Skip to main content
Apr 4, 2012 3:18 PM UTC
Under Consideration

Update Pro Program

Related products:Creo Parametric

Update Pro Program to be a scripting language that is a subset of Toolkit or Object Toolkit. Give us more functionality in Pro Program such as the ability to loop, more data types, ability to create functions/methods. This tool has not seen an update in several years.

14 replies

Aug 17, 2015 2:54 AM UTC

I fully agree to all of the above ...... +++++1

ProProgram needs to be made much more versatile - it is prehistoric right now (perhaps it needs a complete RELOOKt).

Does PTC not want more users and Creo to be more popular ???

The essence of running a successful business is to be able to cut down the design and manufacturing time.

I have been using ProEngineer/WIldfire/Creo for the last 20 years in transformer design. We have used layouts (now notebook) in a big way to populate parameters in parts, assemblies and drawings. To be able to automate, I have struggled to put logic in notebooks, parts and assemblies because of the limited programming and data handling functionality available.

We have used excel with a VB user interface for data input and calculation of child parameters based on logic.

Then we have used a Java routine to create and transfer the values of parameters from excel into a designated file (in this case it happens to be notebook because then all the components declared to it get the data; but it can be a part, assembly or a drawing).

However, this is a very complicated mechanism. Logics in excel are nested and sometimes when we want to edit, the time spent is enormous. Also, any errors get lost in the recursive formulae. Further, the knowledge of excel, Java and VB becomes essential.

Now, that MathCAD Prime has been implemented, why can it not be made to interact with notebook so that we do not need any excel, java or any other language to manage the logic, input and the transfer of parameter values to notebook ???

I have been told that we are the only people around with this kind of requirement, but I simply fail to comprehend that nobody else uses Creo like we do.

To me, propagating the value of parameters to parts & assemblies via notebook is a very robust and clean method.

Years ago, Mike Campbell was here in Melbourne for a User's Conference. I had then discussed with him all of the above (except that MathCAD was nowhere on the scene). Since then little has been done by PTC to enable the above!

I hope PTC are listening and we get something happening !!

Jun 14, 2018 6:24 PM UTC
Status changed to: Acknowledged
Aug 19, 2020 3:39 PM UTC
Status changed to: Under Consideration

PTC has considered modernizing Pro/PROGRAM to support new languages like Python.  In fact, there is debate about converting mapkeys into scripting language supported with Python to improve the ability to edit and update macros.  As we consider a viable approach to this, we will also consider the impact across other areas of Creo to unify the approach.   This is on the roadmap for a future release of Creo.

 

Regards,

Mark Fischer

Sr. Director, CAD Product Management

Jun 15, 2023 2:23 PM UTC

+1 !

It is good to see that PTC is considering to update Pro Program, finally it moved up in the ranking! When I started using it in 1994 it already felt very limited and out of date compared to other programs. Nothing has changed since so I would really welcome it if it would be updated.