Skip to main content
Mar 7, 2015 4:34 AM UTC
Question

Who is the product line manager for printing in Creo 3?

ryankelley‌, pmaraninchi‌, or any of the champions,

Do any of you know who the product line manager is for Creo, specifically for printing?

There are very serious issues with printing in Creo 3. I've done a ton of testing (both with released and unreleased development code) and I'd like share this information with someone on the management side. It's really hard to work through "big picture" issues with tech support.

I'll be super nice. I promise.

Thanks!

    10 replies

    Mar 9, 2015 1:26 PM UTC

    I'm not sure who that would be, but can you describe the issues you're seeing so that we can go to the team with more than just a request to connect? I'm sure Tmetcalf and pmaraninchi would also be interested in your feedback so that they can bring it to the Technical Support side of the equation.

    Mar 10, 2015 9:12 AM UTC

    TomUminn,

    ryankelley‌is correct. Please open a case with TS to report the problems you are facing in a formal way. if those are defects, we need to escalate them to R&D for proper fixing.

    Please share the case number once you have it and I'll ask the right Tech Support engineer to work on it

    Meanwhile, I'll start asking who is the right PM as I don't know who is in charge of this topic from the top of my head.

    TomUAuthor
    Mar 10, 2015 4:14 PM UTC

    Thanks guys. Over the last 3 1/2 years I've opened more than 200 cases with tech support. 100 of those were in the last 6 months and 50 of them were just in January and February alone after switching to Creo 3. (I'm really starting to feel like I work for PTC's QA department.) Through these many cases I've learned that tech support does best with one narrowly defined issue at a time. I've also learned that providing a video and every possible log and debug file right off the bat stops most of the WebEx sessions and "I can't reproduce that" problems. I'm to the point now where most of my cases go straight to SPR filing. This is good. Now if I can just figure out how to move to the next level where most of my SPR's actually make it to fixes, I will be very, very happy.

    I do have a case open right now with tech support for one specific aspect of printing (C12372227). The problem is, the overall behavior is so messed up that I feel it would be better to have a conversation directly with the product manager instead. I truly can't fathom how this ever made it through the QA department.

    It takes a lot of work to document each specific problem, create a separate case, and then talk to 5 different tech support people about the same set of interrelated issues. If that's what I need to do, then I will, but I'm hoping to move up the food chain a bit and make sure I really understand the intended functionality ("working to spec") before creating all these separate cases. There is more here than just fixing one specific problem, but rather how these different pieces are supposed to work together.

    I wrote this to someone the other day:

    I feel there are many different competing requirements. One person codes one little piece and someone else codes another little piece, but no one is stepping back and asking if the total solution is really any good.

    This was the reply:

    Over the years I've come to the conclusion that whoever is in charge of output at ptc doesn't actually know much about output. Like - The postscript output should have round end segments; a simple thing to do so the default lettering isn't borked, but for 20+years they can't change 2 numbers in the postscript header.

    The shaded output in ps was offset from the coordinates of the HLR output so they didn't directly overlay. Same scale, just offset. I wrote a script to fix that so that the shaded images could have edges marked. Why were they offset? Same screen, same picture, just not the same for no good reason.

    We had Gerber file output for a long while, then one release they decided to ignore aperture assignments, making the output useless. You better believe they charged 'maintenance' for the special Plotter license that included Gerber, but they didn't deliver anything for it.

    It's pretty certain when the simple stuff is broken for decades that no one in charge either knows or cares. Would not be surprised it's getting worse.

    That seems harsh, but after testing it doesn't seem far off. Again, I truly can't fathom how this ever made it through the QA department.

    Here is a screenshot of the simple testing I've done so far:

    CP3_Printing.PNG

    Here is a document I put together to try to explain some of the interrelated issues:

    --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

    Creo Parametric 3.0 – Printing Issues

    Summary of Problems

    • Paper orientation is NOT controlled or set from the plotter config file (PCF).
    • Paper orientation is NOT based on the currently active drawing sheet.
    • Paper orientation can ONLY being set by the user interactively.
    • Paper orientation is modal.
    • Modal setting is not applied (effective) unless the paper dialog is opened and “OK” is selected. (Fixed in Creo 3.0 M030+)
    • “Landscape” doesn’t mean “paper long dimension is width”
    • “Portrait” doesn’t mean “paper long dimensions is height”
    • Rather, “portrait” means “rotate the selected paper size 90 degrees”. “Landscape” means, “don’t rotate”.
    • This means if a "portrait" paper size is defined, "landscape" orientation has to be selected so it doesn't get rotated.
    • Changing the orientation from "landscape" to "portrait" doesn't swap the paper dimensions like the sheet size dialog does. (This may or may not be intentional, but it is not consistent with drawing sheets.)

    There seems to be two ways to fix the problem, either set the paper orientation via the PCF file or set the paper orientation based on the current drawing sheet. I greatly prefer the second solution.

    1. Set the paper orientation via the PCF file

    Pros:

    • This seems to agree with the intent of the "paper" settings dialog – to select the paper size and orientation the drawing will be plotted on.
    • The PCF file can already control the paper size. Controlling the orientation from the PCF file seems logical.

    Cons:

    • A separate PCF file will be needed for each sheet size orientation – one for landscape and one for portrait.
    • Landscape and Portrait oriented drawings will now require separate plotter config files.
    • Landscape drawings sent to portrait oriented paper do not print properly.
    • Portrait drawings sent to landscape oriented paper do not print properly.
    • There is no way for Creo to automatically select the correct plotter config based on sheet orientation.
    • If the plotter is capturing the Postscript for use electronically (PDF, etc.), the Postscript orientation will be incorrect any time the drawing orientation doesn’t agree with the sheet orientation. For example, when a landscape oriented drawing is output to a portrait sheet, the PDF created will be oriented vertically (portrait) instead of horizontally (landscape).

    2. Set the paper orientation based on the current drawing sheet (my preference)

    Pros:

    • A single plotter config file can continue to be used for each paper size (like Wildfire 5).
    • The Postscript data output will always be oriented correctly (the paper is automatically rotated to agree with the drawing vs. the other way around).
    • A drawing could still be set to output opposite its sheet’s orientation by changing the orientation dropdown, but this should not be kept modal. It should always
      reset to the drawing’s orientation each time print mode is started or a different printer (PCF) is selected. [This is how virtually all other software works. If you change printers you have to reselect “landscape” or “portrait” if you want something other than what the item is.]

    Cons:

    • Can’t think of any….

    --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

    Just to be clear, I'm not complaining about tech support, or how this specific case is being handled. Rather, I want to properly understand how it's all supposed to work, make sure someone is actually looking at the big picture, and then help in whatever way I can to get it all working properly.

    Thanks!