Skip to main content
Sep 27, 2010 8:25 PM UTC
Question

What new features do you want to see in Mathcad Prime?

Hi Everyone,

As many of you know, Mathcad Prime 1.0 is well under way and is slated for release around the end of the year. We have gotten great feedback from our Alpha program participants and are happy to report that the majority of said feedback is positive. People like Prime!

So, onward and upward. We are now in the process of planning Mathcad Prime 2.0 (yes, already). Product Management has held many discussions with all the different teams within the Mathcad business unit, aligned with other PTC products across the PDS (Product Development System, that is), and spoken to many, many customers about what they would like to see in Mathcad Prime.

We have been spreading the word that as an initial release, Mathcad Prime 1.0 will not be a feature-to-feature replacement of Mathcad 15 (though Prime will have some great things that Mathcad 15 does not). We are spending a lot of time trying to close the feature gaps, but with the extra time left over, we are dedicated to providing some great new features and functionality that people have been waiting for and wishing for for years. So, now I'd like to reach out the the PlanetPTC community..

I'd like everyone to tell me their top three most desired new features in Mathcad Prime and why you want that feature. These could be completly new features or just additional new functionality on an existing feature.

P.S. I know most would love to give at least ten, but please keep it to three for my own sake and also because we only have so many development resources

P.P.S. Alpha testers please keep in mind not to discuss feedback related to the Alpha of course. Much thanks in advance.

    14 replies

    Sep 27, 2010 8:44 PM UTC

    Let me expound briefly on the why..

    What I'd really like to know is what high level problems will this feature solve for you? For example: "I want a sketching tool because I have difficulty formatting my documents the way I want and emphasizing information in my worksheets."

    You get the gist

    Thanks!

    Sep 28, 2010 3:59 PM UTC

    Actually, I don't. I have yet to see a solid raison d'etre for MP1. Is it intended to replace MC15? Is it supposed to be a descendant of Studyworks? What is its price point relative to MC15 or MC 16?

    I don't see how we can suggest features for something whose reason for existing we don't have a clear understanding of.

    Sep 28, 2010 6:49 AM UTC

    Before I name my top three requests I would like to point something out.

    We have been spreading the word that as an initial release, Mathcad Prime 1.0 will not be a feature-to-feature replacement of Mathcad 15 (though Prime will have some great things that Mathcad 15 does not). We are spending a lot of time trying to close the feature gaps, but with the extra time left over, we are dedicated to providing some great new features and functionality that people have been waiting for and wishing for for years. So, now I'd like to reach out the the PlanetPTC community..

    I understand it has been difficult to implement all features found in Mathcad 15 in Prime 1.0 due to the impending release, but before looking at additional features it is imperative that PTC get all features found in previous versions of Mathcad into Prime 2.0.

    I was hugely excited when first seeing the new features in Prime, which quickly dispersed when realising the features which where not included.

    Simple features like: Page format – Borders, Collapsed Areas…etc. just to name a few.

    These features are key and I couldn't see my employer upgrading until the features are implemented. We have proprietary in-house software written in Mathcad where only sections of the calculation are displayed and given to the client – If Prime 1.0 doesn't support collapsed area’s, how would this be possible????

    Mike

    Sep 28, 2010 6:02 PM UTC
    Sep 30, 2010 10:34 PM UTC

    David,

    One of the problems you face is that all the collaborators are PASSIONATE about MathCAD and simply want <expect> more and better.

    As you will be already aware, this means that Prime, in version 1.0 and 2.0 will be addressing a different market - most likely those who use Pro/E as regular designers and who don't have the same advanced maths needs. It is likely to be those teams that can advise as to the best order for implementing the existing MathCAD features in Prime. This is not to say that all our collaborator comments should be ignored, rather you should ensure that the architecture and design of the product internals has all the necessary hooks and internal APIs and methods to allow the features to be implemented later <sooner>.

    For example I would like the ability to have both "matrices" which have a single common unit, and "tables" which have consistent rows or columns, or even individual element units. These multi-unit tables are so common in standards and guides for engineering calculations that you will need to be able to handle them intelligently.

    I also think you need to address "see break out box" calculations which are shown 'off to the side' (i.e. not in-line with the regular flow).

    You must also address your long terms strategy for addressing simulation issues. The current MathCAD cannot do repetition, going over and over the same calculations (e.g. an area or break out box) and then plot a summary graph of the calculated trend (where most of the data was overwritten each time around). This is a real word engineering activity that currently requires me, and others, to use tools that are not always of our liking, just because MathCAD can't (won't?) do it. I can program in that other mathematics laboratory tool but I'm often frustrated by it compared to the ease of use of mathcad, but I still have to use it to do any simulation or temporal based displaying (e.g. process and view a digital video stream)

    Philip

    Oct 1, 2010 7:32 AM UTC

    One of the problems you face is that all the collaborators are PASSIONATE about MathCAD and simply want <expect> more and better.

    As you will be already aware, this means that Prime, in version 1.0 and 2.0 will be addressing a different market - most likely those who use Pro/E as regular designers and who don't have the same advanced maths needs.

    100% agree with this, but the reason we Mathcad is directly the opposite - Shouldn't PTC's first priority be looking after their existing customers, not changing the software to attract new ones.

    Mike

    Oct 12, 2010 7:51 AM UTC

    Where is "Feature Suggestions" -sub forum, sub community, subzer0?

    Cheers. Alvaro.

    Oct 12, 2010 7:58 AM UTC

    Left in the old forum along with several other sub communities.

    Mike

    Oct 12, 2010 8:17 AM UTC

    MikeArmstrong wrote:

    Left in the old forum along with several other sub communities.

    Mike

    Thanks, yes, I see ... well, at least have this post. Announcements go here too ? 🙂

    Regards. Alvaro.

    Nov 11, 2010 7:26 PM UTC

    Product management.jpg

    Forgive me for another "distraction" moment, but things may really happen sometimes like that !

    Best regards, Liv.

    [ No more tracks on author of picture (SDLC ... ?), so credits must go to who is entitled. ]

    Jan 14, 2011 1:58 PM UTC

    In order to answer the question intelligently, I need to know what Mathcad Prime is, or will be, and where can I find

    documentation to that effect?

    Mar 29, 2011 8:29 PM UTC

    Hi All,

    We are going to move this discussion to a new Enhancing Mathcad group, so that each topic can be discussed separately. It's getting very unwieldly in this long (277 replies) thread.

    The topics are going to be separated so they are easier to search and discuss.

    For now, to find the group click on the groups icon above.

    groups.png

    We'll be adding a larger announcement to highlght the group in the next week or so.

    For each release, we prioritize features according to the different feedback we receive from a number of sources including feature suggestions from users, sales, technical support, Mathcad support engineers in the field, and our current strategies.

    Thanks for all your suggestions. They are very helpful.

    Mona Zeftel

    Mathcad Senior Technical Consultant.