Skip to main content
Jul 26, 2016 10:28 AM UTC
Question

MBD: Additional texts in geometric tolerances

Good morning:

Now with Creo 4 It is possible to put additionsl texts surrounded with a box in the geometric tolerances, but the option only appears for up and botton texts,  not for rigth and left texts. Are the options for boxed text on the right and the left to be included in future versions?

Besides, the box and the text don´t appear together. Is it a bug to be solved in F000?

Thank you for your attention, best regards,

Nekane Peña

21 replies

Jul 26, 2016 3:40 PM UTC

The top and bottoms boxes seem to be displaying correctly for me...

Jul 27, 2016 7:48 AM UTC

Good morning Tom:

Yes, you are right, it works correctly with new parts, created with Creo 4, beta. We get the same as you. But if the part is old, created with Creo/Parametric 2.0 and the additinal texts of the geometric tolerances are edited with Creo 4 beta, we get separate text and box, like in the firts image I sent.

Best regards,

Nekane

Jul 27, 2016 9:02 AM UTC

But I was able to create the additional text without box for the part and drawing both created in Creo 2.0

Jul 27, 2016 6:36 PM UTC

The intent behind allowing boxes on the above and below text fields was to support some constructs that were specified in old versions of the GD&T standards.

For example, in the 1982 version of ASME Y14.5, the method of indicating projected tolerance zone was to place the circle P character in a box below the feature control frame.

I'm not aware of any places in the standards where some text appearing to the right or to the left of a feature control frame needs to be placed in a box. If there is such an indication in a standard, please let me know.

Even if it's not found in a standard, I'm curious how you would expect to use the box on text to the left or right of the feature control frame. If you can provide an example of what this should look like, I'm interested in seeing it.

I should also mention that the misaligned text and box is just a bug that we will fix by the time F000 is shipped.

Jul 27, 2016 7:06 PM UTC

Sometimes we have "boxed" notes and those boxed notes can proceed a dimension.

Jul 27, 2016 7:26 PM UTC

That's a note, not a feature control frame.  You can do that today.

Video Link : 7125