Skip to main content
Oct 7, 2014 9:08 PM UTC
Question

Flat, threaded, or hybrid?

Since I brought the subject up, I thought I'd fill everyone in on exactly what the old Mathcad Collaboratory looked like, and why everyone liked it.

I have often seen the question on forums of which view is better: flat or threaded.

A flat view has the advantage that it's easy to find the recent posts, because they are at the end (or beginning, depending on the forum). The problem with a flat view is that the structure of who replied to who is not obvious, and unless people are religious about quoting when there's any ambiguity the thread can get very confusing.

A threaded view has the advantage that it's easy (or easier, anyway) to see who replied to who. However, finding the recent posts in a long thread can be a real pain. It also suffers from the problem that the posts get narrower and narrower as the thread gets longer, and we end up with small columns of text in the middle of an otherwise unused screen.

But it doesn't have to be like that! O'Reilly published software years ago, called WebBoard (unfortunately long since dead and gone) that used a hybrid system that gave the best of both worlds, and then some. Here's a couple of screen shots:

Collaboratory2.png

Collaboratory1.png

The first image shows the structure. On the right are the actual posts. They always take up the same amount of screen width. On the left is something very similar to Windows Explorer. It shows the structure of every forum, the threads within each forum, and the threaded view makes it easy to see the structure, and who has replied to who. Obviously, clicking on a post on the left brings up the appropriate post on the right. This format makes it even easier to see the structure than a threaded view in the current forums, because it's more condensed (you only see the title and the name of the poster). It's easy to find not only the most recent posts, but also the most recent posts in any subthread. Although it's not shown here a poster could also change the subject, so a subthread could have a different name to the main thread. What's shown in the second screen shot (which is of the forums viewed from within Mathcad, rather than a browser) is what happens when you get unread posts. They are highlighted in the left panel! This occurs at the forum level, the thread level, and next to the new posts themselves. It makes it trivial to find the new posts, and it's immediately obvious what the context of those posts is in terms of the existing thread structure. A poster could also flag a post for someone's attention, in which case you also got the !.

As I said, this software is long dead, and while it had it's advantages it also lacked many things the Jive software offers. I really miss the hybrid view though