Skip to main content
Sep 29, 2014 5:50 PM UTC
Question

Welcome and Please Introduce Yourself

Good day everyone,

Welcome to the PTC Community Champions program and our private Group! You have all been chosen because of your product knowledge and your willingness to share it with other Community members - thank you!

In order to break the ice, please take a moment to share somethings about yourself with the Group; as much or as little as you feel comfortable.

Toby Metcalf

I grew up in a small town in Central NY - Skaneatles, but have circled the globe and have lived in England as well as the Philippines.

My hobbies (in addition to on-line communities) are my 3 children, hockey, and cooking.

Twitter @Toby_Metcalf (technolgy - Social Media) @TMetcalf44 (Food & Wine).

Best,

Toby

    20 replies

    Sep 29, 2014 8:25 PM UTC

    Well, I grew up in the UK and New Zealand, and have also lived in Germany and now the US. I have also circled the globe, on a ship, including sailing through both the Suez and Panama canals. Although I was so young when I did that I don't remember any of it, so it doesn't count for much as a "life experience" (I don't remember anything about NZ either) .

    I have travelled a lot in Asia, and went to the Phillipines once for a conference. On Palawan of all places.

    Sep 30, 2014 3:33 PM UTC

    I think I should add a little more about my background, rather than just "I've travelled a lot". My background is as a physicist, but I am currently involved in both science and engineering in the area of spectroscopy (specifically, vibrational spectroscopy, for anyone that cares ). I do engineering design, algorithm design, data analysis, and even business and marketing. In that capacity I use a number of tools, including CAD (Sorry, Solidworks), optical ray tracing software, and several very specialzed packages. But one tool I use extensively, across almost everything that I do, is Mathcad. I use other math tools as well, but for most math related tasks the whiteboard interface of Mathcad makes it by far the best choice. I've had a couple of consulting companies for the last 7 years (so Mike, if you are going to get involved in consulting I could help get you started. Just PM me if you are interested.), but they are not very active right now because I currently have a new company that actually designs and builds spectrometers. We are just about ready to launch our first product .

    Sep 29, 2014 9:04 PM UTC

    I use the basic Creo parametric package for my business and enjoy the challenges this forum brings me.

    My hope is that this forum remains a successful vehicle for users to get the most out of their PTC products and help PTC understand what users deal with on a daily basis.

    What more can I say than what is posted here: Hero of the Month: Antonius Dirriwachter

    Richard too wears the badge... Hero of the Month: Richard Jackson

    ...As does Brian - Hero of the Month: Brian Martin

    ...and others!

    Sep 29, 2014 9:45 PM UTC

    Hi Everyone...

    Great to see PTC is putting together a group of Champions that have already put their time and energy into helping build this site. My entire reason for being here was to help people better understand how to milk every last ounce of power out of Creo (Pro/E). Over the years I just got really tired of hearing how "Pro/E can't do this... or that" when I knew better. Worse, PTC tech support has been legendarily horrifyingly bad and that gives the product a bad name.

    When I discovered PTC Community, my hope was that we'd gather some hardcore power users here... and draw others to visit. Over the years, that's definitely happened. Still, I feel like there's much more that can come from this online forum. I'm looking forward to hearing about some of the changes in store for the future- and contributing to making the site better.

    As for me personally... hobbies? Pfft... work, school, family. There's really not time for anything else! I'm spending my time doing what I love... and there's comfort in that, right?

    Sep 29, 2014 10:17 PM UTC

    Honored to be in among such esteemed company

    I recently "retired" but only to change things up hope to be working a lot for a lot more years (I'm 58). Was happy at Alcon Labs, but we were acquired by Novartis and many changes were imposed. Chief among these was moving our group from R&D to corporate IT, in a group that had no idea what PLM and CAD and less appreciation for what they mean to an organization.

    Ok - enough griping and on to positive things...

    From the first day that experienced Pro/E in 1993 and fell in love with parametric modeling, thru similar experiences with Windchill many years later, it's been a labor of love immersing myself in PTC software for all these years. Have spent countless nights / weekends on my own time learning / studying / trying things / mastering various elements of it. I was a decent Pro/E user back thru WF4 but for the past 9 years have focused 99% on Windchill and Oracle.

    I retired without any plan at all for what to do going forward. Currently doing a few consulting jobs part time and considering carefully what to attempt for the future.

    Have traveled what I consider to be quite a bit, but no where near what others are relating. Happy to not spend too much more time in airports / hotels.

    Happy to have 3 wonderful grandsons now and a pretty relaxed life. Hobbies: Snowboarding when my sons can get away, surfing, piano.

    Looking forward to great things from this group.

    Sep 30, 2014 2:35 AM UTC

    Well, I'm pretty sure I've been at this for less time than the rest of you, but I'm more than willing to share whatever I can.

    In 2004 I made a career move from videoconferencing and multimedia system design and installation to tool and die design. This was my first exposure to PTC products and at the time there were just 4 of us running Wildfire. As I learned the software I quickly found that I really enjoyed the automation side of things. I loved figuring out how to create complex library parts that were fully automatic yet simple for the end users to duplicate and configure. It also wasn't long before we got tired of yelling over the wall while attempting to do concurrent design that led to my installing and configuring Intralink 3.4. What an improvement!

    In 2011 I switched jobs again and joined Trans-Matic. Here we have a design engineering department of 11 in the US and 3 in China. I get to wear many hats including CAD admin, Windchill system admin, and IT guy (for all engineering related systems). I love it! My major focus of late has been to move Windchill beyond just a CAD vault to something that can be used to help guide and control our business processes.

    On the personal side of things, I live in West Michigan with my wife and 7 kids (3 - 13). As the kids increased, the hobbies decreased to the point where my kids, church, and work are all that's left. Fortunately I really like my job, so that almost feels like a hobby. Travel wise I've been to maybe half the states in the US and a few different countries in Europe.

    I'm really looking forward to learning from this group and the rest of the community as a whole. Not sure how many of you make it out to PTC Live Global each year, but I've attended the past 2 and really enjoyed it! Maybe if there are enough of us we can have a 'Champions' get together some night. (I know Mike likes lobster.)

    Sep 30, 2014 2:54 AM UTC

    Wow - 7 kids. I come from a family of 7 (we're not close). We have two sons and now 3 grandsons - keeps us plenty busy. My hat's off to you for keeping up w/all.

    Sep 30, 2014 2:00 PM UTC

    Hello Everyone,

    I have been working with Windchill since 2004 (except 2 years of FT masters degree). I usurp all the knowledge shared across the Windchill community. I share my knowledge when/where possible, but very little. Oftentimes, time needed to articulate a complete response/solution is an obstacle for me. I joined this community with a purpose to share knowledge and increase my involvement by helping others.... very much looking forward to it.

    Sep 30, 2014 7:53 PM UTC

    Thanks for your contributions, everyone, and a special thanks to Toby Metcalf for "championing" the efforts to assemble such a great group of community contributors (pun intended). Toby and I have been working on plans to develop a group of PTC Community "MVPs" since he joined the company this past spring and I'm excited to see this group come together to help our knowledge sharing efforts.

    A little about me - I've been with PTC for exactly one year (today) and in a previous life did product marketing and community management for several video games companies and startups here in the Boston area. I'm also the manager and lead vocalist for a Justin Timberlake tribute band, 'The Timberfakes'. We just wrapped on our latest show in NYC and if you're ever in the Boston-area you should drop me a line to see if we're playing around town.

    Looking forward to more as we continue to roll out the Champions program!

    Oct 1, 2014 3:57 PM UTC

    Wow. This looks like a pretty good team with a very impressive collective experience!

    Wrapping up the series of introductions on the PTC side : I’ve been with PTC for….a while. I started as a Technical Support engineer based in France in ‘99, supporting Windchill 2.1. (BTW, I still have a Windchill 1.0 Installation manual in mint condition if someone is interested ).

    Since then, I had several positions in PTC Tech Support, including a 3 years assignment in the US in our Needham headquarters where I had the pleasure to meet Mike in person.

    Knowledge sharing and collaboration have always been two of my areas of focus through my career, that’s why I am really happy to be in charge of our global Knowledge Management program (the Support Knowledge Base) and Community engagement program (you might have noticed that some Tech Support engineers are more involved in PTC Community recently).

    When I am not at PTC, I spend time with my 2 daughters (5 and 1), cook and eat a lot, play the ukulele and “do stuff with my computer”...

    Oct 1, 2014 4:33 PM UTC

    Hi Pierre...

    Welcome! I gave a ton of input into the new PTC Tech Support portal. I think the new system is much better than the old one. It's good to have you on board.

    On thing I did want to add, though. Since you brought it up... yes, there have been more PTC Tech Support people posting on the PTC Community. Personally, the jury's still out on how I feel about this. I think the original plan of having the support techs leave a "light footprint" on the community is the right way to go.

    Many, many, people already think this site is nothing but an extension of tech support... and that it's staffed by nothing but PTC "shills" and cronies trying to keep up the corporate image. That's never been the case- but the perception is out there. Having too many PTC people on the boards only perpetuates that perception... and lends creedence to those who criticize the Community for being nothing but Tech Support 2.0.

    Since we're speaking privately, I can be honest. PTC Tech Support is really poor until you get into the far upper reaches of experienced personnel. The first two levels of tech support are nothing to be proud of. All it takes to be at that first level is for someone to regurgitate the questionably "accurate" information from the knowledgebase. The second level isn't much to write home about either.

    Within just the past few months, I've had PTC tech support give me or my people bad or outright incorrect guidance. The beauty of PTC Community is that in a huge number of instances, we have been able to help when tech support could not. There have to be at least a hundred threads on here where the community members have solved issues PTC's own personnel could not. This is because Community members have to live and breathe this software every single day. We don't have the luxury of shrugging it off when the software won't perform... or when we have a deadline and need to "do something" the software doesn't want to do.

    There are surely times when we need PTC's input and when guidance from a greatly experienced PTC developer or tech support expert are needed. These threads are easy to find... people usually outright ask for PTC to chime in. Still, I am concerned about too many PTC people jumping in for numerous reasons:

    • Will we be getting opinions and advice from the same people who routinely give out bad advice on tech support tickets?
    • Will too much PTC involvement damage the credibility of a 'crowd-sourced' portal for support? With too much involvement, people will turn back to the mail exploder.

    I think we have a good thing going with PTC Community... and I think there's a place for limited PTC involvement. But for PTC, the real value in this community is not in jumping in to answer questions. Unless we're at a hard stop or there's a true ace PTC representative available to chime in, the real value is in listening to the voices of people in the Community.

    I am reminded of something my wife says all the time- "I don't want you to fix every problem I come to you with... sometimes I just want you to listen!" This is the perfect example of that. When you have a thread with 100+ responses called "JUST SWITCHED TO CREO 2 AND I HATE IT!!!!!!", that should get someone's attention. The greatest criticism PTC ever receives is not that the company does not do enough to "help", it's that the company doesn't listen to customers. That leads to the perception that, because it doesn't listen, the company does not care about customers.

    Case in point... the current discussion thread in the Diamond Members Lounge regarding Mathcad. PTC will possibly be getting around to incorporating missing and needed features from Mathcad v15 at Prime 5.0?!? Seriously, 5 . 0 ... and that's not even definite? This is a perfect example of PTC not listening to customers... people are screaming to get their old v15 functions back and yet it's just not much of a priority!

    The best way for PTC to demonstrate it actually cares is to reach out to customers and listen. In fact, quit helping me so much... I get better answers on my own most times. Quit helping me with new interfaces and dashboards I never asked for. Quit programming new things into the software no engineer in the trenches ever asked for. Instead, listen to the chorus of long-time customers who are at their wits end trying to get PTC's attention to address long standing issues. Show how much you want to listen... and how much you value the input of those people... and you'll turn the tide of public perception.

    You may just also start to regain market share from competitors who love to play off the perception that PTC is a corps of elitists who don't listen.

    Anyway, that turned into a mini rant and it wasn't intended that way. I apologize for going off the rails. But if we can't be candid here among friends, I think we're missing an opportunity to do something truly worthwhile with this site.

    TmetcalfAuthor
    Oct 2, 2014 1:02 PM UTC

    Build it, and they will come.

    A phrase that has been proven true by this thread

    Again everyone, welcome and thank you for your comments and examples. Looks like we have some homework to do - we will be posting some replys to the points made later today.

    Best,

    Toby

    Oct 3, 2014 7:17 AM UTC

    I’m glad I introduced myself … it would have been a shame to miss all of this feedback, thanks a lot guys. I want to reassure you, this is not a hostile takeover bid. As Brian pointed out, customers know more about advanced product usage than Tech Support, and we know it. You guys use our software day-in, day-out, while we are good at understanding how it works (or why it does not in some cases).

    I really like Brian’s wife’s comment “I don't want you to fix every problem I come to you with... sometimes I just want you to listen!” and believe it’s a fair statement.

    Switching to “Tech Support is really poor” and “PTC is not listening”, we know we have issues (hey, admitting we have a problem is the 1st of the 12 steps). We now have to prove that not only we listen, but we also understand and take actions (even if sometimes we will say “sorry, can’t do”). These changes are happening in TS and I know Ryan is also working with other departments (like PM or R&D) to drive similar changes there too.

    Lastly, search and Knowledge Base. First of all, I want to thank Tom for the positive feedback. Improving quality/quantity/accessibility of knowledge available for customers has been one of my priorities over the past 4 years and I am glad we made your life easier. Yogesh is correct when he says that “we are not sharing everything”. More than half of our articles are not visible to customers (yet) because we don’t think they are “good enough” to share. We want to publish as much knowledge as we can to customers, but we don’t want to cause frustration or confusion by sharing low quality content. Mike has been sharing feedback on articles on a regular basis when he found them incomplete or misleading and I can’t thank him enough for that. It helped us understand where we failed to meet his standards and gave us an opportunity to improve those articles quickly.

    Two good news to finish on a positive note:

    • a new search engine is coming your way in January (with beta access in December). It will index content from different sources (product documentation, SPRs, TS knowledge Base…..and communities) and will bring many long awaited features and an improved navigation.
    • Until then, we’ve put together a document called “How to get started with PTC Knowledge Base” which is not yet publicly available. If you guys want to take a look at it and share your comments, I’m all in. Just let me know.

    Thanks again for the feedback and if some of you want to spend more time on some of those topics, we can always start specific discussions in the forum.

    TmetcalfAuthor
    Oct 3, 2014 1:01 PM UTC

    Good morning everyone,

    I would like to highlight how Pierre closed his post as it will help with communication.

    This thread (and Group) is off to a fine start, please:

    1. Continue to post and share here

    2. For each new topic, please open a new discussion.

    If the issue is around a product idea, please post that in the open Community area as it will get more votes from members. As Pierre wrote, we know we have issues and idea submission, AND feedback, is one of them. Sorry for the current process - we are working on it.

    Have a great Friday all.

    Best,

    Toby