Skip to main content
Jan 14, 2015 4:58 AM UTC
Question

Clipping old threads

It's a big distraction for threads that have had no recent activity to get a sudden addition, often unrelated, often enough to a "Correctly Answered" thread.

It makes more sense that threads be automatically closed after 6 months of inactivity, with an option to start a new thread that carries a reference to the old one.

This one, for example, was 3 years old before someone grafted a similar, but unrelated question to it. http://communities.ptc.com/message/268496#268496 The original thread was why PDMLink Update behaved different from Intralink Update (still wondering why PTC developers can't seem to use a thesaurus instead of just re-purposing terminology in confusing ways) and now has a graft about Update downloads configuration. As a result, Martin Toreskog, who made his only post in 2012, now gets an unrelated reply almost 3 years later (and Jive doesn't round up, so it says two years.)

If the desire is to accumulate information, then creating a website with curated pages, such as a Wiki, would be a much better method than the jumble of questions and answers across multiple software versions.

As an aside, clipping thread hijacks would also be valuable. http://communities.ptc.com/message/268449#268449

It comes from an interesting strangely broken profile http://communities.ptc.com/people/ptc-4594570?view=overview

Also interesting, related broken page http://communities.ptc.com/thread/56708

    11 replies

    Jan 14, 2015 5:52 AM UTC

    Ya picked up on that, did ya I also got a PM on the very same subject from Muhammad. I suspect several people did.

    Jan 14, 2015 12:44 PM UTC
    It comes from an interesting strangely broken profile http://communities.ptc.com/people/ptc-4594570?view=overview

    Also interesting, related broken page http://communities.ptc.com/thread/56708

    Actually, those aren't "broken", they are simply the text of a traceback file from a Creo crash.

    dschenkenAuthor
    Jan 14, 2015 6:49 PM UTC

    Except the contents don't match the subject and the responses don't suggest anyone was bothered by the trace-back, suggesting to me that the original entries were corrupted.

    Jan 14, 2015 12:52 PM UTC
    If the desire is to accumulate information, then creating a website with curated pages, such as a Wiki, would be a much better method than the jumble of questions and answers across multiple software versions.

    I agree 100%. If this isn't possible, then maybe have the ability for moderators to make certain discussions "sticky". A topic specific page could also be created with all the best information - kind of like what Marco did with the Windchill reporting stuff.

    As an aside, clipping thread hijacks would also be valuable. http://communities.ptc.com/message/268449#268449

    Is there a way in Jive for a moderator to move a thread hijack to a different, new thread? This is done all the time on other forums I use. Both new questions and replies to existing questions are often moved to different areas of the site or turned into completely new threads.

    Jan 14, 2015 1:34 PM UTC

    This also happens sometimes in the Mathcad forums, but not often. However, sometimes people also add information to an older thread that is relevant to that thread (in fact, I did just that a couple of months ago), and if the thread is automatically closed after 6 months that would not be possible. I don't think there is any automatic way of closing threads that I would consider satisfactory.

    dschenkenAuthor
    Jan 14, 2015 7:08 PM UTC

    At Eng-tips the forum includes a button on closed threads that creates a new thread with a reference to the old one. One is always able to follow linked threads.

    The number of times irrelevant information is attached to threads far exceeds the times a thread is usefully extended, at least on the Creo Parametric/Pro-E threads. Perhaps an infinite window on MathCAD? On the Creo side there are a lot of threads where the conversation ends in 2008, then in the middle someone will reply as if they don't see the date with a question to one of the users about some other problem that shares a keyword. Reading the thread then goes from a relatively linear activity to a jumble of junk.

    I generally see threads as a way to elicit information from people as to the exact nature of their problem, not as a good way to record solutions. Because of this I see little value in extending threads. When someone has a new problem, there should be a new thread. When someone wants to see a solution to a problem, there should be a Wiki page to cover that solution, with links to threads that solution touches. This way only one place needs to be updated/clarified and all the threads/problems will get the improved solution automatically, and as software changes, the Wiki pages can be expanded to reflect the changed capability.

    Jan 14, 2015 8:06 PM UTC

    On the Mathcad forums, this actually doesn't happen all that often.

    At Eng-tips the forum includes a button on closed threads that creates a new thread with a reference to the old one. One is always able to follow linked threads.

    Does the link work both ways, so if someone finds the old thread they find a link to the newer material?