Skip to main content
Jun 15, 2017 7:35 PM UTC
Question

Community Organization

Good day Gents,

I am hoping to open the door for you shortly.

I would like to consolidate sub-communities and categories to best classify content within each product.

Would you please review Creo, Mathcad, and Windchill and offer your top 8 labels for each?

May I please have this by Monday?

Best and thank you,

Toby

    36 replies

    Jun 15, 2017 7:40 PM UTC

    Sub-communities - are you talking drop downs?

    i.e. Creo:

    TmetcalfAuthor
    Jun 15, 2017 7:49 PM UTC

    That is correct Dale.  I know this is not an easy ask, but we have a few too many options with not enough content attached.

    This move is an opportunity to fine-tune and streamline.

    Toby

    Jun 15, 2017 10:28 PM UTC

    The Mathcad area is a mess in this respect, which has a lot to do with legacy communities from the old forums. Some communities are based on worksheet content (e.g. Programming), and some are based on area of application (e.g. Mechanical Engineering). To add to the confusion you can get three different lists of communities, depending on how you view them (the drop down at the top of the page, the "Communities" listing on the left of the main Mathcad page, and the list you get when you click on Sub-communities). And then we have the categories, which are set within the first post in a thread, regardless of which community it's in. One of those categories is Programming!

    So, will the new forums have categories, or something equivalent? Because if the answer is "yes", then I think the best arrangement would be to set communities by field of application, and categories by type of worksheet content being discussed. That would result in a grid structure that could be navigated in two directions, depending on need.

    Jun 15, 2017 8:50 PM UTC

    Here's an Excel file to help you work through this.  The first tab lists the existing communities and categories.  The second tab lists all of PTC products.

    Jun 15, 2017 8:54 PM UTC

    My list is pretty sad. I only use what I am interested in and work with regularly.

    If it was up to me, I would add DRAWING to that dropdown.

    I would change the top lvl category to CREO PARAMETRIC and have a CREO ELEMENTS DIRECT

    I also don't like the sub-community "VISUALIZE" because no one uses that term to describe "Creo Illustrate, Creo View MCAD and Creo View ECAD"

    A more appropriate name would be better, maybe Illustrate.

    I'm not much help but this is my list.

    TmetcalfAuthor
    Jun 16, 2017 2:19 PM UTC

    No worries Stephen - trying to make things simple by reducing options.

    Jun 16, 2017 1:06 PM UTC

    Toby,

    Mathcad:

    • Mathcad Usage
    • Programming & Extending Mathcad
    • Math Homework Help
    • Chemical Engineering
    • Electrical Engineering
    • Mechanical Engineering
    • Statistics & Data Analysis
    • Other Subjects

    Creo:

    • Modeling
    • Manufacturing
    • Analysis and Simulation
    • Piping, Cabling & Schematics
    • Rendering
    • Visualize
    • Creo Customization
    • Creo Elements/Direct

    Possibly that some sections can be combined (by adding in the name "&").

    Jun 16, 2017 1:15 PM UTC

    Mathcad:

    • Mathcad Usage
    • Programming & Extending Mathcad
    • Math Homework Help
    • Chemical Engineering
    • Electrical Engineering
    • Power Engineering
    • Mechanical Engineering
    • Statistics & Data Analysis
    • Units
    • Art and Games
    • Other Subjects
    TmetcalfAuthor
    Jun 16, 2017 2:22 PM UTC

    Here is what I have in Mathcad - see the labels on the right

    Mathcad.jpg

    TmetcalfAuthor
    Jun 16, 2017 1:53 PM UTC

    Thanks Guys.

    I know this is hard without actual navigation and I will get it for you soon.

    A little Lithium-speak:

    A product community in Jive is a Category in Lithium.  Within the category, we have Boards (for discussions), Blogs, Ideas.  For discussions that are very popular (Modeling in Creo for example) will have their own board.  Those with lower volume will be in another board and can be identified with a label (set by me (and you)), and tags.  You will be able to subscribe to labels so you will be altered to new content.

    Community Look.jpg

    This is what it will look like when asking a new question or starting a discussion - see the labels on the right.

    I know we will have bumps in the road and as you have pointed out above, we need to clean a bit of house; this move is a great opportunity to do so.

    As always, I promise to ask for your input as it helps me see the entire picture and the build for the customer point of view; I cannot always implement all at once.

    Thanks for your suggestions.

    Toby

    Jun 16, 2017 3:59 PM UTC

    I want to make sure I have this correct.  Is this what you mean:

    If so, can you prevent posting to a category and only allow posting inside the sub-categories (discussion boards)?

    Are labels unique to each discussion board (sub-category)?

    TmetcalfAuthor
    Jun 16, 2017 4:58 PM UTC

    Indeed Tom - I can set things so the post needs to have a label attached before it can be posted and the labels will be unique to boards.

    Jun 16, 2017 6:37 PM UTC

    Toby Metcalf‌, how many top level categories and next level discussion boards would you like to see?

    In my opinion, the top level categories should generally not allow content to be placed directly under them without first moving one level deeper.  "Creo" and "Windchill" are way to broad and span way to many, completely unrelated products.  The current setup causes lots of confusion (Creo Parametric vs. Creo Direct and PDMLink vs. WPA).

    I would strongly suggest that the top level categories align with the broader PTC product areas.  Maybe something like this:

    • Creo
    • Integrity
    • Servigistics
    • Thingworx
    • Windchill

    Creo and Windchill both have a ton of products under them.  It might make sense to break them down even more at the top level (just like PTC does today):

    • Creo CAD
    • Creo Simulate
    • Creo View
    • Integrity
    • Servigistics
    • Thingworx
    • Windchill PDM & Process
    • Windchill Quality

    At the next level down, break out into the more popular/common products.  Again, users come to the community to interact about a product.  I think it's very important that the community reflect this reality (and help get content in the right area.)  For example:

    Creo CAD

    • Creo Layout
    • Creo Illustrate
    • Creo Options Modeler
    • Creo Parametric
    • Other Extensions

    Windchill PDM & Process

    • Windchill FlexPLM
    • Windchill MPMLink
    • Windchill PartsLink
    • Windchill PDM Essentials
    • Windchill PDMLink
    • Windchill ProjectLink
    TmetcalfAuthor
    Jun 17, 2017 12:43 PM UTC

    This is an excellent discussion - thank Gents.

    We are working through the final touches of SSO and hope to get you guys access early next week.

    I know seeing and navigating will help.

    Best,

    Toby

    3-Newcomer
    Jun 16, 2017 7:06 PM UTC

    I would like to strongly suggest a move that some have hinted at - categorization by software package.  "Modelling" can be done in Creo Parametric, Creo Direct, Creo Elements Direct and perhaps other packages.  There is little overlap in command structure or methodology between them.  The current "modeling" community is pretty much Creo Parametric.

    Jun 16, 2017 7:15 PM UTC

    Totally agree.  This also makes it clear which software package a particular product idea applies to.

    Jun 19, 2017 3:45 PM UTC

    Here are my suggestions for Creo Parametric labels:

    • 2D Drawings
    • Modeling
    • Automation (Relations, Pro/Program, Drawing Program)
    • Customization (J-Link, VBAPI, Toolkit, etc.)
    • Sheetmetal
    • Mechanism
    • Assembly

    Since there are too many PTC products to give every one of them their own discussion board, it might make sense to keep the Creo Extensions as just labels until the traffic justifies a dedicated board.  For example:

    • Creo Advanced Assembly Extension (AAX)
    • Creo Advanced Framework Extension (AFX)
    • Creo Advanced Rendering Extension (ARX)
    • Creo Behavioral Modeling Extension (BMX)
    • Creo Collaboration Extensions
    • Creo Complete Machining Extension
    • Creo Complete Mold Design Extension
    • Creo Computer-Aided Verification Extension
    • Creo Design Exploration Extension (DEX)
    • Creo Distributed Batch Extension
    • Creo ECAD-MCAD Collaboration Extension
    • Creo Expert Moldbase Extension
    • Creo Flexible Modeling Extension (FMX)
    • Creo Intelligent Fastener Extension (IFX)
    • Creo Manikin Extension
    • Creo NC Sheetmetal Extension
    • Creo Piping and Cabling Extension
    • Creo Prismatic and Multi-Surface Milling Extension
    • Creo Production Machining Extension
    • Creo Progressive Die Extension (PDX)
    • Creo Reverse Engineering Extension (REX)
    • Creo Tool Design Extension

    (Sorry, I don't know the three letter abbreviation for all of these.  Also, it might make sense to drop "Creo" and "Extension" from the label names.)

    Jun 19, 2017 5:43 PM UTC

    I agree with Tom's label for Creo Parametric.

    .

    Jun 20, 2017 2:25 PM UTC

    In the new site, pages look sleek and load faster. Thanks