Skip to main content
Aug 8, 2024 9:14 AM UTC
Acknowledged

Sheetmetal Blend - Request for Improvement

Related products:Creo Parametric

There are multiple posts asking how to blend a square to circle, but instead of "rolling" the corners (Die Formed) some would like the Brake Formed method (rounds divided into equal bends/facets) and all involve a rather complex workaround that don't always have the best results.

 

This is a request for enhancement as even a tool like Fusion360 has the option to switch between the two.

You can see it here: https://youtu.be/g4LYh2__uqE?t=168

If the link doesn't work, just search on Youtube "Fusion360 - Lofted Flange Closed Profile".

 

In the video you can see that a simple square and a simple circle are drawn offset from each other and a lofted feature is used, the only "hiccup" in the video was adding a rip... That's it.

 

Whereas in Creo:
- Your square needs rounded corners (fillets) and said rounds need to be manually drawn in facets.

- The circle needs to be faceted as well (you can't just draw a circle).

- The facets of the "circle" need to be parallel to the line entities in the square as this can cause the surface(s) to twist (if this happens, you can still create the sheetmetal but unable to make a flat pattern).

 

Like I said, this is a request for an enhancement. There are already multiple posts on how others have achieved this (linked below) but it just feels wrong that in a tool like Creo, this functionality doesn't exist.

 

Here is a link to the topics where they discuss the workaround:

https://community.ptc.com/t5/3D-Part-Assembly-Design/How-can-I-unbend-square-to-ellipse-blend-in-creo-sheetmetal-I-am/m-p/156772

https://community.ptc.com/t5/3D-Part-Assembly-Design/Sheetmetal-unbend-fails-for-a-swept-blend/m-p/867068#M128641

 

Creo version: 11.0.1.0

 

6 replies

Aug 8, 2024 11:28 AM UTC

If you want to suggest a product enhancement the way to do that is to create an "idea" here:

https://community.ptc.com/t5/Creo-Parametric-Ideas/idb-p/creoparametric 

 

The more people that vote on it the more likely it is to be considered in theory.

Aug 8, 2024 11:38 AM UTC

1. Describe the Problem

There are multiple posts asking how to blend a square to circle, but instead of "rolling" the corners (Die Formed) some would like the Brake Formed method (rounds divided into equal bends/facets) and all involve a rather complex workaround that don't always have the best results.

 

This is a request for enhancement as even a tool like Fusion360 has the option to switch between the two.

You can see it here: https://youtu.be/g4LYh2__uqE?t=168

If the link doesn't work, just search on Youtube "Fusion360 - Lofted Flange Closed Profile".

 

In the video you can see that a simple square and a simple circle are drawn offset from each other and a lofted feature is used, the only "hiccup" in the video was adding a rip... That's it.

 

Whereas in Creo:
- Your square needs rounded corners (fillets) and said rounds need to be manually drawn in facets.

- The circle needs to be faceted as well (you can't just draw a circle).

- The facets of the "circle" need to be parallel to the line entities in the square as this can cause the surface(s) to twist (if this happens, you can still create the sheetmetal but unable to make a flat pattern).

 

Like I said, this is a request for an enhancement. There are already multiple posts on how others have achieved this (linked below) but it just feels wrong that in a tool like Creo, this functionality doesn't exist.

 

Here is a link to the topics where they discuss the workaround:

https://community.ptc.com/t5/3D-Part-Assembly-Design/How-can-I-unbend-square-to-ellipse-blend-in-creo-sheetmetal-I-am/m-p/156772

https://community.ptc.com/t5/3D-Part-Assembly-Design/Sheetmetal-unbend-fails-for-a-swept-blend/m-p/867068#M128641


2. Are you using a workaround?
Yes, - Your square needs rounded corners (fillets) and said rounds need to be manually drawn in facets. - The circle needs to be faceted as well (you can't just draw a circle). - The facets of the "circle" need to be parallel to the line entities in the square as this can cause the surface(s) to twist (if this happens, you can still create the sheetmetal but unable to make a flat pattern).

3. What is the use case for your organization?
HVAC and ducting systems typically involve sheetmetal blends from squares/rectangles to circles.

4. What impact does this problem currently have on your organization?
To produce accurate flat patterns, the user has to resort to a time consuming workaround as it requires you to manually construct the shapes for Brake Formed sheetmetal parts. Also, the workarounds force you to over/under size the geometry (because of the manual facet method on the circle) so you can (hopefully) cut it on the workshop floor afterwards resulting in scrap material.

Aug 8, 2024 11:39 AM UTC

@Chris3 My apologies for putting it in the wrong section.

I have made a new post under the "idea" section as suggested.

Community Manager
Aug 8, 2024 11:45 AM UTC
Status changed to: Acknowledged

Thank you @MM_10223777 for your idea. Based on the information you provided, we are acknowledging it as the Community management team. This is not a commitment from the Product team. Other users may comment and vote your idea up.

Sep 14, 2025 2:58 PM UTC

@Catalina - my customer Coperion are very interested in this feature, but appear to be unable to vote on this idea. @MM_10223777 mentioned that a new post in the correct section was created. This appears to be this new post. Any idea why others still can't vote on it?

Community Manager
Sep 15, 2025 3:25 PM UTC

Hi @AR_11005271,

 

Thanks for the heads up! 

 

Please give me the accounts of the users in a PM and I'll check it out.

 

Best regards,

Catalina