Skip to main content
Jan 19, 2024 3:33 PM UTC
Acknowledged

Reward for ideas that are actually implemented

Related products:Creo Parametric

Please include detailed documentation such as screenshots, images or video.

1. What product and version are you running?
10.0.2.0


2. What is the problem?
The PTC Ideas community is really great, and many users invest a portion of their time to provide ideas, make videos and follow up to feedback and comments.

When an idea eventually makes it into production , what if PTC had a way of rewarding the author?
It could be a discount on the license renewal, or a time extension of the license, I think there are many ways it could be done in a way that doesn't cost much or at all to PTC, and which provides a token of appreciation to the idea author.

3. Are you using a workaround? If yes, please describe it.


4. What is the use case for your organization? Describe how your idea would work in context or how it would apply to a practical situation.
Over time we proposed some ideas and user feedback, some were implemented as bug fixes while one of these will be introduced in the near future

5. What impact does this problem currently have on your organization? (Number of users affected, hours of lost productivity, etc.)
I think it could bring more ideas to this platform.

3 replies

Jan 19, 2024 3:35 PM UTC
Status changed to: Acknowledged

Hi @idrive101!

Thank you for your idea. Based on the information you provided, we are acknowledging it as the Community management team. This is not a commitment from the Product team. Other users may comment and vote your idea up.

Jan 19, 2024 7:17 PM UTC

I agree, and I can say that I almost stopped making any new suggestions due to a lack of feedback of the proposals already made,. I could have spent a lot of time to provide further clarifications in terms of sending images or videos, but due to almost lack of feedback I think it sould simply be wasting my time.

Feb 19, 2025 12:15 PM UTC

Out of the 5,500+ ideas that have been submitted in the past 12 years, 134 have been delivered by PTC based on the ideas on this forum. These were marked as Delivered by PTC. Here is a summary....

Idea 927959 - Automatically add the date & time for each line in the Message Log (Posted 1 years ago (Feb 05, 2024))

- Automatically add the date & time for each line in the Message Log (Posted 1 years ago (Feb 05, 2024))

Currently in Creo Parametric versions ranging from 7 to 10, there is no built-in feature that automatically adds timestamps for each line in the Message Log. This lack of functionality makes it challenging to identify the time taken for various processes or actions within the software, such as checking in parts, opening large assemblies, etc., which can lead to difficulties in diagnosing issues and determining their causes (e.g., poor connection to Windchill, local computer resources, etc.).

To address this limitation, it is proposed that Creo Parametric incorporates a feature to automatically add timestamps for each line appearing in the Message Log. This enhancement would provide users with insights into how long different processes or actions take and help diagnose problems more effectively. For instance, by having timestamps, users could determine if most of the time spent on opening an assembly is related to adding the assembly to the workspace or opening the workspace itself.

The suggested idea would be extremely beneficial for organizations in improving their productivity by streamlining problem-solving processes and minimizing guesswork when addressing issues with Creo Parametric. The person who proposed this idea has demonstrated valuable insights into identifying and suggesting practical solutions that can significantly improve the overall user experience within the software environment.

Thank you to the individual who suggested this idea, contributing towards enhancing the functionality of Creo Parametric for all users.

 

Idea 916645 - Select Both Surfaces of a Hole in One Click (Posted 1 years ago (Dec 05, 2023))

- Select Both Surfaces of a Hole in One Click (Posted 1 years ago (Dec 05, 2023))

In the present scenario, users encounter an issue where holes and circular extruded features in Creo Parametric produce two half-cylindrical surfaces instead of one continuous cylindrical surface. This leads to a requirement for selecting twice as many surfaces during tasks such as adding surfaces to an annotation reference.

To alleviate this problem, the suggested solution is modifying the selection filter or some other aspect of the select tool within Creo Parametric. This modification would allow users to automatically select both halves of each hole whenever they select a hole surface, making the process more streamlined and efficient.

The expected benefits of this proposed change include reducing the time spent on selecting hole surfaces, improving productivity, and enhancing user experience for less experienced users who may find the current workaround using the search tool challenging.

We would like to extend our gratitude to the community member who suggested this valuable idea, as it addresses a common issue faced by many Creo Parametric users. By implementing this modification, we can create a more efficient and user-friendly environment for all designers working with Creo Parametric.

 

Idea 896462 - Need Block List capability for the Creo Embedded Browser in Creo Parametric (Posted 1 years ago (Aug 27, 2023))

- Need Block List capability for the Creo Embedded Browser in Creo Parametric (Posted 1 years ago (Aug 27, 2023))

Analysis:

  • Current Problem or Limitations: The organization is facing an issue where users are accidentally registering and connecting to incorrect Windchill URLs, which results in cache corruption. This problem is exacerbated by the use of multiple Windchill clusters on a load balancing router with a common base URL.
  • Proposed Solution: Implement a Block List capability for the Creo Parametric embedded browser that allows users to restrict access to certain Windchill URLs, preventing them from corrupting their cache when they register and connect to incorrect URLs.
  • Expected Benefits: If implemented, this solution would significantly improve data integrity by eliminating the possibility of accidental cache corruption due to incorrect Windchill URL registration. Additionally, it would reduce the number of hours lost due to data loss caused by this issue for the 3000 users in the organization.
  • Acknowledgement: Thanks go out to the individual who suggested this idea on the Creo Parametric community forum. This idea is particularly valuable as it addresses a long-standing problem that has resulted in significant data loss over the years.

Idea 892204 - Slow regeneration analyzer (Posted 1 years ago (Aug 05, 2023))

- Slow regeneration analyzer (Posted 1 years ago (Aug 05, 2023))

Current Problem or Limitation: In the current version of Creo Parametric, users have reported experiencing slow regenerations, which can significantly impact productivity. This problem is particularly high for organizations using large and complex assemblies. The slow regeneration process causes delays in design iterations and reduces overall efficiency.

Proposed Solution: The suggested idea is to develop a command that analyzes the regeneration process, identifying the points where it is slowest. By providing suggestions on how to optimize the regeneration process, this tool would enable operators to intervene effectively on the structure of the study, leading to faster subsequent regenerations.

Expected Benefits:

  • Reduced regeneration times for assemblies, improving overall productivity and design efficiency
  • Faster iterations in the design process, allowing for quicker prototyping and development
  • Enhanced user experience by minimizing frustrations caused by slow regeneration processes

Give Thanks: A big thank you to the individual who suggested this idea. The proposed solution has great potential to improve the overall workflow for Creo Parametric users, particularly those dealing with large and complex assemblies on a daily basis. Your contribution to the community is greatly appreciated!

 

Idea 884361 - Shrinkwrap multibody generation (Posted 1 years ago (Jun 30, 2023))

(https://community.ptc.com/t5/Creo-Parametric-Ideas/Shrinkwrap-multibody-generation/idi-p/884361) - Shrinkwrap multibody generation (Posted 1 years ago (Jun 30, 2023))

Current Problem or Limitations: The user is experiencing a lack of functionality in Creo Parametric as the software does not currently have the ability to generate a fully associative multibody part from an assembly file. This can lead to increased time spent on generating a shrinkwrap and obtaining less optimal results.

Proposed Solution: The proposed solution is to include a function that allows for the generation of a fully associative multibody part directly from an assembly file. This would facilitate the creation of the final machined part derived from a welded assembly, streamlining the design process.

Expected Benefits: Implementing this functionality will save considerable time spent by users in generating a shrinkwrap and obtaining improved results. It will help to create more efficient workflows within the organization, leading to increased productivity and reduced turnaround times for projects.

Giving Thanks: Thank you to the user who suggested this idea for bringing attention to this potential enhancement that could greatly benefit Creo Parametric users in our organization.

 

Idea 869961 - Unable to select sketched Datum points for spot weld feature (Posted 1 years ago (Apr 19, 2023))

- Unable to select sketched Datum points for spot weld feature (Posted 1 years ago (Apr 19, 2023))

Current Problem or Limitation: The user is experiencing a limitation in Creo Parametric version 8.0.4.0 where they are unable to select datum points that have been sketched while creating a spot weld feature. This restriction forces the designer to create datum points outside the context of the sketch, which limits their ability to effectively constrain the points and creates additional steps in the design process.

Proposed Solution: The suggested solution is to enable the capability for designers to create and select datum points inside a sketch when creating a spot weld feature. This would allow for more flexibility in designing point patterns, as well as improved efficiency by eliminating the need to create datum points outside the sketch.

Expected Benefits: Implementing this solution would save users time by streamlining the process of creating and selecting datum points. Design engineers would have increased flexibility in creating point patterns at the sketch level, making it easier for them to effectively constrain points and improve overall design efficiency.

Give Thanks: Thank you to the individual who suggested this idea, highlighting their valuable input in improving the Creo Parametric user experience and streamlining the design process for electrical equipment designers.

 

Idea 865501 - Creo to better handle imported ECAD PCB silk screen layers (Posted 1 years ago (Mar 30, 2023))

- Improving Creo's handling of imported ECAD PCB silk screen layers (Posted 1 years ago (Mar 30, 2023))

Current Problem or Limitations: In the current version of Creo Parametric (9.0 and 7.0), when importing IPC-2581 ECAD files, the silkscreen data is imported as quilts, which are positioned below the 3D copper layers and sold mask layers. This placement makes it difficult for users to clearly see and validate the ECAD design, especially in product designs where thickness is crucial.

Proposed Solution: To make the importation of ECAD files more useful and effective, there are two possible solutions. Firstly, the silkscreen layer should be allowed to be imported as quilts. Secondly, at least the silkscreen entities should be enabled to place on top of copper layers and sold mask layers. Converting ECAD Entities as 3D quilt surfaces with multiple layers with thickness will allow users to accurately validate designs.

Expected Benefits: Implementing these suggestions will significantly improve the current design workflow, making it more reliable, faster, and easier for designers. The ability to clearly see and validate ECAD designs in Creo will save time, reduce errors, and increase overall productivity.

Relevant Information: We would like to express our gratitude to the person who suggested this idea on the PTC Community. Improving Creo's handling of imported ECAD PCB silk screen layers is essential for our design automation team, as it enables us to better validate complete designs in our industry (PCB design, computer and electronic device design).

Additional Note: Although not explicitly stated in the original post, a potential advantage of allowing silkscreen entities to be placed on top of copper layers and sold mask layers is that it will also facilitate collaboration between MCAD and ECAD designers. By providing clear visualization of the silkscreen layer for both parties, misunderstandings and errors can be reduced, ultimately leading to improved design quality and shorter development cycles.

 

Idea 857554 - Update the roughness symbol (ISO1302 --> ISO21920 (Posted 1 years ago (Feb 22, 2023))

- Update the roughness symbol (ISO1302 --> ISO21920

This idea, initially posted on February 22, 2023, proposes updating the roughness symbol from ISO1302 to ISO21920 within Creo Parametric software. The current version being used by the SOMFY group is CREO7 and CREO9.0.2.0.

The problem the user is facing is that while ISO 1302 is native in Creo 9, it has been canceled and replaced by ISO 21920. The new symbol of ISO 21920 offers more precision as it can indicate whether the roughness is linear or surface-based. In the current version (CREO7), creating this symbol results in an unwanted point, with limited options available for linear roughness below Ra1.6.

The proposed solution is to update the roughness symbol within Creo Parametric from ISO 1302 to ISO 21920. This update will allow users to create symbols that accurately represent their roughness specifications in both linear and surface formats (a line for linear roughness and a losange for surface roughness).

The expected benefits of this solution are as follows:

  • Improved accuracy and precision in roughness symbol representation
  • Alignment with the latest industry standards (ISO 21920)
  • Streamlined communication between teams, customers, and vendors using Creo Parametric software

Thank you to the person who suggested this idea for bringing attention to this important update. This will undoubtedly benefit all Creo users within the SOMFY group and potentially beyond.

 

Idea 854883 - Creating standard symbols for iso 13715 (Posted 2 years ago (Feb 10, 2023))

- Creating standard symbols for iso 13715 (Posted 2 years ago (Feb 10, 2023))

Current Problem or Limitation: The user has identified a problem in Creo Parametric where the symbol for the state of edges relative to the ISO 13715 standard is not available. This creates an issue because this symbol is essential for their work in the watchmaking industry, and its absence necessitates the creation of personalized symbols that do not meet all scenarios of the ISO standard.

Proposed Solution: The user suggests creating a custom symbol to address the problem. They propose that this symbol should comply with the ISO 13715 standard to ensure consistency across their components, which number in the hundreds.

Expected Benefits: By implementing this suggested solution, the organization would be able to create symbols that meet the requirements of the ISO 13715 standard, thereby improving the accuracy and efficiency of their designs. Additionally, starting organizations using Creo Parametric would not have to spend time learning how to create robust custom symbols to achieve this symbol, reducing their learning curve and increasing productivity.

Relevance: Thank you to the person who suggested this idea previously. Restarting this post in hopes of gaining more support to help our organization and others using Creo Parametric solve this issue.

Note: This analysis has been written in response to your query regarding the detailed breakdown of the provided Creo Parametric idea. The format, problem explanation, proposed solution, expected benefits, and relevance have been addressed accordingly.

 

Idea 845586 - Generative design criteria: Minimum thickness (Posted 2 years ago (Dec 22, 2022))

- Generative design criteria: Minimum thickness (Posted 2 years ago (Dec 22, 2022))

Analysis:

  • The current problem or limitation: In the space industry, components for satellites need to be designed with a minimum thickness to ensure they can be produced through Additive Manufacturing (AM). However, there is no built-in design criteria in Creo Parametric to enforce this. This results in potential overspending on structural components and increased launch costs.
  • The proposed solution: Implement generative design criteria for minimum thickness within Creo Parametric to ensure that the part can be produced through AM. This will provide a more efficient and cost-effective way of designing satellite components.
  • The expected benefits: Mass savings on structural components can reduce launch costs, increase the mass that the satellite payload can have, and ultimately lead to cost savings for the organization as a whole. Furthermore, by automating this process, designers will have more time to focus on other critical aspects of satellite design.

Give thanks to the person who suggested the idea: Thank you to the individual who suggested the idea for generative design criteria in Creo Parametric for minimum thickness. This idea is crucial for our space industry and can lead to significant cost savings and increased efficiency in the design process.

 

Idea 832935 - Generative Design - Remote Forces (Posted 2 years ago (Oct 25, 2022))

- Generative Design - Remote Forces (Posted 2 years ago (Oct 25, 2022))

In the aerospace and defense industry, organizations are constantly seeking advanced capabilities to create more efficient products. One such capability is generative design, which leverages artificial intelligence to optimize designs based on specific criteria. However, current versions of Creo Parametric do not natively support remote forces or moments, which limits the scope of generative design.

The proposed idea aims to address this limitation by adding the functionality to apply remote forces or moments to a model during the generative design process. This would open up new possibilities for optimization and enable the creation of more advanced products that can withstand various external loads effectively.

By incorporating remote forces into generative design, organizations in the aerospace and defense industry could gain several benefits:

  1. Enhanced product performance: Products optimized using remote forces would be better equipped to handle real-world conditions, leading to improved safety and reliability.
  2. Reduced development time: Generative design can significantly speed up the product development process. With the ability to include remote forces, designers could achieve optimal designs even faster, saving valuable time and resources.
  3. Increased innovation: The inclusion of remote forces would expand the possibilities for innovative designs, allowing organizations to develop cutting-edge products that outperform existing solutions.

Many thanks to the individual who suggested this idea. Their contribution has the potential to revolutionize the way we approach generative design in the aerospace and defense industry, leading to more efficient and effective product development.

 

Idea 828000 - [Eztol] Rename action not synchronous in Eztol (Posted 2 years ago (Oct 04, 2022))

- [Eztol] Rename action not synchronous in Eztol (Posted 2 years ago (Oct 04, 2022))

Current Problem or Limitation: In the current setup, when parts or assemblies are renamed on Windchill for adherence to factory rules during the pilot run phase, the changes do not synchronize automatically within Eztol. This requires users to manually update the names in Eztol, which can be time-consuming and potentially lead to inconsistencies between Eztol and the actual part or assembly names on Windchill.

Proposed Solution: To address this issue, it is proposed that the renaming action within Eztol becomes synchronous with the part or assembly names in Windchill. This would mean that whenever a name change is made on Windchill, the same change would automatically reflect in Eztol without requiring manual intervention.

Expected Benefits: The suggested solution would improve efficiency by eliminating the need for manual updates of part and assembly names within Eztol. It would also ensure consistency between Eztol and the actual part or assembly names on Windchill, reducing potential errors and improving overall data integrity. Moreover, this enhancement would make Eztol a more user-friendly tool, as it aligns with the naming conventions used in the factory environment.

Relevance to Query: Thank you to the person who suggested idea 828000 - [Eztol] Rename action not synchronous in Eztol. This suggestion addresses a real-world problem faced by chassis designers using sheetmetal and solid in Creo Parametric EZTol2, specifically related to part and assembly naming inconsistencies during the transition from product development to pilot run phases. By implementing this solution, we can enhance RD efficiency, improve user experience, and potentially facilitate greater adoption of Eztol by customers.

 

Idea 822596 - Fix Modernized Project and Offset Tools in Sketcher (Posted 2 years ago (Sep 09, 2022))

- Fix Modernized Project and Offset Tools in Sketcher (Posted 2 years ago (Sep 09, 2022))

Current Problem or Limitation: The user is experiencing a significant increase in time required to perform operations related to projecting or offsetting a loop in the Sketcher environment of Creo Parametric version 9.0.1.0. The Modernized Project and Offset Tools now require 4 clicks to set up, 1 click per loop plus 1 click to confirm each loop, as compared to only 2 clicks in previous versions (Creo 8 and below). Additionally, each loop is treated as a single entity, making it impossible to delete one or more segments of it using the Delete segment function without deleting the entire loop and re-projecting it as a partial loop.

Proposed Solution: To address this issue, the user suggests reverting to the previous method of projecting or offsetting a loop in Creo Parametric, which was faster and more efficient. An alternative solution could be to implement a feature that allows users to easily delete one or more segments of an existing loop without having to delete the entire loop and re-project it as a partial loop.

Expected Benefits: The proposed solutions aim to make work lighter and faster by reducing the number of clicks required to perform operations related to projecting or offsetting loops in Sketcher, thus saving time and improving productivity. Additionally, allowing users to delete one or more segments of an existing loop without having to delete the entire loop and re-project it as a partial loop will further streamline the design process.

Relevant Information: I would like to thank the person who suggested this idea for highlighting this important issue that affects productivity in our organization. Addressing this concern will help us continue to deliver high-quality designs efficiently, ensuring our clients receive top-notch products on time and within budget.

 

Idea 822019 - Generative Design - Mass on Point (Posted 2 years ago (Sep 07, 2022))

- Generative Design - Mass on Point (Posted 2 years ago (Sep 07, 2022))

Current Problem or Limitation: In the current version of Creo Parametric, there is a capability to add mass on points related to model in Creo Simulate, which represents unmeshed geometry and participates only in simulation as local mass. However, this feature is not available in Generative Design setup. This limitation prevents the accurate representation of unmodeled mass during the generative design process, leading to potential errors in the final design.

Proposed Solution: The proposed solution is to extend the capability of adding mass on points related to model surface in Generative Design setup. This would allow the representation of unmodeled mass during the generative design process, ensuring a more accurate and reliable final design.

Expected Benefits: The implementation of this solution would provide several benefits for the organization. Firstly, it would enhance the capabilities of Generative Design, resulting in advanced and highly technological products. Secondly, it would ensure accuracy by considering unmodeled mass during the design process, reducing potential errors in the final product. Lastly, it would save time and resources by eliminating the need for manual adjustments to account for unmodeled mass.

Relevance: Thank you to the person who suggested this idea. The proposed solution aligns with our organization's goals of using cutting-edge technology to design advanced mechanical products. By implementing this suggestion, we can improve the accuracy and reliability of our designs while enhancing the capabilities of Creo Parametric.

 

Idea 812062 - Imprinting should happen within single Part in ProMechModel (Posted 2 years ago (Aug 08, 2022))

- Imprinting within a Single Part in ProMechModel

The current problem or limitation lies in the functionality of imprinting within ProMechModel. When working with an assembly that contains separate parts, imprinting works correctly. However, when dealing with a single part (.prt), the imprinting feature fails to function as intended. This is problematic as it limits the flexibility and efficiency of the software, particularly for users who work primarily with individual parts.

The proposed solution would be to modify ProMechModel's imprinting feature so that it functions correctly within a single part. This could be achieved by adjusting the algorithm that controls the imprinting process to account for the absence of additional parts in the model.

The expected benefits of this solution are manifold. Firstly, it would eliminate the current inconsistency in the imprinting feature's behavior. Secondly, it would make ProMechModel more versatile and efficient for users who primarily work with individual parts. Lastly, it would ensure a consistent user experience across different types of models, regardless of their complexity.

A big thank you goes out to the person who suggested this idea. Your insight has helped us identify an issue that may have gone unnoticed and provided us with a valuable opportunity to improve our software. We hope to implement this change in future updates of ProMechModel to better serve our users.

 

Idea 810658 - Generative Design - Geometric constrains - Rotation Symmetry (Posted 2 years ago (Aug 01, 2022))

- Generative Design - Geometric constrains - Rotation Symmetry (Posted 2 years ago (Aug 01, 2022))

In the Defense Aerospace industry, I work as a Product Engineer in an organization that focuses on designing and manufacturing defense and aerospace products. The stakeholders for this idea include designers, engineers, and product managers who work on generative design projects within our organization.

The problem being addressed by this idea is the current limitation in Creo Parametric's Generative Design where there is no option to define Rotation Symmetry during optimization. This limitation makes it difficult for us to optimize parts that have symmetry, leading to suboptimal solutions and increased design time.

To solve this problem, the user suggested adding an option to define Rotation Symmetry in Creo Parametric's Generative Design capabilities. This would allow designers to specify the number of rotational axes and the angle of rotation for each axis during optimization, enabling the software to generate optimal designs that take advantage of symmetry.

The expected benefits of this solution include improved product optimization by taking advantage of symmetry, reduced design time due to more efficient solutions, and increased design flexibility. These benefits would result in cost savings, improved product performance, and faster time-to-market for our defense and aerospace products.

I would like to express my gratitude to the user who suggested this idea for highlighting an important limitation in Creo Parametric's Generative Design capabilities and proposing a solution that would be valuable for our organization. By implementing Rotation Symmetry in generative design, we can improve our product optimization processes and stay competitive in the Defense Aerospace industry.

 

Idea 810634 - Generative Design - Remote Forces (Posted 2 years ago (Aug 01, 2022))

- Generative Design - Remote Forces (Posted 2 years ago (Aug 01, 2022))

In the Defense Aerospace industry, I serve as a Product Design Engineer. My organization is consistently seeking ways to optimize and improve our products, aligning with our stakeholders' objectives of delivering high-performance, reliable, and cost-effective solutions. The individual who suggested this idea is contributing significantly to our ongoing efforts to innovate within our design workflow.

The problem we face in our current version 8.0.13 of Creo Parametric pertains to the implementation of Generative Design. Although the existing feature allows for optimal shape generation based on user-defined constraints, it lacks the capability to apply remote forces that act at a distance from the model geometry. This limitation hinders us from exploring complex design scenarios where remote loading conditions are crucial in determining the performance and functionality of our products.

To address this issue, the proposed solution is to extend the Generative Design capabilities within Creo Parametric to include Remote Forces. This feature would enable users to specify forces that act outside the model boundary, allowing for a more accurate representation of real-world loading conditions on complex structures.

The expected benefits of implementing Remote Forces in our design process are numerous. First and foremost, it would lead to improved product performance through better understanding of how external loads affect our designs. This could result in reduced weight, increased stiffness, and enhanced overall structural integrity. Furthermore, the ability to more accurately simulate loading conditions would expedite the prototyping and testing phases, ultimately leading to time and cost savings for our organization.

Lastly, I would like to express my gratitude to the individual who proposed this idea, as it has the potential to significantly enhance our design capabilities in the Defense Aerospace industry. By addressing this limitation within Creo Parametric, we can continue to push the boundaries of innovation and deliver superior products to our stakeholders.

 

Idea 810633 - Generative Design - Mass on Point (Posted 2 years ago (Aug 01, 2022))

 - Generative Design - Mass on Point (Posted 2 years ago (Aug 01, 2022))

In the Defense Aerospace industry, I work as a Product Design Engineer in a leading organization. My role involves optimizing existing products and designing new ones to meet the stringent requirements of this demanding sector. My stakeholders include product managers, engineers, and end-users who require efficient, reliable, and high-performing solutions.

The suggested idea aims to expand the capabilities of Creo Parametric's Generative Design feature by allowing users to define a mass on a point as an input for optimization. The current limitation is that generative design can only optimize based on predefined geometric constraints, which may not always align with real-world design requirements, such as needing to maintain a specific mass at a particular location.

The proposed solution would enable users to specify a desired mass at a specified point within the model during the optimization process. This enhancement would lead to more accurate and effective product optimization by taking into account both geometric and mass properties.

For our organization, this suggestion represents significant business value in terms of product improvement. By leveraging generative design with the ability to define a mass on a point, we can optimize our products more efficiently, leading to lighter, stronger, and more cost-effective designs that meet the stringent requirements of the Defense Aerospace industry.

Thank you to the community member who suggested this idea. Their contribution helps us stay at the forefront of design technology and improve the efficiency of our product development process.

 

Idea 806113 - Enhanced solid shrinkwrap or copy geom- only outer geometry with optional capped holes (Posted 2 years ago (Jul 08, 2022))

- Enhance Solid Shrinkwrap or Copy Geometry: Only Outer Geometry with Optional Capped Holes (Posted 2 years ago (Jul 08, 2022))

The idea proposed by a user in the Creo Parametric community addresses a significant challenge faced by OEM car manufacturers and other organizations dealing with large assemblies. The current problem lies in the manual data collection and repair associated with using shrinkwrap functionality for huge assemblies. Inner contours/geometry must be excluded from the surface copy to prevent unnecessary information sharing, particularly when collaborating with internal departments and external suppliers. Additionally, manually filling holes in assemblies with hundreds of parts is extremely time-consuming and challenging.

The proposed solution is to enhance the solid shrinkwrap or copy geom functionality to include only the outer shell geometry while excluding inner components. This enhancement will allow quick selection of bounding surfaces, resulting in a fully closed shrinkwrap that retains the quality of original data. Additionally, an optional auto-hole filling feature will be added to make the process more efficient.

The expected benefits of this solution include:

  • Reducing manual data collection effort and time, making geometry creation faster and easier.
  • Lowering manual data repair time by automating hole filling.
  • Providing know-how protection by hiding inner geometry and holes.
  • Minimizing loss of data by producing a single outer component instead of manually collecting all geometries.
  • Reducing data size due to the simpler resulting geometry compared to current methods.

A big thank you goes out to the individual who suggested this idea, as it has the potential to significantly streamline and improve workflows for large assembly projects in various industries.

 

Idea 792265 - If only 1 body exists, the advanced reference configuration should just automatically pick that body (Posted 2 years ago (Apr 27, 2022))

 - If only 1 body exists, the advanced reference configuration should just automatically pick that body (Posted 2 years ago (Apr 27, 2022))

Current Problem or Limitation: The user has pointed out a problem with the functionality of the "Paste Special" and the "Advanced Reference Configuration" in Creo Parametric version 73. In this current setup, when there is only one body in a part, the user must manually select the body for the features to apply to. However, most parts are built with just one body, making it unnecessary and inconvenient to select a specific body.

Proposed Solution: The suggested solution aims to make the process more efficient by allowing Creo Parametric to automatically pick the only body present in the part when using the "Advanced Reference Configuration" if there is only one body in the part. The user will still have the option to create a new body manually, should they require it. This functionality was available in older versions of Creo Parametric but seems to have been removed or changed with the release of version 7.

Expected Benefits: The implementation of this solution would save time for users by reducing the number of clicks required when working on parts that consist of only one body. This could lead to increased productivity and streamlined design processes within the organization, as well as a more user-friendly experience overall.

Giving Thanks: A big thank you goes out to the individual who suggested this idea in the Creo Parametric community. Their contribution helps to make the software more efficient and user-friendly for all CAD users in the aerospace industry and beyond.

 

Idea 792218 - Notes and symbols attached to 3D annotations (Posted 2 years ago (Apr 27, 2022))

- Notes and symbols attached to 3D annotations (Posted 2 years ago (Apr 27, 2022))

In the given idea, Fabrice, a user in the Swiss watch manufacturing industry, highlighted the issue of managing notes and symbols associated with 3D Model-Based Definition (MBD) annotations within Creo Parametric version 7.0.7.03. The current problem lies in the manual adjustment of elements following any movement of annotated components due to the fact that the attached notes or symbols are not autonomous.

To address this limitation, Fabrice proposed a solution where notes and symbols would be linked directly to 3D MBD annotations, such as dimensions and other types of notes. This modification aims to make the design process more efficient by reducing the need for manual repositioning of associated elements when moving an annotation with attached notes or symbols.

The expected benefits of this proposed solution would be considerable time savings in the quality assurance phase of Swiss watch manufacturing, where precision and organization are crucial. This enhancement will lead to a smoother workflow, increased productivity, and ultimately better-quality products.

Thank you, Fabrice, for your valuable insight and for suggesting an idea that could significantly improve the efficiency of design processes within Creo Parametric. Your contribution is highly appreciated by the wider community, and it's always inspiring to see users like yourself driving innovation and fostering collaboration.

 

Idea 791260 - Display model units on drawing (Posted 2 years ago (Apr 21, 2022))

- Display model units on drawing (Posted 2 years ago (Apr 21, 2022))

The current problem or limitation described in this idea is the lack of a good method to display the model units (such as length, mass, etc.) on a drawing or in a drawing Repeat Region (BOM table) within Creo Parametric. This can lead to confusion and errors when working with models that use different units, as it may not be immediately clear what unit of measurement is being used for various parts or dimensions.

The proposed solution suggests adding the ability to easily display the model units on a drawing or in a BOM table within Creo Parametric. This would enable users to quickly and accurately understand the units being used for different components, reducing errors and improving communication between team members.

The expected benefits of implementing this solution include increased accuracy, reduced confusion, improved communication, and time savings due to the elimination of manual calculations or unit conversions. Additionally, this feature could help ensure compliance with industry standards and regulations that require clear and consistent use of units on drawings.

I would like to give a big thank you to the person who suggested this idea! This is an issue that I have run into many times myself, and having a built-in solution for displaying model units on drawings would be extremely helpful in my day-to-day work with Creo Parametric.

 

Idea 787358 - Pattern Count Parameter (Posted 2 years ago (Mar 31, 2022))

- Pattern Count Parameter (Posted 2 years ago (Mar 31, 2022))

Current Problem or Limitation: The user faces a challenge in accessing the actual count of patterns, particularly hole patterns, within a design. This is especially problematic when some of the patterns are suppressed and the accurate count cannot be easily determined. The current solution, which involves finding the pattern count in a hole note for standard holes, is not applicable for all patterns and requires the hole note to be set to show the pattern count.

Proposed Solution: The proposed solution aims to provide users with direct access to the actual count of a pattern within their designs. This functionality would be applicable to all types of patterns, not just holes. For example, if a user has patterned a hole but suppressed some instances, they should be able to quickly and easily find out the total count of those holes.

Expected Benefits: The implementation of this solution would streamline the design process by reducing the time spent on manually counting patterns, especially when dealing with multiple instances. This efficiency gain can lead to increased productivity and improved accuracy in designs. Furthermore, the ability to access pattern counts for all types of patterns would make the software more versatile and user-friendly.

Give Thanks: A big thank you to the user who suggested this idea. The ability to quickly and easily access the count of patterns within a design is an essential tool for any CAD user, and your insight has helped us better understand the need for this functionality in Creo Parametric. We appreciate your contributions to our community!

 

Idea 783681 - Creo Sketcher palette import section scale 1:1 setting (Posted 2 years ago (Mar 11, 2022))

- Creo Sketcher palette import section size 1:1 setting (Posted 2 years ago (Mar 11, 2022))

Current Problem or Limitation: When importing sections from the palette in Creo Parametric, the software scales the sections based on their bounding box, which can sometimes lead to errors and misunderstandings, especially when dealing with sections related to specific holes for bolts or other components. This can result in incorrect sizes that need to be manually adjusted, potentially causing delays and increasing the risk of errors.

Proposed Solution: The suggested solution is to add settings within Creo Parametric that allow users to set the default scale for imported sections at 1:1. With this setting, users could import sections directly without worrying about their size adjustments, ensuring correct visualization of related components like holes for bolts from the get-go.

Expected Benefits: By implementing this feature, users can save time and reduce errors by avoiding manual adjustments for sections related to specific components. This will lead to more efficient workflows and improved accuracy in designs, ultimately resulting in a higher quality of work.

Thanks to the person who suggested the idea: A big thanks goes out to the user who proposed this idea! Your insight into improving the Creo Parametric experience for everyone is much appreciated, and your efforts help make the software more efficient and user-friendly for all of us. Keep sharing your great ideas!

 

Idea 782264 - Add TOOLKIT C API ProUILayoutBackgroundcolorSet() (Posted 2 years ago (Mar 03, 2022))

- Add TOOLKIT C API ProUILayoutBackgroundcolorSet() (Posted 2 years ago (Mar 03, 2022))

Current Problem or Limitation: In the current implementation of Creo Parametric's TOOLKIT GUI, there is no simple way to programmatically display a color choice other than by using an InputPanel widget which is not ideal for this purpose. The InputPanel widget is designed for entering data and is not suitable for displaying colors that need to be set programmatically. Additionally, the location of the message window at the bottom of the GUI in CreoParametric can make it easy for users to miss important messages.

Proposed Solution: The proposed solution is to add a ProUILayoutBackgroundcolorSet() API to the TOOLKIT C API. This API would allow for the display of a rectangular area that defines a color choice and enable the full implementation of a MessagePanel composite widget similar to those used in Perl/Tk and Java applications. The MessagePanel consists of a Layout that contains a PushButton on the left, an InputPanel, and other optional widgets like a PushButton for closing the application. This would allow users to easily see messages and improve the usability of the application.

Expected Benefits: The addition of ProUILayoutBackgroundcolorSet() API would provide a more flexible and user-friendly way to display colors programmatically in Creo Parametric's TOOLKIT GUI. It would also allow for the implementation of MessagePanels that can be placed at the top of the GUI, making it easier for users to see important messages. Overall, this improvement would enhance the usability and functionality of the application.

Thank you to the person who suggested this idea! Your contribution is valuable and will help make Creo Parametric a better tool for our users.

 

Idea 781605 - Simple hole notes (Posted 2 years ago (Mar 01, 2022))

- Simple hole notes (Posted 2 years ago (Mar 01, 2022))

Current Problem or Limitation: The current limitation in Creo Parametric is that when creating a simple hole, there are no associated notes with the hole that appear when the Show Model Annotations button is clicked in a drawing. This can cause issues when creating detail drawings for parts that have simple holes because important dimensions such as diameter and depth or thru options are not easily accessible.

Proposed Solution: The proposed solution is to create parametric notes associated with simple holes, allowing the diameter parameter and depth or thru option to be included in the note. This would make it easier for engineers designing resistance welders, such as the author of this idea, to quickly access important information about the hole when creating detail drawings.

Expected Benefits: The expected benefits of implementing this solution are time-saving when creating drawings and increased efficiency in the design process. By having easy access to important dimensions for simple holes, engineers can create accurate and detailed drawings more quickly, which can improve productivity and overall project timelines.

Relevant Remark: Thank you to the person who suggested this idea! Your feedback is valuable and helps us improve Creo Parametric to better meet the needs of our users. Keep sharing your ideas and helping us make Creo a powerful tool for engineers like yourself.

 

Idea 776807 - Repeat Mode for surface finish symbols (Posted 3 years ago (Feb 07, 2022))

- Repeat Mode for surface finish symbols (Posted 3 years ago (Feb 07, 2022))

Current Problem or Limitation: In the current version of Creo Parametric, when adding a new surface finish symbol in Manufacturing Bill of Materials (MBD), users have to manually select the symbol in the browser and define the roughness height for each symbol. This process becomes time-consuming when dealing with repetitive symbols.

Proposed Solution: The suggested solution is to implement a Repeat Mode command similar to the one already available for placing multiple symbols, but specifically for surface finish symbols. This would allow users to quickly place multiple surface finish symbols using the last placed symbol's settings as a default.

Expected Benefits: Implementing this feature would save time by eliminating the need to browse for symbols and define roughness heights for repetitive surface finish symbols, making the process more efficient.

Relevance to the Query: Many thanks are due to the person who suggested this idea as it aims to improve productivity in Creo Parametric by streamlining the process of adding surface finish symbols, especially when dealing with large models containing numerous similar surfaces.

 

Idea 774592 - supporting #of instances for simple hole using type "sketched" (Posted 3 years ago (Jan 25, 2022))

- supporting # of instances for simple hole using type "sketched" (Posted 3 years ago (Jan 25, 2022))

The user's idea proposes a solution to a limitation in Creo Parametric version 8.0.3.0 when creating a Hole feature using the TypeStandard "sketched." Currently, when using this type of hole, the number of holes cannot be shown automatically in the drawing environment. However, when using a Type Standard hole, this feature is available. This discrepancy is problematic for general mechanical design as it leads to inconsistencies and potential user errors.

The proposed solution is to extend the functionality of showing the number of instances for simple holes to match that of TypeStandard holes. This can be achieved by modifying the code responsible for displaying annotation notes in the drawing environment.

Implementing this suggestion would bring system consistency, ease of use, and minimize user errors. In a mechanical design context, these benefits are crucial for maintaining accuracy, efficiency, and reliability in designs.

Thank you to the person who suggested this idea and brought attention to this issue within Creo Parametric. Your input is valuable in improving the software and making it more efficient for users like us.

By addressing this limitation, we can expect a more streamlined design process that reduces errors, making it easier for mechanical designers to create accurate models.

 

Idea 772855 - [Cabling] move the RT IN BUNDLES option to the ROUTE DIALOG (instead of the setup menu) (Posted 3 years ago (Jan 14, 2022))

Idea Analysis:

- [Cabling] move the RT IN BUNDLES option to the ROUTE DIALOG (instead of the setup menu) (Posted 3 years ago (Jan 14, 2022))

Current Problem or Limitation: The current issue lies in the user interface design of Creo Parametric's cabling feature. When launching a new session and routing cables, they often get routed outside existing bundles. This requires users to cancel their operations, navigate to the SETUP menu, and enable the 'RT IN BUNDLES' option every time they start a session. This process is cumbersome and inefficient, leading to wasted time.

Proposed Solution: The proposed solution is to move the RT IN BUNDLES option from the SETUP menu to the ROUTE CABLES dialog. By doing so, users can easily access this feature while routing cables without having to switch to another section of the software, thus streamlining their workflow and improving efficiency.

Expected Benefits: The suggested change would significantly reduce wasted time for users working with cabling in Creo Parametric by eliminating the need to frequently navigate between menus. This improvement could potentially boost productivity and make the software more user-friendly.

Relevance: A big thanks goes out to the user who suggested this idea, as it addresses a real-world problem faced by many users in the marine industry and others who work with cabling in Creo Parametric. The proposed change could bring about a more efficient and enjoyable user experience for these individuals.

It is essential that PTC consider implementing this solution in future updates of Creo Parametric, as it aligns well with their goal of providing intuitive and time-saving features to its users.

 

Idea 765728 - Overhaul to support GPS in MBD to most recent ISO (Posted 3 years ago (Dec 27, 2021))

- Overhaul to support GPS in MBD to most recent ISO (Posted 3 years ago (Dec 27, 2021))

The idea proposed by the Mechanical Engineering community aims to enhance the Creo Parametric software to be more compatible with the latest Geometrical Product Specifications (GPS) standards. The current version of Creo Parametric requires significant modifications to meet the most recent ISO GPS standards, particularly in areas such as general tolerances (ISO 22081) and surface roughness (ISO 1302).

The proposed solution is a general overhaul of the system, making it configurable according to the used MBD or Drawing standard. This change would update the software to use the latest versions of ISO standards, ensuring compliance and reducing the need for manual adjustments.

The expected benefits of this suggestion are twofold: first, standard compliance ensures that the organization's designs meet industry standards, enhancing the quality of its products. Second, time to market could be reduced as less time would be spent on manual adjustments to meet ISO GPS standards.

I would like to express my gratitude to the individual who suggested this idea. Their contribution could significantly improve our workflow and product quality, contributing to our success in implementing MBD for Manufacturing by Extraordinary means (MBE).

 

Idea 751690 - Model tree - Filters should include TERMINATOR in the CABLING tab (Posted 3 years ago (Oct 05, 2021))

- Model tree - Filters should include TERMINATOR in the CABLING tab (Posted 3 years ago (Oct 05, 2021))

Current Problem or Limitation: The current model tree filtering options for the cabling tab in Creo Parametric do not include the option to filter by terminators. This means users have to manually navigate through a large number of cables to find the ones with terminators, which can be time-consuming and inefficient.

Proposed Solution: The proposed solution is to add a filter option for terminators within the cabling tab of the model tree. This would allow users to quickly find all cable components that have terminators attached to them without having to manually search through multiple cables.

Expected Benefits: The addition of a filter for terminators in the cabling tab of the model tree would provide several benefits, including increased efficiency, improved organization, and reduced user frustration. By being able to quickly find all cable components with terminators attached, users can work more efficiently and complete their tasks faster. Additionally, having a dedicated filter for terminators would improve the organization of the model tree, making it easier to navigate and find specific components. Lastly, by reducing the need to manually search through multiple cables, user frustration will be reduced, leading to a better overall experience with Creo Parametric.

Giving Thanks: A big thank you goes out to the person who suggested this idea on the PTC community forum! This is a common pain point for many users of Creo Parametric and a solution like this would greatly improve the user experience. We appreciate your contributions to the community and hope to see more ideas like this in the future!

 

Idea 749281 - Rotation of 3D model in creo parametric (Posted 3 years ago (Sep 21, 2021))

- Rotation of 3D model in creo parametric (Posted 3 years ago (Sep 21, 2021))

Current Problem or Limitation: The user has pointed out a situation where rotating a 3D model in Creo Parametric can be challenging when using a mouse with a central click is unavailable or defective. This issue can lead to reduced productivity and efficiency during customer visits, as well as potentially affecting the quality of work in certain circumstances.

Proposed Solution: The proposed solution is to introduce shortcut keys for rotating 3D models within Creo Parametric. Specifically, the user suggests using a combination of the shift key with arrow keys (up/down/left/right) for rotation purposes. This would allow users to rotate models without relying on the central mouse click, making it more accessible in various working conditions.

Expected Benefits: Implementing this solution can help overcome the challenges of using a defective or non-available central mouse click during customer visits and other critical situations. By providing an alternative method for rotation, users will be able to work more efficiently, maintain productivity, and deliver quality work despite any hardware limitations.

Giving Thanks: Thank you to the user who suggested this idea! Your insights have helped identify a potential issue and propose a practical solution that can improve the usability of Creo Parametric for all users.

 

Idea 748625 - Creo-MBD — enhance/improve PMI functionality (Posted 3 years ago (Sep 16, 2021))

 - Enhance Creo-MBD PMI functionality (Posted 3 years ago (Sep 16, 2021))

Current Problem or Limitation: The current version of Creo Parametric lacks the ability to attach symbol instances to PMI/dimensions via offset placement in solid mode. This results in a manual process that can be time-consuming and error-prone, particularly when large models with numerous dimensions are involved. Additionally, if a dimension is moved, the associated symbols do not move with it, potentially leading to mismatched or incorrect information.

Proposed Solution: The proposed solution aims to enhance the PMI functionality in Creo Parametric by allowing users to attach symbol instances to PMI/dimensions via offset placement in solid mode. This would enable the automatic movement of attached symbols when their associated dimensions are moved, ensuring that the relative position between the two remains consistent. Furthermore, the existing Toolkit functions for creating symbol instances should be extended to include the option of creating them with offset attachment, with the placement plane for the new symbol instance being the same as for the annotation to which it is attached.

Expected Benefits: By implementing this solution, users can expect increased efficiency and reduced errors when labeling PMIs/dimensions and enriching their data sets for MBD post-processing. The automatic movement of symbols with associated dimensions will ensure that information remains accurate and consistent throughout the design process. Additionally, the user-based attributes for PMI will provide more flexibility in managing and organizing data, while maintaining these attributes when exporting to neutral data file formats such as JT and STEP.

Give thanks to the person who suggested the idea: A big thank you goes out to the community member who proposed this insightful idea. Your suggestion not only addresses a common pain point in our workflows, but also contributes to improved accuracy and efficiency in our design processes. Keep the great ideas coming!

 

Idea 737027 - Creo 7 'Regression' - Change Material of a body when there is a collapsed Merged feature (Posted 3 years ago (Jul 06, 2021))

- Creo 7 'Regression' - Change Material of a body when there is a collapsed Merged feature (Posted 3 years ago (Jul 06, 2021))

Current Problem or Limitation: In the latest version of Creo Parametric, users have noticed that they can no longer change the material of a body that has been merged and collapsed. This is a limitation compared to previous versions where this operation was straightforward. This issue becomes particularly problematic when dealing with imported or purchased parts, as these often need their materials changed for various reasons.

Proposed Solution: The proposed solution addresses the inability to change a material after performing a collapse on a merged feature. The ideal scenario would be to restore the functionality that allowed users to easily modify the material of a part without needing to completely rebuild the model, especially when aiming for accurate mass properties.

Expected Benefits: Restoring this functionality would save users valuable time and effort by eliminating the need to reconstruct the entire model when changing materials. This improvement would enhance productivity and allow users to manage their models more efficiently, particularly when dealing with imported or purchased parts.

Giving Thanks: Special thanks are due to martin neumueller for bringing this issue to light and suggesting a solution that would help streamline the workflow of many Creo Parametric users.

 

Idea 727752 - Cabling Point Visibility (Posted 3 years ago (May 05, 2021))

- Cabling Point Visibility (Posted 3 years ago (May 05, 2021))

This idea aims to enhance the visibility of cabling location points within Creo Parametric. The current issue is that these location points can be hard to see, making it challenging for users to easily identify and work with them in their designs. This problem is evident from the provided image "Location Points.png."

To address this limitation, the idea proposes extending the location point visibility function to make the default points more visible by default across all location points. Additionally, editing vs the default points could be highlighted in a distinct manner for clearer differentiation. This proposed solution is based on an improvement made with Creo 7, where the look of location points was updated and found to be more effective (as shown in "Creo 7 Location Points.png").

The expected benefits of this idea would include increased efficiency and accuracy when working with cabling location points. With improved visibility, users could more easily identify these points, reducing errors and saving time during the design process.

Many thanks to the person who suggested this idea for bringing attention to this useful enhancement request.

 

Idea 727309 - Projecting Curves or Edges in Sketcher (Posted 3 years ago (Apr 30, 2021))

- Projecting Curves or Edges in Sketcher (Posted 3 years ago (Apr 30, 2021))

Current Problem or Limitation: The user finds it time-consuming and confusing when selecting curves or edges of type loop from a surface to project onto the sketching plane. This is especially true for complex surfaces with many features as each chain must be stepped through individually and accepted.

Proposed Solution: To address this issue, the idea suggests adding a new menu item in the Type menu called "All". This option will pre-select and highlight all the curves and edges on the surface. The user would then have the ability to easily select or de-select from the highlighted features, making it less time-consuming and more efficient when dealing with complex surfaces.

Expected Benefits: The proposed solution will reduce confusion and improve efficiency by allowing users to handle complex surfaces more effectively within the Sketcher environment in Creo Parametric. This can lead to improved productivity and better management of complex geometries during the design process.

Give thanks to the person who suggested the idea: Thank you to the contributor for suggesting this idea! Your insight into improving the user experience when dealing with complex surfaces in Sketcher is much appreciated by the Creo Parametric community. We hope that our development team takes this into consideration as they continue to enhance the functionality of the software.

 

Idea 715440 - Feature_Name and Ref_Des config.pro sync (Posted 3 years ago (Feb 25, 2021))

- Feature_Name and Ref_Des config.pro sync (Posted 3 years ago (Feb 25, 2021))

Current Problem or Limitation: The user is facing an issue where the designation of cabling features in Creo Parametric does not automatically update the associated Feature_Name in Windchill/MPMLink's wtParts reference designation. This requires manual maintenance to ensure consistency, which can be time-consuming and prone to errors.

Proposed Solution: The suggested solution is to introduce a config.pro setting that would automatically update the Feature_Name in Creo Parametric based on the Ref_DES (cabling designation). This would eliminate the need for manual maintenance, ensuring consistency and reducing potential errors.

Expected Benefits:

  1. Reduced manual effort in maintaining consistency between cabling designations and Feature_Names.
  2. Minimized chances of errors due to manual intervention.
  3. Increased efficiency in the overall product development process.
  4. Improved data integrity and consistency across Creo Parametric and Windchill/MPMLink systems.

Giving Thanks: A big thank you to the user who suggested this idea. The proposed solution addresses a common pain point in the product development process, making it more efficient and error-free. This idea not only saves time but also ensures data integrity, which is crucial in any engineering workflow.

 

Idea 714720 - Enable use of editing functions without first selecting geometry (Posted 3 years ago (Feb 22, 2021))

Idea Analysis:

- Enable use of editing functions without first selecting geometry (Posted 3 years ago (Feb 22, 2021))

The current problem or limitation lies in the Part Mode of Creo Parametric where most editing functions under the Model tab - Editing group are not accessible until relevant geometry has been selected. This can be time-consuming and inefficient, especially when complex operations require multiple selections and modifications.

The proposed solution is to modify the behavior of these editing functions so that selecting them automatically modifies the selection filter to correspond with acceptable geometry. For instance, instead of first selecting a quilt's edge before using the extend function, users could directly use the function and then apply rule-based selections within it, thereby saving the initial selection step.

The expected benefits of this change include increased productivity due to reduced time spent on initial selections, smoother workflow for complex operations that require multiple selections, and a more intuitive user experience overall.

Many thanks to the person who suggested this idea for bringing this valuable enhancement to our attention. This could significantly improve the efficiency of Creo Parametric for users dealing with intricate parts or assemblies.

 

Idea 714176 - Add PMI table support to Creo Parametric (Posted 4 years ago (Feb 19, 2021))

- Add PMI table support to Creo Parametric (Posted 4 years ago (Feb 19, 2021))

Current Problem or Limitation: In the current version of Creo Parametric, designers can only create tables in drawings and not directly within the 3D design environment. This limitation prevents model-based definition and design, as PMI tables are essential for clear communication of design intent and dimensions.

Proposed Solution: The proposed solution is to integrate a PMI table feature directly into the 3D design environment within Creo Parametric. This feature would allow designers to create, edit, and manage tables containing relevant PMI annotations during the design process.

Expected Benefits:

  1. Improved communication of design intent through clear presentation of dimensions and annotations directly on the 3D model
  2. Faster and more efficient design iterations, as changes to dimensions or annotations can be made within the 3D model rather than having to update separate drawings
  3. Enhanced collaboration among team members, as all relevant PMI information will be readily accessible in the same environment
  4. Increased productivity by reducing the time spent on manual creation and updating of tables in multiple locations (i.e., both the model and drawing)

Thank you to the user who suggested this idea for recognizing the need for improved communication and collaboration during the design process, and proposing a solution that addresses these concerns directly within Creo Parametric.

 

Idea 708183 - Creo multibody (Posted 4 years ago (Jan 18, 2021))

- Creo multibody (Posted 4 years ago (Jan 18, 2021))

Current Problem or Limitation: The user has expressed a need for the ability to create multiple sheetmetal bodies within the same part in Creo Parametric. Currently, users can only create one sheetmetal body per part. This limitation forces users to create multiple parts if they need to work with more than one sheetmetal body, which increases model complexity and makes it harder to manage the entire assembly.

Proposed Solution: The proposed solution is to enable users to create multiple sheetmetal bodies within the same Creo Parametric part. This would allow for better organization and simplify the management of complex models with multiple sheetmetal components.

Expected Benefits:

  1. Improved model organization: With the ability to create multiple sheetmetal bodies in a single part, users can keep their models more organized, making it easier to navigate and work with large assemblies.
  2. Reduced model complexity: By reducing the number of individual parts required for a given design, overall model complexity is reduced, which can lead to faster modeling times and improved performance.
  3. Enhanced collaboration: With better organization and reduced complexity, it becomes easier for team members to collaborate on projects, as they can more easily understand and work with the model.
  4. Time savings: By simplifying the creation and management of sheetmetal bodies within a single part, users will save time in their modeling tasks.

Thank you to the user who suggested this idea! Your input is valuable in helping us improve Creo Parametric for all users. Keep sharing your ideas and feedback with our community so that we can continue to make Creo even better for everyone!

 

Idea 696098 - Provide Toolkit API for accessing Cable Curves (Posted 4 years ago (Oct 30, 2020))

- Provide Toolkit API for accessing Cable Curves (Posted 4 years ago (Oct 30, 2020))

The current problem or limitation lies in the lack of a direct Toolkit API for accessing the Curves associated with a Cable. This makes it difficult to perform geometric operations on Cables, such as determining the arc length location of Clamp Models along a Cable. The workaround, which involves examining ProCurves in Cable Segment Features and comparing them against obtained Points and Tangents, is convoluted and can sometimes require rearranging the ProCurves since they are not always in the correct order.

The proposed solution is to create a new API that allows users to obtain a properly-ordered list of ProCurve objects for a given ProCablesegmentInfo. This would be accomplished through an function like extern ProError ProCablesegmentInfoCurvesGet(ProCablesegmentInfo segment, ProCurve p_curves).

The expected benefits of this solution include:

  1. Simplified access to Cable Curves, making it easier for users to perform geometric operations on Cables.
  2. Reduced need for workarounds and convoluted processes, resulting in more efficient modeling.
  3. Improved consistency and accuracy in the arrangement of ProCurves associated with a Cable Segment.
  4. Enhanced user experience by making Creo Parametric more intuitive and easier to use.

Thank you to the individual who suggested this idea for bringing attention to this important issue and contributing to the enhancement of Creo Parametric.

 

Idea 673886 - Add rtos() function to Pro/Program (Posted 4 years ago (Jun 25, 2020))

Add rtos() function to Pro/Program (Posted 4 years ago (Jun 25, 2020))

Current Problem or Limitation: The user interface for creating parametric models in Pro/Program is efficient but lacks a built-in function to convert real numbers into string format with customizable formatting options such as number of decimal places and the separator used between integer and decimal parts (comma or dot). This results in users having to create workarounds that involve generating additional temporary parameters, which can clutter the main parameter user interface.

Proposed Solution: The proposed solution is to add an rtos() function to Pro/Program, similar to the existing itos() function. The rtos(real, decimals, comma) would convert a real number into a string format with specified decimal places and use a comma as a separator between integer and decimal parts if the boolean parameter 'comma' is set to true. For example, rtos(45.778, 2, true) would produce the string "45,78". If the comma parameter is not specified or set to false, the function would use a dot as a separator instead. Additional flexibility could be provided by including a generic formatting function with options for left or right sided formatting, minimum output length, and padding with spaces or zeros.

Expected Benefits: By adding the rtos() function to Pro/Program, users would have an efficient method for generating part reference strings automatically using real parameters they specify. This would streamline the process of creating parametric models, reduce clutter in the main parameter user interface, and ultimately improve productivity. Furthermore, the inclusion of a generic formatting function could provide additional flexibility for users to customize their string output based on specific needs.

Thank you to the individual who suggested this idea! Your contribution to improving Pro/Program's functionality is greatly appreciated by the Creo community.

 

Idea 664526 - Provide option to import STEP file as multi-body part instead of assembly (Posted 4 years ago (May 06, 2020))

- Providing the option to import STEP files as multi-body parts instead of assemblies

The current problem or limitation lies in the process of importing models from vendors, which often arrive as assemblies with numerous components that do not conform to our naming conventions and are not essential for integrating their product with ours. Managing these excess parts individually can be time-consuming, especially when shrinkwrapping them into a single part with less detail. This process may also affect performance, as more complex models require more resources to load. Additionally, it can lead to the cluttering of our PDM system with numerous individual part files for subcomponents.

The proposed solution is to enable users to import STEP files directly as multi-body parts rather than assemblies. This would allow us to maintain all original details while avoiding the need to manage multiple part files for the subcomponents.

Expected benefits include improved efficiency in managing models, reduced clutter in our PDM system, and potential performance enhancements due to loading fewer components at once. Furthermore, this change would promote better organization and standardization by adhering to our established naming conventions.

A big thank you goes out to the person who suggested this idea for recognizing a common challenge faced in CAD modeling and offering a practical solution that addresses it.

 

Idea 661742 - Hatch Pattern preview (Posted 4 years ago (Apr 22, 2020))

- Hatch Pattern preview (Posted 4 years ago (Apr 22, 2020))

The current problem or limitation in Creo Parametric lies within the Hatch Pattern tab. Users can only see the actual section preview after adding the hatch pattern into a component. If the user is not satisfied with the result, they need to remove it and reapply a different pattern, which consumes time and leads to repetitive work.

The proposed solution aims to address this issue by adding an actual section preview for different materials/standards within the Hatch Pattern tab itself. This will enable users to see and select the desired section pattern in one shot without going through the process of applying it, removing it, and reapplying other options repeatedly.

The expected benefits include saving time, reducing repetitive work, and providing a more seamless user experience when working with hatch patterns in Creo Parametric. By implementing this suggestion, users will be able to make informed decisions quickly and efficiently, ultimately improving productivity and design accuracy.

Thank you to the person who suggested this idea for enhancing the Creo Parametric user interface and workflow. Your contribution is greatly appreciated!

 

Idea 656935 - Number of instances in a point pattern (Posted 4 years ago (Mar 27, 2020))

- Number of instances in a point pattern (Posted 4 years ago (Mar 27, 2020))

In the current setup within Creo Parametric, it is already possible for the software to identify the number of instances in a point pattern, whether driven by datum points or a sketch with datum points. This information can be found under Feature Information, where it mentions that the sketch or datum point set is the leader of an (N x 1) pattern. However, the issue lies in the fact that this number, N, is not currently stored as a parameter and thus cannot be easily called out on drawings. This presents a challenge for efficient management and utilization of data within Creo Parametric.

The proposed solution to this problem is to incorporate a feature where this number, representing the count of instances in a point pattern, can be stored as a parameter. By doing so, users will have the ability to call out this information on drawings, which would streamline the process and make it more efficient. Additionally, this feature would enhance the consistency of data across different files, thereby improving overall organization and accessibility.

The expected benefits of implementing this solution include increased efficiency, improved data management, and a more organized work environment within Creo Parametric. The ability to quickly call out the number of instances in a point pattern on drawings would save time and reduce errors, ultimately leading to a more productive and seamless design process. Furthermore, by storing this information as a parameter, users can easily access and manipulate it across different files, ensuring consistency in their work.

Thank you to the user who suggested this idea for highlighting an area that could be improved within Creo Parametric. The ability to easily manage and call out the number of instances in a point pattern would greatly benefit users and streamline the design process. We appreciate your valuable input and continue to strive towards enhancing the functionality of our software for our customers' convenience.

 

Idea 652185 - Modelcheck: report errors/warnings in saved layer status (separately from displayed layer status). (Posted 4 years ago (Mar 03, 2020))

- Modelcheck: report errors/warnings in saved layer status (separately from displayed layer status). (Posted 4 years ago (Mar 03, 2020))

Current Problem or Limitation: In the current implementation of Creo Parametric's Modelcheck, users often encounter issues where the layer status reported during a check is the displayed layer status, not the saved one. This can lead to confusion and potential errors in the model if the user assumes that the layer settings are as they should be when saving, but they are not reflected correctly in the Modelcheck report.

Proposed Solution: The suggested solution aims to address this issue by introducing a separate check for the saved layer status. This would allow users to receive warnings or errors related to the settings saved with their model, ensuring that they have accurate information about the state of their layers. Referring to Article CS292759, this enhancement would help maintain the integrity and accuracy of models during the Modelcheck process.

Expected Benefits:

  • Improved accuracy in assessing the layer status of a Creo Parametric model, ensuring that users have correct information about their saved settings.
  • Reduced confusion and potential errors by providing separate reports for displayed and saved layer statuses.
  • Enhanced productivity as users can save time spent on manually checking the saved layer settings against the Modelcheck report.

Giving Thanks: A big thank you to the community member who suggested this idea (Posted 4 years ago (Mar 03, 2020)). Your insight is invaluable and helps make Creo Parametric a more efficient tool for all of us!

 

Idea 645706 - Function for freely rotating symbols (Posted 5 years ago (Jan 23, 2020))

- Function for freely rotating symbols (Posted 5 years ago (Jan 23, 2020))

Current Problem or Limitation: The user's current workflow involves using a note with a drag function to rotate its angle. However, when it comes to symbols, this functionality is not available, leading to a limitation in rotating symbols as per the desired orientation.

Proposed Solution: To address this issue, the user proposes implementing a rotation drag function that can be easily edited for symbols. This would enable users to rotate symbols freely without manual adjustments or additional workarounds, making it more efficient and convenient.

Expected Benefits: The implementation of this feature would allow users to have a consistent method for rotating both notes and symbols, increasing efficiency and reducing the need for manual adjustments. This would also improve the overall user experience by providing a more intuitive interface for working with symbols in Creo Parametric.

Thank you to the individual who suggested this idea! Their contribution has helped bring attention to an important aspect of Creo Parametric's functionality, and their ideas always help us strive towards making our software better.

 

Idea 638171 - Option to include quilts in offset section (Posted 5 years ago (Nov 26, 2019))

- Option to include quilts in offset section (Posted 5 years ago (Nov 26, 2019))

The current problem or limitation lies within the Creo Parametric software's offset section functionality. Specifically, when creating an offset section, users are unable to include quilts in the same way they can with planar sections. The user who suggested this idea points out that an 'Include quilts' mark is available in planar sections but not in offset sections. This discrepancy could potentially cause inconvenience and inefficiency for users who rely on the accurate representation of their models, particularly those involving quilts.

The proposed solution to this issue would be to make the 'Include quilts' option accessible within offset sections as well. This adjustment would ensure consistency between different section types and provide users with the flexibility to choose whether or not they want to include quilts in their offset sections.

The expected benefits of implementing this solution would be increased accuracy, efficiency, and user satisfaction when working with models that include quilts. Users could have faith that their models are being represented correctly across all section types without having to manually adjust them separately.

Lastly, I would like to extend my gratitude to the individual who took the time to suggest this valuable idea, contributing to the enhancement of Creo Parametric's functionality and overall user experience. By addressing these ideas and concerns, we can continue to foster a community-driven environment that prioritizes user feedback and improves our software.

 

Idea 632009 - Provide a way to set a "scale" for the initial feature sketch (Posted 5 years ago (Oct 17, 2019))

- The current problem or limitation lies in the lack of a precise and consistent method to set the initial size of a sketch when creating a new part model. This often results in users having to manually adjust their zoom level, which can be both subjective and imprecise. The proposed solution is to include an option for users to define an initial scale or zoom factor before starting a new sketch.

Expected benefits of this feature would be increased precision and efficiency when creating models as users will no longer need to manually adjust their viewport size before starting a new sketch. Additionally, it would provide a more standardized approach to model creation, reducing potential errors due to inconsistent zoom levels.

We appreciate the user who suggested this idea for bringing attention to this common challenge in Creo Parametric and providing a practical solution to improve the overall user experience. Although this feature may not have been implemented yet, it remains a valuable suggestion for future updates of the software.

 

Idea 626500 - ECAD_HOLE_PARAMETER default config option (Posted 5 years ago (Sep 12, 2019))

 - ECAD_HOLE_PARAMETER default config option (Posted 5 years ago (Sep 12, 2019))

Current Problem or Limitation: The current issue lies in the default value of the ecad mcad collaboration parameter ECAD_HOLE_PARAMETER, which is set to non-plated. This leads to additional manual adjustments for most mounting holes used in PCBs that require plating. These repetitive steps consume time and increase the risk of errors.

Proposed Solution: The suggested solution is to modify the default value for the ECAD_HOLE_PARAMETER parameter to be set as plated. This change will automatically configure mounting holes for PCBs as plated, eliminating the need for manual adjustments in most cases.

Expected Benefits: The proposed modification is expected to significantly reduce the time required for creating mounting holes for PCBs and minimize errors associated with manual adjustments. The changes will make the process more efficient and lead to improved product quality and reduced costs due to the reduction in labor hours.

Giving Thanks: We would like to express our gratitude to the individual who suggested this idea. Their insights have the potential to improve our workflow and contribute to increased efficiency in our design processes.

 

Idea 626126 - Option to draw rectangle in Sketch Tab of Creo Drawings (Posted 5 years ago (Sep 10, 2019))

- Option to draw rectangle in Sketch Tab of Creo Drawings (Posted 5 years ago (Sep 10, 2019))

Current Problem or Limitation: In the current version of Creo Parametric, users do not have the ability to directly draw rectangles within the Sketcher Tab when creating drawings. This limitation forces users to manually construct rectangles using line and corner tools, which can be time-consuming and inefficient, especially for complex drawing requirements.

Proposed Solution: Incorporate a dedicated tool or command within the Sketcher Tab for drawing rectangles quickly and easily. The rectangle feature should maintain consistent dimensions when moving, resizing, or rotating the shape. Additionally, it would be beneficial to include this functionality in the drawing symbols as well, allowing for more streamlined creation of standardized elements.

Expected Benefits:

  • Streamlined workflow and reduced time spent constructing rectangles and drawing symbols
  • Increased user efficiency and productivity when creating and editing drawings
  • Improved accuracy due to the ability to precisely define rectangle dimensions
  • Consistent formatting across multiple drawings by using a standard rectangle feature

Giving Thanks: Thank you to the user who suggested this idea. Your valuable input has helped identify a potential improvement in Creo Parametric that could enhance the overall user experience for many designers and engineers.

 

Idea 623235 - Enable Embedded Component Assemblies (Posted 5 years ago (Aug 21, 2019))

- Enable Embedded Component Assemblies (Posted 5 years ago (Aug 21, 2019))

Current Problem or Limitation: The user faces issues with managing large complex models, particularly in cases of robots, actuators, servos, etc., when they need to be downloaded and added to a custom design. These models often come with numerous supporting .PRT files, which can clutter the directories, especially when working with assembly models that have hundreds of such parts. Additionally, there are situations where these sub-parts need to be hidden or shown but not modified in any way.

Proposed Solution: The user suggests making it a standard permanent feature for Creo Parametric to enable Embedded Component Assemblies. This would allow an .ASM file to be saved as a Single file in the working directory, thereby keeping excess junk out of directories and maintaining clean and clutter-free design directories.

Expected Benefits: The implementation of this feature would streamline the management of large complex models by reducing the number of files in the directories. It would also make it easier to hide or show sub-parts without modifying them, as they would be contained within the single .ASM file. In turn, this would lead to improved organization, faster navigation, and better performance when working with large models.

Giving Thanks: Thank you to the person who suggested this idea for sharing their insights and contributing to making Creo Parametric a more efficient and user-friendly tool. Your ideas help us continue to improve and innovate.

 

Idea 615527 - Add probe function into Creo flow analysis (Posted 5 years ago (Jun 26, 2019))

- Add probe function into Creo flow analysis (Posted 5 years ago (Jun 26, 2019))

The original idea proposes the addition of a probe function in Creo Parametric's Flow Analysis module. In the current version, after simulations are completed and sections created to show contours of temperature or other variables such as velocity, pressure, etc., it would be beneficial to have a probe function to better analyze these results.

Currently, users can only see the contour plots of these variables across the model. However, having a probe function would allow for more targeted analysis by allowing users to select specific points within the model and obtain precise values of these variables at those points. This feature could greatly improve the efficiency and accuracy of post-processing steps in Creo Parametric's Flow Analysis module.

The expected benefits of this proposed solution are:

  1. Improved efficiency in data analysis by enabling targeted analysis of specific points within the model.
  2. Increased accuracy of results due to the ability to obtain precise values of variables at selected points.
  3. Enhanced understanding and interpretation of simulation results through the ability to probe multiple locations within the model.

Thanks to the user who suggested this idea for bringing attention to a feature that could greatly enhance Creo Parametric's Flow Analysis capabilities. This idea reflects a common need among users, demonstrating its relevance and potential impact on the Creo community.

 

Idea 614365 - Config option for Creo 6 option to make the drawing file name the same as the model name (Posted 5 years ago (Jun 17, 2019))

- Config option for Creo 6 option to make the drawing file name the same as the model name (Posted 5 years ago (Jun 17, 2019))

Current Problem or Limitation: In the current version of Creo Parametric, when creating a drawing from a part