Skip to main content
Dec 31, 2011 2:08 PM UTC
Question

Quality of Forum Discussion

Now the year is at an end I though I would raise the nagging issue I have had for a while.

Do you agree that the quality of work and questions on display within the Mathcad forum has decreased? Since the old guru's left, the in-depth conversations between the old members has disappeared and we seem to see many threads about licensing or similar issues.

Would it be possible to set a sub-community up for licensing and leave the Mathcad section empty of the negative comments regarding licenses and related issues?

Please let me know your thoughts or proposals

Mike

    7 replies

    Jan 4, 2012 5:47 PM UTC

    Quality in terms of the skill level of the member asking the question?

    A sub-community to contain licensing questions won't hide the licensing discussions. In fact, my gut tells me if we designate such an area, it would be encouraging members to discuss it even further.

    Jan 13, 2012 4:09 PM UTC

    Quality in terms of the skill level of the member asking the question?

    Yes that is exactly what I mean.

    A sub-community to contain licensing questions won't hide the licensing discussions. In fact, my gut tells me if we designate such an area, it would be encouraging members to discuss it even further.

    Yes, maybe it would but at least it wouldn't clutter the main Mathcad section up. If someone has a licensing problem, they will discuss it no matter where the sub-community is.

    Mike

    Jan 13, 2012 4:50 PM UTC

    A sub-community to contain licensing questions won't hide the licensing discussions. In fact, my gut tells me if we designate such an area, it would be encouraging members to discuss it even further.

    Yes, maybe it would but at least it wouldn't clutter the main Mathcad section up. If someone has a licensing problem, they will discuss it no matter where the sub-community is.

    Before adding another, there's still the matter of consolidating the existing less-traveled, less active Mathcad sub-communities.

    Jan 4, 2012 7:53 PM UTC
    Do you agree that the quality of work and questions on display within the Mathcad forum has decreased?

    Yes.

    Please let me know your thoughts or proposals

    Wait. Maybe new people will join and the level of discussion will return to what we used to have on the Collaboratory. Then again, maybe it won't. Sorry, but I cannot think of anything you or I could do that will change the situation.

    Jan 4, 2012 8:19 PM UTC

    Wait. Maybe new people will join and the level of discussion will return to what we used to have on the Collaboratory. Then again, maybe it won't. Sorry, but I cannot think of anything you or I could do that will change the situation.

    I think that's exactly what it is. New Mathcad members in the sense that:

    • they never had exposure to the Collab and are getting their fix now
    • new to Mathcad all together and are asking elementary level questions

    Once community registrations level off and the newer members get ramped up with the software, the quality (more advanced) topics will start to flow again [or more so].

    I also realize the same questions continue to be asked over and over again. And you are reluctant to respond because the answer already exists somewhere else in the community (I believe this is what spawned the Mathcad FAQ document) and you'd rather be spending your time assisting members with more challenging issues. How about we try an experiment? You let the 'easy' questions pass on to the next tier of experts so they can start building a reputation and status within the community. Sort of like training them to become power users like yourselves?

    I'll be honest, I actually prefer questions to asked several times over. Mainly because it makes for the appearance of a super-active community. If no one is posting, the community appears to be dead. No new content translates into no repeat visits.

    Jan 13, 2012 4:12 PM UTC

    I think that's exactly what it is. New Mathcad members in the sense that:

    • they never had exposure to the Collab and are getting their fix now
    • new to Mathcad all together and are asking elementary level questions

    Once community registrations level off and the newer members get ramped up with the software, the quality (more advanced) topics will start to flow again [or more so].

    Good point.

    I also realize the same questions continue to be asked over and over again. And you are reluctant to respond because the answer already exists somewhere else in the community (I believe this is what spawned the Mathcad FAQ document) and you'd rather be spending your time assisting members with more challenging issues. How about we try an experiment? You let the 'easy' questions pass on to the next tier of experts so they can start building a reputation and status within the community. Sort of like training them to become power users like yourselves?

    I'll be honest, I actually prefer questions to asked several times over. Mainly because it makes for the appearance of a super-active community. If no one is posting, the community appears to be dead. No new content translates into no repeat visits.

    Well I can see your point of view. Remember even is a question is repeated the solution is not always the same and different collabs will respond.

    Mike