Skip to main content
Dec 15, 2014 12:45 PM UTC
Question

New Search Engine available for Beta Testing

Dear PTC Community Support Champions,

As announced during the meeting on Thursday, a new search engine will be deployed on the eSupport Portal next month and one of the new feature will be the ability to search PTC Community content.

Beta access is available starting from today for customers with a valide ptc.com account and is available here : https://support.ptc.com/search/Pages/results.aspx

A quick video of introduction and some advanced tips and tricks are available to get you started.

For those of you who do not have a ptc.com account, you should still be able to view the introduction video if you are interested as the above link does not require any login/password.

    49 replies

    Dec 15, 2014 1:38 PM UTC

    Hah! I claim first bug report

    When clicking through your introduction some pages are cut off at the bottom. For example, there's no way to scroll down to see what "Archive" is:

    noscroll.png

    As a question, now that I have exited that introduction, is there anyway to see it again? If there is, it's not obvious.

    Dec 15, 2014 2:44 PM UTC

    Just out of curiosity, what screen resolution are you running?

    Dec 15, 2014 2:48 PM UTC

    I'm running 1920 x 1200 (not sure if you were asking Richard but I figured it couldn't hurt to chime in).

    Dec 15, 2014 2:30 PM UTC

    Hi Pierre...

    So far I'd say this is better. I am not prepared to say how much better just yet... because I still think the search is a little wonky. I have a special search I always perform when evaluating PTC's knowledgebase searches.

    Many years ago, I opened a ticket on a topic that had never been documented before. The ticket took weeks to resolve because one of the PTC developers had to dig into the Pro/ENGINEER code to figure out how a certain feature was supposed to work. This feature was poorly documented and exceptionally rarely used... to the point that no one had ever asked how to use it. This was not something one could just "click around" and figure out. I spent a good bit of time with PTC insuring this feature was documented in the knowledgebase.

    A few years ago, when the "new" search and knowledgebase came online, I was asked to test it. The first thing I searched for was this "rare feature". It did not come up in the search. I used this as the basis for my claim that the search was flawed and that old knowledgebase articles were missing from the new, improved search. This was met with skepticism. However, upon further examination, I was proved right.

    Just now I re-ran the search for that rare feature - and the old knowledgebase article is still gone. A newer one created just a year or two ago appears. This is the result of a second ticket I opened with PTC regarding that same rare feature.

    So I guess I'm saying you get points for having something come up. It still took me over 5 minutes to find the article I wanted. Had I not already known the information was there, I wouldn't have found it. Some of this is because the new article is really poor. The old one was very detailed and accurate but since it was circa 1999, it's long since gone. The new one is probably circa 2011 or 2012... and it barely provides any useful information.

    The new interface is an improvement... that is definite. I can't gauge how great that improvement is until I can spend more time with the tool.

    Thanks,

    _Brian

    Pierre_MAuthor
    Dec 15, 2014 3:13 PM UTC

    Brian,

    Thanks for the feedback. A couple of points of clarification

    • the serach engine is (supposed to be) smart and learning by itself: if several people searched for the same things and all clicked on the 4th link on the result page, the serach engine will move this content to a higher position for this query. Quality of results should improve over time for "frequent" queries (which might not be the case with your example)
    • if you are looking for the old document, it should be in the "archive" tab as this is where live all the document which have not been updated for the past 4 years. We received a lot of feedbakc from customers complaining about "all documents poluting results" but we also had a lot of customers asking for "old documents to not be removed from KB". So we made this decision to keep in "everything" whatever has been updated recently and keep in "archive" whatever has been unouched for a while.
    • If you give me the name of the new & old documents I can ask a TSE to improve the new one with content from the old one.

    /Pierre

    Dec 15, 2014 3:40 PM UTC

    I like the idea that it will learn. This will help to keep the most relevant new material at the top, but I don't see how it will bring old "lost" material to the top. If relevant material is at the bottom of the list nobody will click on it, so that's where it will stay.

    On another note, if I apply a filter on the left, and then change tab, it clears the filter. I'm not sure if this is intentional, but it's not what I would want.

    Dec 15, 2014 5:29 PM UTC

    Pen,

    I keep having issues with secondary searches not working. Take a look at the attached screenshot. It shows that the next search I'm attempting (a specific SPR number - shown in red) is not properly clearing out the last search I made (shown in yellow).

    4.PNG

    Pierre_MAuthor
    Dec 16, 2014 4:41 PM UTC

    Tom,

    I don't seem to be able to reproduce the problem.

    If you have time, can you tell me which steps you are following and which browser you are using ?

    Thanks

    Dec 18, 2014 2:33 PM UTC

    I haven't been able to reproduce the issue past the first day of usage. I will let you know if happens again. Thanks.

    Jan 6, 2015 6:15 PM UTC

    Pierre,

    I'm having trouble with the "exact" search. I'm trying to locate articles with this exact text string: [.x]

    Searching for [.x] and "[.x]" both return the same result, and neither of them contain this text string. Instead I'm getting pages that contain "x" on them (no brackets).

    What am I doing wrong?

    P.S. I'm trying to figure out how Creo 3 handles the decimals displayed modifier "[.x]". This isn't working for me in Creo 3 and and I need to know what changed.

    Jan 6, 2015 6:20 PM UTC

    Here's another form: "[.#]"

    Searching for this should return articles like this: CS35812

    Instead it returns absolutely nothing.

    Feb 5, 2015 10:39 PM UTC

    Pierre,

    1.) Is it possible to still force the system to use the old search site? (Alternate link or something)

    I have several things I'm searching for that are returning ZERO results. These are valid detail options that exist in Creo Parametric 3.0 and are even listed in the help documentation at http://help.ptc.com.

    Examples:

    • show_sym_of_suppressed_weld
    • aux_view_note_format

    2.) I don't know if you have any control over http://help.ptc.com, but the top link listed for every one of these is invalid (404 error). The other links load just fine.

    • show_sym_of_suppressed_weld
    • aux_view_note_format
    • ref_des_display

    404.PNG

    Feb 6, 2015 12:21 AM UTC

    Tech support has confirmed that "show_sym_of_suppressed_weld" and "ref_des_display" were both removed as options back in Wildfire 2. (Yes, 6 major releases back!) There are apparently SPRs requesting that the options also be removed from the documentation but apparently these have never been completed.

    Regardless, the support search site should still be returning something for these options since they WERE valid options at one time and there are still open SPRs.

    Pierre_MAuthor
    Feb 6, 2015 10:01 AM UTC

    Tom,

    Sorry for the delayed answer. I've been travelling most of the past 3 weeks and could not come here as frequently as I intended too.

    Here is a bulk answer to the previous 5 posts

    • "[.#]" --> Will look into this and will get back to you
    • Controlling the Number of Decimal Places in Parameters --> I got 99 documents in Everything Section and 59 in the Archive Section (we've tweaked a few things over the past 2 weeks so maybe this is why there are results now)
    • SPR 2247425 --> has just entered "fixing" state (it was escalated to high last month)
    • No we can't give access to old search as it's being retired
    • show_sym_of_suppressed_weld --> there is an internal article (I will ask for it to be published) but the feature has been removed as ou say.
    • aux_view_note_format --> nothing in old search there neither
    • Creo 3 help centers broken links --> will report it to Product Management

    I'm taking the opportunity to clarify a bit our Knowledge Management Startegy

    • Indexing the HelpCenters is something that we plan to do in the new search this year, to really make it the "one stop shop" when it comes to knowledge access
    • Our goal in TS in not to duplicate the work done by Technical Writers on the help centers, but really complement them by creating/maintain ad different type of knowledge (more fluid, more customer centric) and rpointing to the help centers whenever they alreay have the information captured.

    I will post updates in the thread when I have them !

    Jun 25, 2015 6:24 PM UTC

    Pierre Maraninchi‌,

    Just noticed something weird today with the knowledge base search engine.  Searching for "JMX-Administrators EMAIL LIST HAS NOT BEEN POPULATED" (without the quotes) yields 0 results.

    search1.PNG

    Searching for "JMX-Administrators" does yield results and the first one contains the exact same text as my original search term.

    search2.PNG

    Why didn't the first search work?  The exact same text is clearly there in the first article.

    search3.PNG

    Thanks.

    Pierre_MAuthor
    Jun 25, 2015 9:21 PM UTC

    Tom,

    That's a bit of an unfortunate very specific situation triggered by the upper case error message

    The search engine is considering upper case AND, OR, NEAR and...NOT as boolean operators. As a consequence the NOT BEEN sequence tells the search engine to exclude articles containing the word "been".

    If you search for JMX-Administrators EMAIL LIST HAS not BEEN POPULATED then the article is returned

    Jun 25, 2015 9:32 PM UTC

    Interesting.  Thanks for looking into it.  I guess I'll try to keep that in mind for future searches.

    It'd be really cool if there was a way to highlight (in some color) those special search terms in the search box so people realized the impact.  I imagine this would be pretty easy to do with CSS and the right filter...

    (Off topic, please read my post here:  Re: Windchill 10.3 (X-26).  Not sure if you can do anything about it or not.)