Skip to main content
Sep 2, 2015 5:35 PM UTC
Acknowledged

Sheet metal Bend angle precision

Related products:Creo Parametric

Currently, in Creo 2 drawing mode, when we show a flat pattern of a sheet metal part, we can get the parametric bend angles to display.  But, it seems to be 'hard coded' to 2 decimal places. it would be nice to be able to set / alter that, as we do with dims.

2nd: It also would be nice to be able to move the anchor point for said bend angle note.  Currently, it is attached on the mid-pint of the bend line.  To slide it along the bend line would be a nice touch.

We can alter the number of decimal places, and also the anchor point, but we then loose the parametric relation.

    15 replies

    Mar 13, 2017 7:49 AM UTC

    It is so silly to see sheetmetal angles with two decimal places of precision.

    Makes you wonder if any engineers or fabricators were involved in the application design process.

    As usual - work-around by placing your own parametric note...

    Sep 3, 2020 12:49 PM UTC

    This is probably because in non metric units you want to have more decimal places. Only in metric units it's quite odd. And accidentally PTC is an American company...

    Jan 18, 2022 10:44 AM UTC

    Dear team,

     

    This is very important to have the ability to control the precision of Bend angle note value.

    Jan 18, 2022 11:14 AM UTC

    @kamleshjoshi if you use the imperial system I can imagine it's important. But when you use metric (like the rest of the world) chances are quite low you need decimal places. But to be flexible I also prefer an configuration option to control the number of decimal places.

    Apr 24, 2024 8:44 PM UTC

    We also have a problem with this functionality. So much so that I'm currently looking to see if I can add a custom function to Creo using OTK Java free to deal with it. 

     

    Clearly, in almost all sheet metal processes, it is impossible to hold a sheet metal bend to 0.01 degrees of arc. In most cases, you're lucky to be accurate to 1 degree unless it is a mass production process. 

     

    Our designers therefore spend a huge amount of wasted effort manually editing the notes to remove the trailing zeroes, so that the drawing can match actual production capabilities. Having the function to specify the number of trailing zeroes would likely save our business many man hours in a typical work week and prevent wrong information on the drawing, caused by the 3D model being changed after the note is edited. 

    Aug 14, 2024 1:36 AM UTC

    It's quite embarrassing to have Solid works users pick this up & rubbish Creo for lack of functionality when the reality is quite the opposite.

     

    The non-parametric work around is too much work & will end up in mistakes later when the part is changed.

    Aug 14, 2024 5:51 AM UTC

    Here is my interim solution.

    Modify the unbend note to include the dimension name from the parent bend feature. If the feature was created from a shelled extrusion, remove the horizontal & vertical constraints & add a dimension representing the fold angle instead. That dimension name can also be used in the parametric note in the bend note.

    Here’s the end result using the dimension name which I will use in the meantime. This is less problematic as it will at least show up as a failed parametric note if the parent dimension is deleted.

    SuperBoot_0-1723614655535.png

     

    Oct 2, 2024 9:06 AM UTC

    Hi,

    I would also like a better solution...
    So many decimal places looks really bad.

    JK_10290348_0-1727859863825.png

     

    Oct 2, 2024 9:16 AM UTC

    All users of Creo Parametric do, but only one can solve it and that's PTC. Decimal places is an overall "issue". In europe we hardly use more than 1 decimal, you can change some config.pro settings that improves some of them but still on a lot of places there are still 3 digits. 

    Currently the speed of fixing the easy things is at an average of several years, so don't hold your breath..

    Oct 2, 2024 1:21 PM UTC

    The speed of fixing any 'trivial' enhancement is directly related to the number of new seats of Creo that enhancement will sell. Don't hold your breath on this one.