Skip to main content
Feb 8, 2015 3:41 PM UTC
Question

Renaming some communities

There is some confusion for people about the Mathcad communities, such as Mechanical Engineering, so that they ask about Creo in them.

Would changing the names to be prefixed: Mathcad - Mechanical Engineering be of help?

    6 replies

    Feb 8, 2015 3:50 PM UTC

    That's certainly one way to apporach this issue of user confusion, but It would be evaluated site wide across all product sub-communities. I see the value it brings to solving this issue but also creates new issues like the unnecessary repetition of product names when trying to browse all communities.

    Product names are currently listed at the top of every sub-community page within the breadcrumbs:

    PTC Community > Mathcad > Mechanical Engineering

    As we've mentioned before, please let Toby or I know when this happens so we can move the content into the relevant product sub-community.

    Feb 8, 2015 6:19 PM UTC

    This does happen, but given the total number of posts per day for Creo, it's a tiny percentage. This happens rarely enough it's easy for us to just redirect them to the correct forum.

    dschenkenAuthor
    Feb 8, 2015 11:06 PM UTC

    It takes no ongoing effort to rename, but it does take effort to not only PM one of the moderators, but then for them to move it, then they add a message to the OP that the thread was moved and then the redirects end up looking like the question was responded to already by someone from PTC, which should be an official response, which it isn't.

    Last month a math teacher repeatedly posted into Creo Modeling with Mathcad examples. They were 2D mechanism analysis, but had no connection to Creo Parametric.

    Feb 9, 2015 1:37 PM UTC

    We don't bother to PM a moderator to move the thread. We just tell the poster they won't get an answer unless they post again in the correct forum.

    I'm sure renaming would reduce the misposting, but I'm not sure it would eliminate it. If someone can repeatedly post Mathcad worksheets to the Creo Modeling forum then they are just not paying attention at all.