Skip to main content
Apr 2, 2014 11:38 PM UTC
Delivered

Stop Model Tree Reorder Becoming a Restructure

Related products:Creo Parametric

I've been asked to raise this enhancement request on behalf of a couple of colleagues.

Their main issue was:

"When trying to drag a component for reorder in the model tree, the holding time is too short to reorder well, the component will get restructured into another sub-assembly"

And the response we got from TS was:

"The issue is considered as works to spec since the holding time was implemented per PD's decision."

The users are finding that when they try to drag a component in the model tree to reorder, Creo is restructuring the component into a sub assembly.

Once this happpens, the ability to undo is lost and it is a pain to back out of.

Components are snapping way too quickly into a restructure.

We would like to see either:

1. Slow down the process (back to 2 sec as it originally was) so the the user has time to see that a restructure is going to occur instead of a reorder.

2. Have the ability to toggle and choose b/w restructure and reorder if the system defaults to a restructure.

3. A config setting to allow the user to set the default time to a longer value.

31 replies

Aug 7, 2018 10:20 PM UTC

Thanks for the tip, ill give it a try.

Community Manager
Sep 19, 2019 4:35 PM UTC

I've been asked to raise this enhancement request on behalf of a couple of colleagues.

 

Their main issue was:

"When trying to drag a component for reorder in the model tree, the holding time is too short to reorder well, the component will get restructured into another sub-assembly"

 

And the response we got from TS was:

"The issue is considered as works to spec since the holding time was implemented per PD's decision."

 

The users are finding that when they try to drag a component in the model tree to reorder, Creo is restructuring the component into a sub assembly.

 

Once this happpens, the ability to undo is lost and it is a pain to back out of.

 

Components are snapping way too quickly into a restructure.

 

We would like to see either:

 

1. Slow down the process (back to 2 sec as it originally was) so the the user has time to see that a restructure is going to occur instead of a reorder.

 

2. Have the ability to toggle and choose b/w restructure and reorder if the system defaults to a restructure.

 

3. A config setting to allow the user to set the default time to a longer value.

Aug 5, 2020 7:34 AM UTC
Status changed to: Under Consideration

This is on the roadmap. We will review the UX of drag&drop reorder/restructure one more time.

Apr 6, 2022 3:44 PM UTC

Why is the most voted enhancement still not fixed properly after 2 years.... PTC come on, you have to show you are really listening to your users and not only bragging about it in presentations and release notes..

Apr 6, 2022 8:07 PM UTC

This is amplified since there are so many people working from home and remoting in to workstations.

The slight lag makes it so this never works correctly.

A simple dwell adjustment for the function would increase productivity and lessen user frustration.

PTC, stop "considering" and just implement it already.

May 2, 2022 10:53 AM UTC
Status changed to: Implementation In Progress

being worked on for Creo 10.0

Apr 21, 2023 10:07 AM UTC
Status changed to: Delivered

This enhancement is addressed with Creo 10.0.

See https://support.ptc.com/help/creo/creo_pma/r10.0/usascii/whats_new_pma/ux_reorder_and_restrucure.html#

 

Dec 20, 2023 2:24 PM UTC

Good to see the second most voted enhancement request is solved! Still the most important thing that needs to be solved is not the support of multi-CPU's but the speed of which PTC is solving quite simple ideas as improving a restructure. It took 9 YEARS!!!!!!