Skip to main content
juil. 9, 2016 12:48 PM UTC
Question

Surface offset, thicken and shell

With every release of Creo I hope the thicken and shell feature will catch up with rest of the pack. Even Inventor can still do better than this:

When offsetting surfaces that self-intersect, the feature just fails rather than displaying a warning and absorbing the intersecting surface. Catia has been able to do this for years. It might be usually a good idea to have equal wall thicknesses for many manufacturing processes, but surely that is up to the user. - Perhaps I going to 3D print it, or remove the problematic surface later. Or I might just want to get on with my design without the CAD software failing.

I hooped the option to "Prevent shell penetrating solid" might help here, but it doesn't seem to.

160708161800_1.jpg

Why can't I make this surface thicker without the feature failing? Creo should just absorb any self-intersecting surfaces like competing programs do.

14 commentaires

mars 8, 2017 12:22 PM UTC

Has this been sorted for the final release of Creo 4? PTC are in danger of falling even further behind.

mars 10, 2017 7:59 AM UTC

Could you share this part?

mars 10, 2017 12:45 PM UTC

Here it is. The feature fails if the offset is increased any further. Other CAD programs just create a sharp corner where the radius drops below zero.

mars 10, 2017 2:45 PM UTC

This geometry was created with Creo Parametric Sneak Peek Edition and is not compatible with comercial version

mars 13, 2017 6:04 AM UTC

I make offsets every day and I have to confirm that Creo offset tools is not comparable with same tool in Catia. I wish, Creo could make offsets like Catia can.

Make this topic a product idea!

mars 14, 2017 5:27 PM UTC

I've created product idea 8682 Surface offset, thicken and shell.

mars 24, 2017 8:46 AM UTC

thanks Sam, good call.

Surely sometimes geometry is such that you cannot get a 'natural' or 'normal' offset as the geometry falls over itself? interesting what catia does with complex/organic geometry? how about NX or SW?

Having said that I spend time is making internal shells, creating multiple offsets of quilts etc. and merges just to maintain wall thickness.

I do wish the automatic offset actually worked as you say and just creates creases or other it will be a big improvement less features/more robust parametric model and keep intent.

mars 24, 2017 9:27 AM UTC

Dan, I've not been able to try in NX or Saladworks but have just had a go with Onshape, and it works fine as shown below:

Onshape Shell Thicken Test.jpg

avr. 1, 2017 5:10 PM UTC

I've just tried this with my brand shiny new and expensive Creo 4.

It still fails.

mai 19, 2017 11:03 AM UTC

I didn't realize that offset beyond self intersections actually works with other CAD systems.  The offset tool is very central to the work we do.  We spend hours to days trying to fix things to where they actually work without losing the design intent.

juin 2, 2017 2:18 PM UTC

Paul, I made the same assumption, and thought it must be a fundamental problem with the maths behind the surfacing. A quick look at other software shows this is clearly not the case.

I've recently started a new project and have the same problem. On this instance, I can model the 'B' surface, and thicken on the outside, but it's hardly an ideal way of working.

Sam