked on such a design? Feel free to share your designs and comment.


I look forward to hearing from you!


Bettina

P.S. Don’t forget to suggest a new topic!

    1 reply

    Jul 21, 2011 11:44 AM UTC

         Nice Post! Like you said, there are so many variables in fruit that automating the harvest may be quite difficult. Between the fragility of the produce and the subjective ripeness inspections, it would be a complicated task to get a perfect fruit to market without blemish.

         Around here in Indiana there are a lot of corn and bean fields, and they are always picked late in the summer/ early fall. With these products though, the grains are so hard that they would be less likely to be damaged with the machinery. I guess that is one of the factors that allow them to harvest the grains with the machinery.

    Thanks for the post!

    -Greg