Skip to main content
Oct 17, 2019 10:03 PM UTC
Implementation In Progress

Surface desing- smooth radius corner

Related products:Creo Parametric

It should be possible to generate corner radius, like the image bellow.5.PNG

 

At the moment creo has the ability to generate a corner sphere radius. But it should be usefull to generate a simillar quality radius setback.

 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P57yWtDxlxA

15 replies

T_FAuthor
Dec 6, 2019 12:09 PM UTC

for the ones who works in metal stamping industries, will understand this need. This is very usefull, to prevent cracks in metal stamping parts. Solidworks, solidedge, CATIA, NX, Inventor has this feature. The solution provided by CREO isn't the best solution for this type of corners. Please take a look deeply in this enhancement.

T_FAuthor
Jan 9, 2020 9:50 AM UTC

Once again.

 

I have this surface:

 

T_F_0-1578563325584.png

And I need to draw the following.

 

T_F_1-1578563389329.png

 

Still no way of how to do it.

 

Jan 9, 2020 2:36 PM UTC
You might be able to create the geometry in the forming tool (die etc.). That's a weird looking blend, I've never seen anything like it, but then I'm not an expert sheet metal guy. Best of luck!
T_FAuthor
Jan 9, 2020 2:38 PM UTC

Do you have any suggestion?


"You might be able to create the geometry in the forming tool (die etc.)."

Jan 9, 2020 2:58 PM UTC
Try looking at the picture I posted and do that transition radius on your tool. I haven't played much with sheet metal dies/forms, but I think that'd be the way you'd want to go. There are some experts here.
T_FAuthor
Jan 9, 2020 5:11 PM UTC

Sorry, I can't find your picture, can you tell me where it is?

 

Jan 22, 2020 2:44 PM UTC

We complained about this issue also in other suggestions/ideas. Having a better transition to corner edges is a must in your modelling strategies. We don’t develop product, we only design/produce stamping tools, and we can’t impose the limited corner sphere transition that simply doesn’t work in most cases.

 

In this picture there’s a simple Catia automotive part (the cad system used to develop the majority of automotive body parts), the transitions are smooth and simple but we can’t replicate them with any radius transition solution in Creo.

 

PASousa_0-1579703887109.png

 

PTC should address this issue with more care and more proactivity.

Jan 22, 2020 9:55 PM UTC
As I understand it Catia is WAY more expensive, so, you can't certain features in a lower-priced CAD package.
T_FAuthor
Jan 22, 2020 10:30 PM UTC

You are right, but you need to explain me also, how even smaller budget CAD tools, like solidworks, solidedge, inventor, are able to create this within radius command??? So if the lower and the high end CAD packages have the hability for this, why the Middle one don't. It simply don't make any sense!

T_FAuthor
Jan 22, 2020 10:50 PM UTC

Inventor example :

https://youtu.be/u9doNhT4E3E

 

Inventor costs nearly half of CREO

 

Solidworks example :

https://youtu.be/45OWkBGwYt8