Skip to main content
Feb 26, 2013 8:03 PM UTC
Alternate Solution

Remove the Ribbon

Related products:Creo Parametric

The ribbon interface makes users less productive than ever before.  It requires more time and mouse clicks to do the same operations than in previous versions, despite the propoganda put out by PTC.  The ribbon UI also eliminates the opportunity for users to utilize the innate human ability to spacially recognize objects.  Limited customization options and poor use of screen space compound the issue.  Leave bad UI implementation to Microsoft, do your own useability research and build a UI that works specifically for CAD users.

Above all, remove the ribbon from future releases of Creo.

27 replies

Feb 26, 2013 10:59 PM UTC

I second that.......VERY much so.

Feb 27, 2013 11:14 AM UTC

Hi guys,

I do not like the ribbon, but the experience shows, that many users work with it very efficient.

Proposal:

  • Create a mapkey for your daily work to close/open the ribbon.
  • Use the search functionality to reach your desired commands. (OK, there's still missing the navigation via keyboard 😞

Regards,

Joerg

Feb 27, 2013 2:40 PM UTC

The INEXPERIENCED users who have been spoon-fed that microsoft garbage seem to like it.  the advanced, highly-efficient users do not.

Feb 27, 2013 2:46 PM UTC

I fully agree ...but the question is how many users from which kind...

Feb 27, 2013 2:56 PM UTC

From a company productivity standpoint, I'd say do NOT punish your experienced, productive workers.  Also, by limiting the speed of ALL the users, the new ones can then never be as productive as the experienced ones USED to be.

I can tell you the ribbon causes me to need to have easily 2 to 4 times the times needed to make drawings.  This is unacceptable.

Feb 27, 2013 3:16 PM UTC

The main problem in the drawing mode is IMHO not the ribbon.

...and: we discuss about Creo 2, or?

Feb 27, 2013 3:58 PM UTC

To me it is.  I keep trying to select things, only to remember i can't, and have to go up to the stupid ribbon, find out what tab I should be in to do what I want, instead of just being able to DO it, like I had been used to for over 15 years now.  REALLY aggravating, and time-wasting.

Feb 27, 2013 4:03 PM UTC

Personally, I reduce the ribbon while working and use the search functionality and the context menus on RMB.

I miss the possibility to navigate through the search results via keyboard. That would reduce my time for clicking...

Feb 27, 2013 4:06 PM UTC

The RMB still does NOT bring back all the old functionality.  For me, it's a huge time-waster.  We used to have the power to pick anything, and do anything to it.  Now, we must first make sure we're in the right tab, then move the cursor to perform an operation, then go find the next tab, move the cursor, pick and perform the operation, then repeat this garbage endlessly.

Feb 27, 2013 4:13 PM UTC

The ribbon is quite customizable.  I've created my own ribbon tab.  This can be done for each file type (i.e., part, assembly, drawing, sheetmetal, etc.).  After about a month of customizing the various tabs I usually don't migrate away from my custom ribbon for any one file type.  When I do switch ribbon tabs is for commands I don't use frequently and wouldn't want to have there due to potential clutter.  Also I have created some mapkeys and created icons on the ribbon. 

Most importantly the is to much momentum in the GUI world in favor of ribbons that any level of response from users will not change it's implementation, and better to adapt than be left behind.

assembly.JPG

drawing.JPG

part.JPG