Skip to main content
Jul 6, 2016 2:52 AM UTC
Question

Creo - Top Down Design

The advanced assembly extension offers some great features.  Having said that, not every user has a need for all of those features, but I'd bet that the vast majority do at least occasionally have the desire to use some form of top down design.  What are the chances that Creo 4.0 or some future release will allow all users (i.e. not just those with AAX) to do an external merge rather than having to manage another assembly just for that and/or deal with in-context features?  I think this would put its basic top-down assembly abilities more on par with some other CAD packages, while still saving its more advanced TDD features for the AAX module.  It could help entice some smaller to mid size companies to consider using Creo if they aren't already.  Just my two cents...

9 replies

Jul 6, 2016 8:42 AM UTC

Hi gtorrisi,

thanks for your contribution.

regards

Arnaud

Feb 4, 2017 11:54 AM UTC

Does PTC have an answer to this question?

Feb 7, 2017 10:58 AM UTC

I don’t share the expressed point of view that you need external Merge/Inheritance to do basic top down design and think that the AAX package has a well-balanced content.

Feb 17, 2017 3:42 PM UTC

AAX might be well balanced, but its also expensive. What top-down tools are available with the basic Creo? I try and create assembly features and copy them directly to the parts. This works but it is easy to inadvertently create circular references and its dangerous if the parts are opened out of context.

Sam

3-Newcomer
Feb 21, 2017 2:59 PM UTC

I think you've found the big downside of trying to do TDD without copy geometry (and, ideally, publish geometry) features.  It's very easy to create a mess of dependencies and every part requires the assy to be present to properly regenerate.  It's doable, but costly in terms of management time.

Yes, AAX is expensive, but by consistently and extensively leveraging the TDD tools of skeletons, copy gems and publish geoms I find that it pays for itself in faster, more accurate work every year.  I've taken on projects with ridiculous deadlines only because I knew that I could use the Creo TDD tools to get it done. 

One client had an extensive prototype database already developed in SW, but his hard fast deadline was so short (development of an assy of about 200 molded plastic parts to tooling release in about 120 days) one requirement of us taking on the production work was that we would use Creo TDD tools.  We were starting fresh anyway, and we just didn't think that we could get done in SW.  We did it in Creo.