Skip to main content
May 8, 2015 9:07 AM UTC
Question

Discussion forums in PDMLink

Hello,

while PTC made some efforts to improve the discussion pages in PDMLink 10.x it is far to be as efficient, nice to use, user friendly etc... than for instance the forum of the ptcusercommunity.

It does not appear that complicated to integrate in Windchill nice discussion forum. In the past I was told that PTC was not going to make much effort because they have the Social tool and wanted to promote it (and sale it) rather improving the pdmlink discussion forum. While this makes sense in a way. I do not hear much about that tool these days.

I am therefore wondering what PTC strategy is. In the past I had some hard time and not alwas successed to get the users use the discussion forum rather than sending emails. One of the reasons is that user did not like it. while most of them were using all sort of specilized discussion forum. Therefore it was not that they did not like discussion forum, they just did not like the old style, low functionalities discussion forum of PDMLink.

As a consequence. what are my options ?

  1. Ask a programmer to customize PDMLink and make the discussion forum be eg like the one of ptcusercommunity ?
  2. Train my users that I do not need all those fancy buttons and layout and the PDMLink discussion forums does the job
  3. Wait for PTC to finally put some development into it
  4. Buy PTC Social (whatever name it is/was) or third party software and integrate ?

How do you make your users collaborate by using the discussion forum in PDMLink ?

Thanks

Best regards

13 replies

May 8, 2015 6:02 PM UTC

I have yet to see an environment with successful social collaboration in use. If anyone else has, and whatever the results you achieve, will be looking forward to hearing what you do.

May 8, 2015 7:03 PM UTC

I think discussion forums are not a good approach for certain problems. Since they are linear, they tend to accumulate data into long threads that are mostly meaningless to most of the users and can't be reformatted to be more useful. They are good for interaction, but mostly I see this from PTC User, PTC Community, and other forums among people who would never ordinarily meet. I can see where e-mail and phone calls become more preferred among those who work closely. There's no logging-in and no extra training or discipline.

For keeping information about the design process I think WIkis are a better alternative. It is easy enough to consolidate information from e-mails and reformat discussions, while maintaining traceability of participant contributions. The best part is they not only allow crosslinks, but links outside, so that if a reader is trying to find out something they can rapidly follow both internal content and external references. It's almost like someone could build an encyclopedia with this; maybe call it Wikipedia.

The links mean that contracts, requirements, tests, inspection reports, specifications, et al can be accessed as rapidly as a person can read the information and decide what to do next. I typically harvest the text from documents to form the page content, so I don't have delays in opening Acrobat, or Word, or Excel to get the content and so I can in-line notes without affecting the original document. Harvesting also allows correcting information, particularly in Acrobat documents that have had OCR applied - some MIL specs could not be meaningfully indexed, which other systems (Sharepoint) might depend on.

The Wiki can also be accessed by anyone authorized, and they do have as detailed permissions as you want, with a web browser, in a primarily read-only format (unlike Word) but with easy purposeful editing as required. If someone needs significant training to edit a Wiki page, they probably should not have access to the computer.

To those who say that a WIki cannot work, I'd say companies have the same problem with CAD, in which a number of people have to work on a common platform, with users interacting to produce a single output. A Wiki is like CAD, but for everyone in the company.

cc-2Author
May 11, 2015 10:05 AM UTC

Hi David,

I like your idea of Wiki, Frankly speaking I tend to mix discussion forum and Wiki. in the sense that this is where people exchange ideas, discuss etc...

So in that case my question is more. Does PTC intend to include a Wiki module which is enterely integrated into Windchill ?

Nonetheless, I would be more than happy if PDMLink forum looked like the PTCUserCommunity forum

Thanks

Best regards

Oct 23, 2015 5:27 AM UTC

I belief if the discussion would be more powerful and intuitive it would be used a lot more. Sometimes it would make really sense to discuss someting directly in Windchill. E.g.

  • Problem Report
  • Change Request
  • Change Notice
  • Customer Experience
  • Nonconformance
  • CAPA
  • ...

Such topics are mostly not clear and needs a discussion. And also with the subscription it's possible to inform more then just one user.

But the discussion needs a makeover. You should be able to mark some answer as best answer and also a history is necessary if the user edits or deletes an entry.

There are already some ideas about discussion improvements:

Convert Windchill Discussion Comments to Rich Text Format (RTF)

New WYSIWYG (Rich Text) Attribute type

Enable @ callouts in Discussions

is it possible in Windchill to have the live discussion like as on skype?

Oct 23, 2015 6:08 AM UTC
Oct 23, 2015 7:11 AM UTC

Generally I think we all agree that if Windchill is to be considered as the Single Source of Truth, we must be able to discuss in an efficient manner.

There is already a discussion forum which has improved in 10.0   As Mike said, it does the job, may require some guideline for the users.  (eg in my company I implemented a "Inform users when you create a new post, so they can subscribe if interested, otherwise there is no way they know a new post was created".

I insist that from my point of view it does the job and has all the basic functionalities you expect from a discussion forum

This said, the user base is continuously increasing with people who are used to more sophisticated discussion forum (Take the ptcusercommunity powered by Jive for instance). and therefore find the discussion forum in PDMLink out dated and not user friendly.

PTC used to have a Social module for PDMLink, not sure of the name now, I wonder what happened to it.

From my point of view, we should be able to capture of the "real" history of the data/document in Windchill. That is, we should be able to retrieve the reason why a decision was taken at any point of time. Decisions are taken by discussing with people therefore those discussions should be captured.

Someone suggested to add instant messaging, why not ?

I would then add, sometimes we take decision over the phone or video conference, in theory this should also need to be recorded.

However, we have to draw the line somewhere. Everybody has limited number of resources and and budget and we have to respect that PTC has sometimes to take difficult decisions too.

However, we , people who have discussing for months about that topic, that some improvement could be easily made (after all Windchill is web based) and that would be a quick win

brueegg,, with no surprise I voted up

PS: Finger crossed maybe PTC has a nice surprise for us in Windchill 11