Skip to main content
Jun 21, 2016 12:10 AM UTC
Question

Anyone notice this guy?

justme / Frank Defilippi : First really showed up with some vague complaints and then launched this: Swx to Creo back to SWX

One thing that didn't make sense was his lack of Community questions about using Creo, but I can see what he wanted from the start, weeks before he joined the Community. It's interesting that he didn't post much over there either.

Convincing company to switch CAD systems | SOLIDWORKS Forums

forum.solidworks.com/thread/113422

His post, as of April 6th  "I've been at this for 8-1/2 weeks and it took 3 weeks to model a single part (small block)."

But this post, from March 31, tells it all: EPDM and PTC-Creo tie in | SOLIDWORKS Forums

forum.solidworks.com/thread/113422

"My whole evil plan is to bring EPDM here and then suggest converting over SW."

Allowing for a certain amount of hyperbole, there seems like something wrong with this guy's story. Charitable guess is that he is incapable of learning anything new, even if he's had a decent career so far. Less charitable is he's a fake user and there is no company. But maybe it's real, and the company is badly managed/wages are low and no Creo user will touch it. How does a major milestone fly by management with engineers doing nothing for months on end? How can they not get a contract engineer?

He claims he got a training quote from a reseller. It would be interesting to get a PTC sales-engineer up there for a day to snuff the idea that Creo is so hard to use that it takes 3 weeks to make a simple model.

OTOH - Does PTC have a group dedicated to creating transition training to move people from SW & Inventor to Creo? Does it follow up with smaller companies to prevent invasive sales of competitor products? Does anyone else find it amusing that Dassault uses Jive!

Finally - this is hilarious: Jumping dimensions | SOLIDWORKS Forums

    16 replies

    Jun 21, 2016 12:54 PM UTC

    So it now seems obvious that it's either the same guy or that's the 2 guys. In any case, he basically is refusing to learn or can't learn and is digging in. I kinda feel sorry for his situation but he actually is squandering a great opportunity to make himself more valuable.

    Your first link should have been:

    forum.solidworks.com/message/572436

    3-Newcomer
    Jun 21, 2016 12:58 PM UTC

    I've been amused by his posts.  From what I gather, his company doesn't make anything complicated, geometry wise.  What I mean is that I don't think he's doing complicated, injection molded consumer product surface models, although he hasn't really shared a lot about what he's doing.

    There hasn't been many questions about how to do anything specific.  Oddly, he has two profiles, and the other one has asked a fair number of questions:

    Just me

    fdefilippi

    He also got Toby Metcalf attention a while back:

    Re: Oddity in user name

    I use both SW and Creo and, while they are different, and I'll even grant that Creo is harder, they aren't so dissimilar that a person with several years of experience in SW you shouldn't be able to get up to speed and be able to model fairly well in a month.

    Is he a SW troll or just a guy who can't or won't learn new things?  I'd bet the latter, but I'm not sure it matters, it seems whatever harm may have been done is minimal at best.  Now that he's accomplished his goal of getting them to switch to SW, he likely won't be back.

    Regarding the last question - PTC needs to have a dedicated SW > Creo training program.  It's not an easy jump.  Frankly, though I think he had an aversion to change, I'd say that there's still something to learn from following his frustrations.

    Oh, and yes, I find it amusing that Dassault uses Jive too.  I think they used it before PTC even started this community.

    Jun 21, 2016 1:31 PM UTC

    Aversion to change, that's a good way to put it. He seems to be spending way too much time on the forums and not enough time work...hey, wait a minute, I just spent several minutes reading that whole post!!!

    Jun 21, 2016 1:09 PM UTC

    Good day Gents,

    I have noticed these usernames and have not paid much attention to their content.

    Seems like harmless rambling; would you agree?

    I am suspicious of anyone who joins a community and hides behind anonymity.

    I bet if people do not engage with him / them, they will get board and leave.

    Thoughts?

    Best,

    Toby

    3-Newcomer
    Jun 21, 2016 1:30 PM UTC

    I'd agree. He seems to have gotten his wish - that his company would switch to SW.  He's probably already gone.

    Jun 21, 2016 2:07 PM UTC

    Thanks Doug.

    Certainly if you or the rest of the crew notice questionable content from him/them, please let me know.

    Cheers,

    Toby

    Jun 21, 2016 1:51 PM UTC

    I really wouldn't worry about it. I've taught courses in advanced software packages (not Mathcad though), and there are always a few that have used some other package for years, and after two days with the new package declare it's hard to use. The first time anyone uses some advanced piece of software it's a struggle, and many things (even most things!) seem non-intuitive. I'm an occasional user of SW, and because it's only occasional use it frustrates the heck out of me every time! Sometimes I'm convinced that the software designer can see inside my brain, and deliberately did everything in a way that's different to the way I would do it . I at least have the advantage that I'm the boss, and I have a technical background. Pressure from some management type that knows little or nothing about what it actually takes to complete a technical project just amplifies the frustration in a way that's counter productive. So the guy comes to these forums and vents.

    I'm a little surprised you even brought it up. This is a regular feature of the Mathcad forums. Usually people that have used Excel for 15 years, and can't translate that into using Mathcad (for those that don't know, Excel and Mathcad are so different there's almost nothing that you know about Excel that would be useful in using Mathcad)

    dschenkenAuthor
    Jun 22, 2016 12:16 AM UTC

    I don't recall ever seeing someone so publicly lay out a plan to damage his employer for their own benefit.  I understand whining - I do so enough. But I also look to help people improve their situation; this seemed to be the opposite and it irks me.

    Jun 22, 2016 12:37 AM UTC

    What makes you think his employer even knows about his posts, and that they therefore benefit him in any way? It sounds to me like he's just a frustrated user that thinks that a new software package should be as easy to use as one he has spent years learning. As I said, I have encountered many such people over the years, both in the capacity of teaching software, and answering questions on the Mathcad forums. They come. They vent their frustration. Then they either learn the new software or give up (sometimes deliberately; they just refuse to learn it). If they give up, I just write them off.

    I see similar attitudes sometimes when we try to introduce our technology to manufacturing or chemical plants. There are some that see it as a threat to their jobs, and do everything they can to resist it. There are some that embrace it, and realize that job security means adapting. At the end of the day, the ones that adapted are "right", because they are still employed.

    In general, there are two broad classes of people. Those that spend an hour telling you why something is impossible, and those that spend an hour figuring out how to do it. That is obviously a very sweeping statement, but I hope you get my point. Don't worry about those that don't want to figure out how to solve the problem. Just move on.