Skip to main content
1月 26, 2017 10:41 上午 UTC
问题

GD&T Advisor

Hello Everybody in our MBD Team

Who uses the GD&T advisor productively and/or has gained experience in Tests?
Waiting for some information...thx

    6回复

    3月 17, 2017 7:48 上午 UTC

    Hi Jürgen,
    we use the GD&T advisor, but only in a pilot stage.
    What sort of infos are you looking for?

    jganter作者
    3月 17, 2017 8:19 上午 UTC

    Hi Constantin
    thanks for your response, we want to start a pilot stage also. I want to know, if someone has completed the pilot stage and have a result what’s good and what still doesn’t work. That will be great, so I can focus my tests and my request.

     

    5月 12, 2017 3:14 下午 UTC

    Hello Jürgen,

    we implemented the GD&T advisor for our tool design department because they were asked to start using GD&T in their part models. The first impression of the GD&T advisor was that it more easy to use this tool to bring GD&Ts to the 3D model instead of using the default Creo functionality to do that. Currently the users stopped using the GD&T advisor tool because some types of GD&Ts were not possible to create with this tool. They moved back to the Creo basic functionality because of these limitations. As the GD&T advisor is only able to use the functionality that ist implementet in Creo to put GD&Ts to the 3D model it seems to be clear that this tool can not enable the user to have more than the creo functionality but it can have less than that.

    As the functionality to attach GD&Ts to the 3D model was completly overworked for Creo 4.0 it should be easier to do this work without the GD&T advisor if the user knows what he wants to communicate with these GD&T. Maybe it is useful to do a final plausibility check at the end. Here comes another limitation because the communication between Creo and the GD&T advisor is not optimized right now. If a GD&T was created with Creo basic functionality it is always complicated to switch to the GD&T advisor functionaltiy because the tool has a problem with the existing GD&Ts. (this communication should be gone with Creo 4.0 M050 as Raphael communicated to us during his presentation)

    We also had some issues with mirrored parts, more component parts (which are an assembly in this case).

    jganter作者
    5月 15, 2017 6:06 上午 UTC

    Hi Oliver

    thanks for your response, this is one sheet i added in the global list requirements.

    For me and a possible rollout of GD&T a disaster that Creo core annotation and GD&T can not communicate with each other.

    5月 15, 2017 6:44 上午 UTC

    Hi Jürgen,

    yes this might be the reason why they do not use the GD&T Advisor anymore but this should be fixed with Creo 4.0 M050 as I said before - currently this is not working very well. So this is in preperation to be fixed.