Skip to main content
Oct 8, 2010 4:24 PM UTC
Question

FAQ Discussion

A note to anyone reading this thread for the first time: This is NOT the FAQ! Is is a thread where FAQ related issues are discussed.

As already discussed in another thread, we need a FAQ! So this thread is to discuss what our options are for creating a FAQ, what should be in it, what access control is needed, etc.

I think the best option for the format would be a document post, if we can upload multiple worksheets. That must be possible somehow, because it was done here: http://communities.ptc.com/docs/DOC-1157 but I can't see how to do it.

As a starter for content I'll suggest:

Range variables vs vectors. Not a question that is ever asked, but it leads to so much confusion a document we could point to would be very handy. We can steal the article Stuart wrote for PTC express (I think it was Stuart) as a starting point.

Functionalizing solve blocks. This come up a lot, and it's a minefield because the right way to do it depends on the type of solve block and the version of Mathcad!

Other suggestions please everyone

    26 replies

    RichardJAuthor
    Oct 8, 2010 4:35 PM UTC

    Here's another possibility

    Create a new forum, called "FAQ".

    Anyone can post to the discussions, but all the other sections (documents, blogs etc) would have restricted access for content creation. I don't know if it's possible to create a forum with permissions like that (any comments on that Dan?), I'm just throwing it out as an idea.

    Oct 8, 2010 7:14 PM UTC

    Richard Jackson wrote:

    Here's another possibility

    Create a new forum, called "FAQ".

    Anyone can post to the discussions, but all the other sections (documents, blogs etc) would have restricted access for content creation. I don't know if it's possible to create a forum with permissions like that (any comments on that Dan?), I'm just throwing it out as an idea.

    Question to Dan - Would there be a way to give a member permissions to run his own "sub forum". For example make a sub forum called Mathcad Guru's and have a set amount of topics within it - Called something simple like "Richards Section".

    Just an idea?

    Mike

    Oct 11, 2010 6:46 PM UTC

    Adding another sub-community would not be ideal. You already expressed how difficult it is to easily view new posts since your last visit. Adding another sub-community would only add to that frustration. If anything, we should looking to reducing the amount of sub-communitites, not increasing them.

    -Dan

    Oct 8, 2010 7:11 PM UTC

    How about data manipulation functions?

    We often get asked how do you find the value in a vector which is greater then x, less than x, how many times x occurs, remove negative values, remove duplicate values....etc

    Mike

    RichardJAuthor
    Oct 8, 2010 8:01 PM UTC

    Yes, lookup functions would be a good one.

    Oct 8, 2010 7:28 PM UTC

    Another thought.....

    Components, Insert / Export file functions....

    There will be piles of suggestions, that's why the Mathcad Guru section will work.

    Mike

    Oct 8, 2010 11:58 PM UTC

    I don't think that a FAQ could be the better idea, I think more in a wiki. The wiki concept it's a technology, like the mathcad's scracht pad, and can came as software in the implementation. I don't know if this site have implemented a wiki, but at least, as it is free, maybe we can ask for having wiki entries, probably as a button like the red b-log botton.

    Mathcad quicksheets are the thing more identical to a wiki in the format and pressentation, but are actually quite different from the creation process and, important, from the implementation as a software. Maybe most of the entries for a mathcad wiki must to be started as an addendum for the mathcad quicksheets, but I don't know if they are free in the sense that we can reproduce -thing that at least lot of us do, but not with a massive reproduction.

    Also, the mathcad help is in html format in the hard disk, I don't know if this can be leave somewhere in the www, to answer some question with a link to the appropiate help page - anywhere, the help isn't that useful as the quicksheets are.

    Regards. Alvaro.

    RichardJAuthor
    Oct 11, 2010 5:40 PM UTC

    I don't think that a FAQ could be the better idea, I think more in a wiki. The wiki concept it's a technology, like the mathcad's scracht pad, and can came as software in the implementation. I don't know if this site have implemented a wiki, but at least, as it is free, maybe we can ask for having wiki entries, probably as a button like the red b-log botton.

    I'm not sure what you mean. You can create a sort of Wiki by creating a document post and allowing anyone to edit the document.

    I think what we need need are mulitple documents though, all in one place so they are easy to find. They also need to have restricted access (I believe even Wikipedia has editorial review of many, altough not all, articles before changes are actually allowed) to stop documents getting changed by people that only think they know what they are doing (like me ). I don't know how to do that though.I can create a single document in one location with restricted access, but not many. I am hoping to hear back from Dan on what our options are in that regard.

    Oct 12, 2010 7:42 AM UTC

    Richard Jackson wrote:


    I think what we need need are mulitple documents though, all in one place so they are easy to find. They also need to have restricted access (I believe even Wikipedia has editorial review of many, altough not all, articles before changes are actually allowed) to stop documents getting

    Please see "Features of corporate wikis" in http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enterprise_wiki, Wikis have their own search engine, and also, as collabs can be very good in their fields but maybe not writing in html, wiki usually are organized with easy linking system, i.e. the names of the pages must to be simplest and descriptives; that's between others considerations. For this is why I expose the wiki technology at the same level of Mathcad, or other piece of good software.

    Even I undestand the purpose for having blogs at each subcommunity, if you askme to rigorosly explain this fact to another maybe I can't find enough arguments. But have more than five to have a wiki for each subcommunity, and/or for have it also for each user.

    You can try to use your personal wiki downloading one at http://www.tiddlywiki.com/.

    Request for wiki format support: http://collab.mathsoft.com/read?110118,12e#110118

    About restricting access to the wiki pages, given that this is a moderate forum, and we must to login to write anything, having a history of the wiki pages, and the names of the collabs that modifies the pages together the "Report abuse" button, is enough, and wiki pages can be opened to anyone in this forum.

    Regards. Alvaro.

    Oct 11, 2010 4:25 PM UTC

    At the time of this post - 156views and 6 posts from 3 forum members.

    Other members must surley have some suggestions which can be used in a FAQ document.

    Mike

    Oct 11, 2010 6:42 PM UTC

    Richard,

    I think the best option for the format would be a document post, if we can upload multiple worksheets. That must be possible somehow, because it was done here: http://communities.ptc.com/docs/DOC-1157 but I can't see how to do it.

    The link you referenced above is a link to the Need Help? wiki. It's used as a table of contents. The links on that table of contents links to 13 other wiki documents.

    As a starter for content I'll suggest:

    Range variables vs vectors. Not a question that is ever asked, but it leads to so much confusion a document we could point to would be very handy. We can steal the article Stuart wrote for PTC express (I think it was Stuart) as a starting point.

    Functionalizing solve blocks. This come up a lot, and it's a minefield because the right way to do it depends on the type of solve block and the version of Mathcad!

    Here it looks like you want to start with two topics for the FAQ document. So you'll want to create 3 wikis. One titled "Range Variables vs. Vectors," the second titled "Functionlizing Solve Blocks." The thrid wiki will act as the table of contents (FAQ master file) that links to the first two wikis (Have I lost you yet? ).

    From my understanding, you only want a select few to be able to contribute to this growing list of FAQ's. Here's an example of the collaboration options:

    wikisettings.png

    -Dan

    Oct 12, 2010 7:07 AM UTC

    Dan,

    Exactly what this forum needs - that would give the document creator the ability to control the thread.

    The only problem I can see is that the documents doesn't appear in the recent activity stream when a comment is made, therefore will be lost unless specifically searched for.

    Mike

    Oct 12, 2010 1:57 PM UTC

    I can feature the document on the main Mathcad homepage so it will be front and center for every member that visits.

    Nov 8, 2010 1:12 PM UTC

    where_the_publish_button.PNG

    1) Where this bloody button?

    2) Where I can swith forum to standard view (not tree)? I found this style notuseful.

    3) How I can make bootmark to the discussion?

    Nov 8, 2010 2:44 PM UTC

    Vitaliy,

    Vitaliy Timoshenko wrote:

    1) Where this bloody button? It's located at the very bottom of the 'video create page.' I believe you found it since it published? Uncorrect works with font in PDF

    2) Where I can swith forum to standard view (not tree)? I found this style notuseful. Edit Preferences Discussion View Style should be set to 'Flat'

    3) How I can make bootmark to the discussion? You can use the Bookmark tool that's built into your browser or the 'Bookmark this' from the Actions box when you're viewing the discussion to be bookmarked

    ActionsBox_bookmark.png

    -Dan

    Feb 15, 2011 11:39 PM UTC

    What is the difference between a discussion and a question? Apparently it is a really important distinction because I only have 15 minutes after creating one of them to switch it to the other one. OH MY GOODNESS GRACIOUS! But I have no idea why it is so important to choose one over the other. I'm assuming one of them is limited? Do I only get a certain number of questions but unlimited discussions?

    RichardJAuthor
    Feb 15, 2011 11:45 PM UTC

    What is the difference between a discussion and a question? Apparently it is a really important distinction because I only have 15 minutes after creating one of them to switch it to the other one. OH MY GOODNESS GRACIOUS! But I have no idea why it is so important to choose one over the other. I'm assuming one of them is limited? Do I only get a certain number of questions but unlimited discussions?

    As far as I know, the only difference is whether or not you can subsequently flag a particular answer as either helpful of the correct answer. That can be useful to a later visitor to the thread, but I wouldn't worry about it too much. The rest of us don't

    Feb 20, 2011 7:34 PM UTC

    I find it hilarious that when I uploaded my avatar picture I was forced to crop it twice.

    Feb 21, 2011 9:35 AM UTC

    I find it hilarious that when I uploaded my avatar picture I was forced to crop it twice.

    That is a little trivial and annoying, but not the end of the world.

    Least you found it amusing.

    Mike

    http://communities.ptc.com/servlet/JiveServlet/showImage/2-149416-2532/bar_anim.gif