Skip to main content
Dec 16, 2022 7:49 PM UTC
Acknowledged

Creo View MCAD to 'Compare' Models that include Bodies

1. Describe your environment: What is your industry? What is your role in your organization? Describe your stakeholders.
We design and manufacture high-end electronics. I am the CAD Manager / PTC SME. Stakeholders for this idea include our Creo Parametric, Windchill and Creo View user community; a big part of our organization.


2. What product and version are you currently running?
Creo View 9.1 with Creo Parametric 8.0.6.0

3. Describe the problem you are trying to solve. Please include detailed documentation such as screenshots, images or video.
Refer to case 16669999

 

For those who are unaware, there is additional functionality, on top of Creo View Lite, that requires extra licenses. One of this functionality we feel bring a lot of value is the 'COMPARE' tool within the Creo View MCAD license. It allows for an easy way to view changes between drawings, parts and assemblies. 

 

However, it has come to our attention that Creo View 9.1 (and under) can't compare models that include bodies from Creo Parametric 7. This caught us off guard, since Creo View should support new functionality with Creo Parametric. Creo View 7 should support Creo Parametric 7, Creo View 8 should support Creo Parametric 8... and so on. Here, we have Creo View 9.1 (just released) still not supporting functionality with Creo Parametric 7!

 

It gets even worse. If we have 2 versions of a product, and we would like to see what changed, the comparison won't work as long as 1 part, inside the product, has more than one body. This can be even a resistor! Furthermore, it still won't work if you don't ask for any geometry or mass data analysis. All we want to know is what got added, removed or moved. We don't care about bodies!

 

We now have two options moving forward:

1 - Not to renew these licenses and explain to leadership and our sales rep why this amazing tool no longer works with 3 year old files

2 - Go to the PLM team and convince them to change their recipe settings to publish for Creo View 6.1! Then, they need to republish ALL visualizations from the last 3 years!

 

I'm not liking any of those 2 options. If PTC product management could commit to a Creo View 10 release, then we could most likely hold out; since most 'Comparisons' happen at the part or drawing level; not necessarily at the product level.

 

jwagh_0-1671219233316.png

jwagh_1-1671219471836.png

 


4. What is the use case for your organization?
We have use-cases where bodies are being used (although rarely) and now we loose the main functionality within Creo View MCAD that we bought it for. We can't go back as we have data (especially library data) already within Windchill that includes bodies.

5. What business value would your suggestion represent for your organization?
I consider this a 'regression'. Therefore, if this doesn't get 'fixed', we would loose business value as we can no longer compare cad data from Windchill using Creo View. It would definitely cause concern during our renewal period whether these licenses should be renewed if Creo View can't even work with 3 year old Creo files.

6 replies

olivierlp
Community Manager
Dec 16, 2022 7:57 PM UTC
Status changed to: Acknowledged

Thank you @jwagh for your idea. Based on the information you provided, we are acknowledging it as the Community management team. This is not a commitment from the Product team. Other users may comment and vote your idea up.

Olivier
jwaghAuthor
Jan 31, 2023 9:43 PM UTC

FYI, you need to modify the setting to Creo 4, not Creo 6.

 

jwagh_0-1675201354901.png

 

adapter/outputPView=1300

See article: https://www.ptc.com/en/support/article/CS382879

 

Jun 6, 2024 11:23 AM UTC

this is very good idea and now that some of our design office are designing  with multibody they need to be able to compare 2 different parts.

Jul 31, 2025 8:19 PM UTC

Is this resolved in the new version?  Picture below is from Creo View 11 with Creo Parametric 10 checked in model to Windchill 12. 

 

2025-07-31 15_17_12-Creo View 11 Enhancements.pptx - PowerPoint.png

jwaghAuthor
Aug 1, 2025 2:36 PM UTC

@BillRyan ,

The picture is for interference detection, not Compare. I just checked and Compare still does not work with Creo View 12:

jwagh_0-1754058985228.png

jwagh_1-1754058992358.png

 

Aug 1, 2025 3:16 PM UTC

Thanks for the clarification.  I tried to get creative by using the Interference tool with two versions of the same model to see if I could "compare" differences.  It failed.